The Student Room Group

Thousands face Universal credit chaos this Christmas

With many facing chaos with this Univerisal Credit, what do you think of this system in general?https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/midlands-news/thousands-face-universal-credit-chaos-15332404

Scroll to see replies

Original post by John de turtle
Benefits should cover basic needs not Christmas presents.

People on low wages aren't allowed Christmas?

Ill people aren't allowed Christmas?

People between jobs aren't allowed Christmas?

All heart you are.
Original post by StriderHort
People on low wages aren't allowed Christmas?

Ill people aren't allowed Christmas?

People between jobs aren't allowed Christmas?

All heart you are.


It is not the role of the state to provide the latest toys and smart phones for spoilt kids.
If you want to celebrate Xmas earn the right to do so rather than leaching off taxpayers.
Original post by John de turtle
It is not the role of the state to provide the latest toys and smart phones for spoilt kids.
If you want to celebrate Xmas earn the right to do so rather than leaching off taxpayers.

Ah, Troll account, NM.
Original post by StriderHort
Ah, Troll account, NM.

Half-term. All the losers come out of the woodwork.
To any tight bastered who thinks that christmas is not the time to help those in need.. I would suggest you go and look at 2 things:

1, the nativity story (you know that quite fundimental part of christmas)
2, A christmas carrol

Arguably the 2 most influencial stories of christmas - both of which have helping others and being nice to those in need as quite a central theme.

---

If you don't want to help others at christmas - you don't really get what the season is about.
It is almost like these people reporting the 5-week gap haven't heard of the advance payment.
Original post by Notoriety
It is almost like these people reporting the 5-week gap haven't heard of the advance payment.

Tbh I've found it's closer to 6 or 7 weeks, assuming they pay on time, and the advance payment can be insultingly paltry. I have little doubt that part of the system has been designed to infuriate, everyone is near automatically put in rent arears. :frown:
Original post by StriderHort
Tbh I've found it's closer to 6 or 7 weeks, assuming they pay on time, and the advance payment can be insultingly paltry. I have little doubt that part of the system has been designed to infuriate, everyone is near automatically put in rent arears. :frown:

Paltry? It is 100% of your expected first UC payment.

5 weeks is typical.
Reply 9
Original post by StriderHort
Ah, Troll account, NM.


Doesn't sound like a troll account, rather one that doesn't see the need for everyone to buy presents when people already have enough.

Christmas shouldn't be about getting things. If you want to buy presents make them small and useful. Just enjoy time together, don't celebrate a holiday that is just about buying.
(edited 5 years ago)
Original post by Notoriety
Paltry? It is 100% of your expected first UC payment.

5 weeks is typical.

That isn't my experience with them, i've had 2 and neither was even half of full payment, not even a months rent in fact, and this was for straightforward claims with all documents provided. Likewise I've never seen a payment within 5 weeks, they also don't count the first 5 days of the claim either because 'waiting days' Whatever the hell they are.

Just checked DWP btw, 'The most you can get as an advance is the amount of your first estimated payment' is their words, no mention of that being what you get.
Original post by StriderHort
That isn't my experience with them, i've had 2 and neither was even half of full payment, not even a months rent in fact, and this was for straightforward claims with all documents provided. Likewise I've never seen a payment within 5 weeks, they also don't count the first 5 days of the claim either because 'waiting days' Whatever the hell they are.

Just checked DWP btw, 'The most you can get as an advance is the amount of your first estimated payment' is their words, no mention of that being what you get.

So you're talking about UC before they changed it. No more waiting days and advance payments are now 100% of first payment (if you choose them to be).

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/first-universal-credit-payment-paid-quicker

To repeat, people complaining have no idea what UC currently looks like and are fearmongering.
Original post by Notoriety
So you're talking about UC before they changed it. No more waiting days and advance payments are now 100% of first payment (if you choose them to be).

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/first-universal-credit-payment-paid-quicker

To repeat, people complaining have no idea what UC currently looks like and are fearmongering.

