Rank the post-war PMs from best to worst Watch

theeetimdoherty
Badges: 15
Rep:
?
#1
Report Thread starter 1 week ago
#1
Rank the post-war PMs from best to worst, giving reasons.

I'll start:
1) Attlee, for implementing the welfare state.
2) Thatcher, for fixing the unions and showing actual leadership. Many of her policies were terrible tho and she was lucky thanks to North Sea oil and Falkland Islands).
3) Macmillan, for taking initiative in decolonisation and on joining the EEC (tho he did support Suez).

The rest weren't particularly successful:
3) Churchill because he was okay despite hiding strokes from public. Just did nuclear weapons and allowed society to move foreward without his conservatism standing in the way, though he let an unwell Eden come to office.
4) Blair, because although he did nothing to prevent the 2007 financial crisis. The Iraq war was embarassing and immoral.
5) Wilson, because the only good things during his time weren't creditable to him (social liberalisation goes to Roy Jenkins, technological advance was in the making before he came to office) and the bad things were (devaluation was entirely his fault, and his refusal to abandon the US-GBP exchange rate peg made him a slave to the US, he was also terrible at industrial relations).
6) Heath, because he would have been great if he had stood up to the unions. He wanted union reform but couldn't after there was outcry against unemployment hitting a million.
7) John Major, haven't studied him yet but I know he served through Black Wednesday and the economy was meh. I'm not sure if he made any real change.
8) Eden, because he was delirious to attack Egypt. It literally led to the collapse of Western influence in the Middle East, he was out of tune with the new post-colonial world. Plus Nasser hadn't actually threatened to block the Suez Canal and he was forced to nationalise because the Americans withdrew funds from the Aswan Dam, and he couldn't break his promise to his people. He was also against joining Europe at a time when de Gaulle wouldn't have blocked British entry.

I won't rank Callaghan, Brown or May because they all served during extreme circumstances which were beyond their control. I won't rank Home because his time in office was short and uneventful.
1
reply
Napp
Badges: 22
Rep:
?
#2
Report 1 week ago
#2
Cameron and May as the worst for obvious reasons with Blair not too far behind for besmirching our name in Iraq simply to fellate that prized prat Bush.
I imagine Johnson will soon be joining the list of ignominy though.
1
reply
theeetimdoherty
Badges: 15
Rep:
?
#3
Report Thread starter 1 week ago
#3
(Original post by Napp)
Cameron and May as the worst for obvious reasons with Blair not too far behind for besmirching our name in Iraq simply to fellate that prized prat Bush.
I imagine Johnson will soon be joining the list of ignominy though.
Oh yeah I forgot about Cameron. Austerity didn't even work and he just led us into Brexit, he is probably the worse second only to Anthony Eden
1
reply
Rakas21
Badges: 21
Rep:
?
#4
Report 1 week ago
#4
1) Thatcher - Destroyed militant unionism, lowered taxes for the majority of ordinary people, gave millions the Right To Buy. Oversaw the Lawson boom of 84-91. Took back the Falklands and sunk the Belgrano.

2) Blair - Destroyed the left in his party by forcing them to adopt the Thatcherite consensus. Gave BOE independence. Brought in the minimum wage. Maintained Tory spending plans until 01. Invaded Afghanistan and Iraq and Sierra Lionne and Kosovo.

3) Major - Continued the Thatcherite consensus. Invaded Iraq and freed Kuwait. Recession early on was avoidable but ultimately the buck stops with Thatcher for being PM when we entered ERM.

4) MacMillan - The best of an uninspiring bunch between 45-79. Oversaw a massive expansion of social housing (even for working people). Oversaw strong economic growth.

5) Cameron - Maintained a coalition for the full 5 years (we see in other states how difficult that can be), oversaw a falling deficit, falling unemployment and reasonable growth from 2013. Oversaw air strikes in Iraq and Libya. Oversaw the greatest changes to education since the 80’s.

..

6) Attlee - Overrated because most of what he did was discussed in the national government and so would have been done by Churchill anyway. In addition people are somewhat selective in that the original welfare state was not like todays, unmarried mothers for example were feckless and sent to charities. He did at least continue the nuclear programme and fought the Korean War. He is no doubt be spitting in his grave at the modern lefts naive lack of patriotism.

7) Churchill - Continued the post WW2 consensus. Oversaw strong economic growth.

..

8) Heath - Oversaw our entry into the Common Market which in hindsight was a bad move given our links to the Commonwealth were sacrificed. Accomplished little of note and cowed to the unions.

9) May - Despite her Steps Of Downing Street Speech being pornographic she became a victim of her electoral failing and lacking the resolve to leave the EU when she said she would. Failed on the dominant issue of the day.

10) Callaghan - Changed social housing rules to limit the number of working people. A disastrous policy responsible for the Ghettos of the 80’s and 90’s. Accomplished little else due to little to no majority.

11) Brown - Possibly the most unlucky PM in timing, he became PM just months before the Banking Crisis blew up. Accomplished nothing as a result beyond avoiding being knifed.

12) Wilson - Accomplished little, was suspected of being a Republican and having Soviet sympathies. Has more in common with Corbyn than Attlee.

13) Eden - Capitulated to the US at Suez marking the end of any hope of maintaining hegemony.

..

I chose not to judge Alex Douglas Home since he was only PM for a year.
1
reply
Napp
Badges: 22
Rep:
?
#5
Report 1 week ago
#5
(Original post by Rakas21)

11) Brown - Possibly the most unlucky PM in timing, he became PM just months before the Banking Crisis blew up. Accomplished nothing as a result beyond avoiding being knifed.
In fairness he did manage the crash quite well, or at least as well as can be expected
0
reply
X

Quick Reply

Attached files
Write a reply...
Reply
new posts

All the exam results help you need

1,884

people online now

225,530

students helped last year
Latest
My Feed

See more of what you like on
The Student Room

You can personalise what you see on TSR. Tell us a little about yourself to get started.

Personalise

How are you feeling about GCSE Results Day?

Hopeful (214)
12.56%
Excited (156)
9.15%
Worried (306)
17.96%
Terrified (379)
22.24%
Meh (165)
9.68%
Confused (37)
2.17%
Putting on a brave face (234)
13.73%
Impatient (213)
12.5%

Watched Threads

View All