The Student Room Group

Am I the only one who thinks University rankings are unreliable?

Do you believe there's some bias with the rankings?
Original post by nvm787
Do you believe there's some bias with the rankings?


Show me someone who thinks they are reliable...
Original post by ageshallnot
Show me someone who thinks they are reliable...

I think they're reliable, especially the Guardians.
They reliably show what they say they do (except for the complete subject tables which have a different weighting applied to the published methodology).

That doesn’t mean that the universities at the top or bottom are good/bad. Just that they’re good/bad *at the metrics used and combined using that methodology*.

If you create a table of restaurants by number of chairs it won’t tell you which will serve the food you like best. But that doesn’t mean the Chair Table is an inaccurate ranking of chair numbers.
Original post by ···
I think they're reliable, especially the Guardians.


Sarcasm, I assume.
I don't know about their reliability, but I don't think so much emphasis should be put upon them. The ranking of a uni isn't the be all and end all
The league table compilers are advised by HESA on the titles to give different metrics. It’s not like they aren’t clear about what each metric is.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending