Scroll to see replies
•
Intuitionism
•
Naturalism
•
Emotivism
•
Empiricism - Verification Principle (influenced by Hume)
•
Religion - revelation, scripture
•
Hands - can be empirically verified
•
Starving child - an ethical statement
•
Maths - mathematical statement (duh)
•
Design Argument = indirect experience
•
A direct experience - thunder = "God is angry" (link to what Ayer said about this)
•
Design Argument = God's work, not directly controlled by God. Link to the Anthropic Principle
•
Kant - God is external, so can't be experienced (criticism of the Design Argument)
•
Swinburne - personal religious experience, eg personal revelations
•
Intuitionism
•
Design Argument
•
Religious experience
•
Link to Ayer - naming the divine being 'God' gives the concept meaning
•
Mysticism
•
Religious language - how do we know we are talking about God? Link to problems with symbolism, etc
•
Other reasons - independent thought
•
'Religious experience is not the founding of faith, but the product' - contrast with Schleiermacher
•
Religious symbolism
•
Kierkegaard - not a matter of whether God's will is right or wrong, it is simply God's will. Faith is the highest virtue
•
Kant - duties
•
Aquinas - precepts
•
Naturalism
•
Intuitionism
•
Emotivism
•
All these try to tell us what 'right' is
•
Discuss why he thinks intuition is weak - link to Ayer & empricism
•
Need empirical evidence to back up intuition - Ayer would say need empirical evidence alone
•
Analogy - particularly Aquinas
•
We have to trust; link to Kierkegaard - faith = highest virtue
•
Self-deception: Russell - man who eats little and sees God
•
Religious diversity - link to criticism of religious experience - if experience proves God's existence, are all relgions proved true? Do they not clash? Hume says yes
•
Analogy - "John is good" is not the same as "God is good" - allows us to get close to God without claiming to be completely correct
•
Falsification Principle - "Death of a thousand qualifications - even though we cannot know whether intuition gives us knowledge, people will still claim it does
•
Link the end of the paragraph to religious language - interpretation of God
•
Great place to reference Anti-Realism - "I know he lives - he lives within my heart"
•
Dawkins - such 'faith claims' hinder scientific investigation - why bother proving God's existence if you just know God exists in your heart?
•
Falsification Principle - Death of a thousand qualifications links in well with Dawkins' idea
•
Wittgenstein
•
Give examples of claims of God's existence based on direct religious experience - mysticism, Swinburne's categories of religious experience, etc
•
Experience means we know 'about' you, but we do not know 'you
•
Buber - I-It and I-You. Describe what these mean
•
Ways of personal contact with God - prayer, numinous, etc
•
Mysticism. Simone Weil - desciribing it in normal language would make it lose it's meaning, eg 'God is love' doesn't mean the same thing for different people
•
Vicious Circle - people see what they are brought up/conditioned to see
•
This is the problem of analogy - how do we know the analogy is correct?