So you have no experience of receiving it, yet are lecturing someone who is on it about what it's really like...

Typical.
The cost of socialism is finally starting to catch up with society, it's going to get a lot worse.
Original post by BornBlue1
So you have no experience of receiving it, yet are lecturing someone who is on it about what it's really like...

Typical.

The point I was making is rather specific. The 5-week gap, which is much talked about, does not mean anything because you can get your full payment within the first assessment period as an interest-free loan spread over 12 months, and still get your first payment (minus the loan deduction). Meaning within the first 5 weeks you can get 200% (a little bit less) of what your first payment would be.

And if you don't like getting paid monthly, you can get alternative payment arrangements (APA, to be paid fortnightly usually) and you can also have your rent paid directly to your landlord (if either of you elects).

That user's experience is outdated. UC has not been like that for the past 8 months. So their experience is by no means superior to my own.
(edited 5 years ago)
Original post by Notoriety
The point I was making is rather specific. The 5-week gap, which is much talked about, does not mean anything because you can get your full payment within the first assessment period as an interest-free loan spread over 12 months, and still get your first payment (minus the loan deduction). Meaning within the first 5 weeks you can get 200% (a little bit less) of what your first payment would be.

And if you don't like getting paid monthly, you can get alternative payment arrangements (APA, to be paid fortnightly usually) and you can also have your rent paid directly to your landlord (if either of you elects).

That user's experience is outdated. UC has not been like that for the past 8 months. So their experience is by no means superior to my own.

But that's not how it's working in reality, clearly given the huge number of issues with the system which has prompted condemnation even from Conservative MPs.

You are focusing on how the system 'allegedly' works, not on how it actually does work. And dismissing the concerns and stories of people who are actually on UC when you aren't yourself, is quite hollow.
Original post by Notoriety
So you're talking about UC before they changed it. No more waiting days and advance payments are now 100% of first payment (if you choose them to be).

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/first-universal-credit-payment-paid-quicker

To repeat, people complaining have no idea what UC currently looks like and are fearmongering.


Fair enough, I wasn't aware of the changes. I wouldn't say i'm fearmongering though, that IS how they acted, can you blame me for forming an opinion based on my own experience with them?
Original post by StriderHort
Fair enough, I wasn't aware of the changes. I wouldn't say i'm fearmongering though, that IS how they acted, can you blame me for forming an opinion based on my own experience with them?

I was more speaking about the source in the OP. The people who have supposedly researched this. And the impact is surely to strike fear into the heart of anyone who might be transitioned to UC in the near future -- people who are no doubt anxious enough.

Original post by BornBlue1
But that's not how it's working in reality, clearly given the huge number of issues with the system which has prompted condemnation even from Conservative MPs.

You are focusing on how the system 'allegedly' works, not on how it actually does work. And dismissing the concerns and stories of people who are actually on UC when you aren't yourself, is quite hollow.

That user has admitted their experience is from before the UC reforms. See above.

There might be issues, but the 5-week gap is not one of them.
Original post by Notoriety
I was more speaking about the source in the OP. The people who have supposedly researched this. And the impact is surely to strike fear into the heart of anyone who might be transitioned to UC in the near future -- people who are no doubt anxious enough.


That user has admitted their experience is from before the UC reforms. See above.

There might be issues, but the 5-week gap is not one of them.

It clearly is, given how many applicants were short changed. Again, focus on how the system actually works, not on how it is supposed to.

Hence the condemnation of it across the political spectrum.

But again, its no surprise to see someone who's not on the scheme, lecture others who are...
(edited 5 years ago)
Original post by John de turtle
It is not the role of the state to provide the latest toys and smart phones for spoilt kids.
If you want to celebrate Xmas earn the right to do so rather than leaching off taxpayers.


Richard Branson pays no tax nor does his Virgin Healthcare company that made £200 million in profit from the NHS. Just saying! So who should we kick? The poorest in society?
(edited 5 years ago)

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending