girls how cheesy do you consider a guy writing a song for you? Watch
if you write songs like your typical X-Factor reject then nah best not bother
I mean the head boy in my school sang à song at assembly (he didn't write it though) to one of my friends.
It was so cute!
If not or it's an you're a mega creep. Most things in romantic films, if done in real life are super creepy.
I once had an ex turn up at 7am at my doorstep confessing her love for me and how wrong she had been during our entire relationship and promised she would change, wrote me a poem and gave me treats (I 'think' brownies, I may be wrong).... she thought it was hella romantic. *However* it was 7am.... I have to be at work for 8am, I live in the countryside in the middle of nowhere, she doesn't drive and got an uber there (and quick hint for you city slickers, you don't have ubers in most of the countryside, hell taxi's are hard enough!). She offered to stay at mine and wait for me to finish work but hell to the no for that!
My response? Incredibly creeped out, had to get her home at 7am before work (dropped her off at the local train station), pissed me off at the start of my day and I couldn't believe how thoughtless and inconsiderate she was.
Her response? Heartbroken on how I didn't appreciate how romantic she was and that it was proof I never really... deep down... cared for her. She's been moaning about stuff like that on her blog for months now and it just comes across incredibly creepy, self centred and immature.
A more relatable story, someone in our group of friends online (gaming clan) wrote a song for another girl in our group. She found it hella creepy because she wasn't interested in him at all. It also got out and something like 3-4 years later it still gets played over teamspeak and discord with people singing along and taking the micky. Not a bad song per se, just really weird when you think about it.
As long as the song is good-quality and not cheesy in itself, i think it is a great idea !