•
Kant - God is external to the world, so we can't (or Kant) know
•
I'm sorry about that last pun
•
Swinburne - Principles of Credulity & Testimony
•
Falsification Principle (duh)
•
John Wisdom's Parable Of The Gardner
•
Subjectivism & cultural relativism
•
These relations are not scientific, so counters Dawkins'/Ayer's ideas
•
Melvin Tinker's criticism of Dawkins - "ontological reductionism"; that is, he tries to reduce everything to scientific terms, thinks everything has to be scientifically proven, when they are in fact, as was previously mentioned, incommensurable
•
Believers go for I-You over I-It because they feel they already know about God - they know how to talk of God due to language games
•
It is hard to talk of God in terms of I-It, since God is meant to be more than that
•
Kant - no way of talking of God anyway
•
Language games - we have to know that God = 'creator', 'judge', 'father of Chris (and indeed of humanity)', etc
•
Ayer - religious language is meaningless (say why he thinks this)
•
If one does have an I-It relationship with God, then it is a Vicious Circle (since our 'knowledge about' God may be based on language games)
•
Could be argued that first-hand knowledge provides empirical verification
•
Ayer - does it always provide this? He would say religious claims do not
•
Others would say miracles & Design Argument are first-hand and empirically verified
•
Pregnancy (paragraph 3) - similar to how a conversion deeply affects a person (esp. Self-Surrender conversions (eg sudden conversions due to an experience))
•
Religious experience doesn't mean you know something, just that you experienced something
•
Ayer would thus say that it is meangingless - "just an insight into one's own mind"
•
Ayer's attack on mysticism
•
Vardy - religious experience does not stand up philosophically speaking
•
Weaknesses of religious experience - how do we know it's God? Other reasons for it, eg just our brains? etc
•
Kierkegaard - "faith is the highest virtue"
•
Schleiermacher - often the foundation of belief
•
Once more, how do we know this sense is right? Analogy
•
Dawkins - assuming they are right hinders scientific investigation
•
Kant - God is external, so such assumptions are fallacious
•
Anti-Realism - if one senses God is real, then God is real for oneself
•
Hume - can't reason something into existence or non-existence, so thinking God exists doesn't make it so
•
Who decides what God is like, and how do we know if this is correct? - Guess what? You can use analogy here!
•
Someone's experience that this knowledge of God is based upon may in fact be a product of faith - issue of Vicious Circle
Last reply 20 minutes ago
OCR A-level Religious Studies Paper 1 (H573/01) - 10th June 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 2 hours ago
any updates on what the guest password is for philosphy cat ?Last reply 8 hours ago
GCSE Religious Studies Study Group 2023-2024Last reply 1 day ago
AQA GCSE Religious Studies Paper 1 (8062/ 11-17) - 15th May 2023 [Exam Chat]Last reply 2 days ago
OCR A-level Religious Studies Paper 3 (Christianity) - 20th June 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 1 week ago
How to get A* in a level ocr religous studiesLast reply 2 weeks ago
A-level Philosophy Study Group 2023-2024Last reply 2 weeks ago
AQA A GCSE Religious Studies Paper 2 (8062/ 2A and 2B) - 23rd May 2023 [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 weeks ago
WJEC GCSE Religious Studies Paper 1 | 15th May 2023 [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 weeks ago
Aqa a level philosophy and ethics (rs) paper 2 christianity and dialogues 2023Last reply 3 weeks ago
OCR A-level Religious Studies Paper 2 (H573/02) - 17th June 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 weeks ago
Religious studies a level EduqasLast reply 4 weeks ago
Can someone please mark my GCSE AQA Religious studies 12 marker :)Last reply 2 months ago
Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies Paper 1 | 15th May 2023 [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 months ago
Eduqas religious studies a level 2023Last reply 20 minutes ago
OCR A-level Religious Studies Paper 1 (H573/01) - 10th June 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 2 hours ago
any updates on what the guest password is for philosphy cat ?Last reply 8 hours ago
GCSE Religious Studies Study Group 2023-2024Last reply 1 day ago
AQA GCSE Religious Studies Paper 1 (8062/ 11-17) - 15th May 2023 [Exam Chat]Last reply 2 days ago
OCR A-level Religious Studies Paper 3 (Christianity) - 20th June 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 1 week ago
How to get A* in a level ocr religous studiesLast reply 2 weeks ago
A-level Philosophy Study Group 2023-2024Last reply 2 weeks ago
AQA A GCSE Religious Studies Paper 2 (8062/ 2A and 2B) - 23rd May 2023 [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 weeks ago
WJEC GCSE Religious Studies Paper 1 | 15th May 2023 [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 weeks ago
Aqa a level philosophy and ethics (rs) paper 2 christianity and dialogues 2023Last reply 3 weeks ago
OCR A-level Religious Studies Paper 2 (H573/02) - 17th June 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 weeks ago
Religious studies a level EduqasLast reply 4 weeks ago
Can someone please mark my GCSE AQA Religious studies 12 marker :)Last reply 2 months ago
Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies Paper 1 | 15th May 2023 [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 months ago
Eduqas religious studies a level 2023