The Student Room Logo

The Big 'Which Cambridge College?' Thread

Scroll to see replies

Original post by Athena
Here - but that's just for graduates.


Don't worry, I too am mental enough to continue study. :tongue:
Reply 2261
Hi, thanks for posting this discussion group. I just got pooled into Murray Edwards (New Hall) and I'm seriously considering not going.
But before you label me as shallow or superficial; my issue isn't based on the false preconceptions that people have about an all-girls college and about there not being any guys around or whatever. It's an ideological concern, it honestly strikes me that these kind of colleges still exist in our times, where women don't need that extra help to get into university like they did in the 50's. It's old-fashioned and feels like a protective little bubble that separates you from the real world. Also, I fail to understand how such environment is supportive to women - to me, having all-girls colleges but not even one all-men college is diminishing and suggests that we are weaker competitors and would fail to excel in a mixed environment.

However, if I can find one logical answer to why these colleges still exist today I will definitely re-consider.
It doesn't increase your chances at all. Yes, they are less popular and less people apply, but if you can't 'make the cut' then you won't get an offer. They won't hand out offers to everybody just because they have places to fill. And they have the pooling system so some people who don't get into their first choice of college might get an all-girls offer, even if they didn't apply.
Original post by NK2009
Hi, thanks for posting this discussion group. I just got pooled into Murray Edwards (New Hall) and I'm seriously considering not going.
But before you label me as shallow or superficial; my issue isn't based on the false preconceptions that people have about an all-girls college and about there not being any guys around or whatever. It's an ideological concern, it honestly strikes me that these kind of colleges still exist in our times, where women don't need that extra help to get into university like they did in the 50's. It's old-fashioned and feels like a protective little bubble that separates you from the real world. Also, I fail to understand how such environment is supportive to women - to me, having all-girls colleges but not even one all-men college is diminishing and suggests that we are weaker competitors and would fail to excel in a mixed environment.

However, if I can find one logical answer to why these colleges still exist today I will definitely re-consider.


Although it's not the only factor as to why they have them, some people prefer single sex collages for religious reasons. But whatever, just wanted to point that out :smile:
Reply 2264
Original post by Rosie0914
I decided to rep you for this post because it was brilliantly thought out and well presented.

Seriously, I have been on open days and people constantly try to play the numbers game. I went on one open day and there was this boy who I was chatting to and he had been to four course open days just to find out the application stats for each subject. It really annoyed me because you should pick a subject you're passionate about, not the one you're most likely to be able to study at Cambridge. Same with colleges, you should pick the one you feel is suited to you, not the one you thik will take you on.



Anyway, going to a single sex college would not be my preference, but I would certainly not turn down Cambridge if they offered me a place through the pool.


You've never heard of the 'back door route'? This is how it works: apply for an easy suject like ASNAC or arch and anth, get in, make a song and dance to your tutor about being unhappy, and voila, you transfer to the course of your choice. These easy courses have like 4 applicants for 5 places etc, you get what I'm trying to say.

I know a couple of people at my sixth form who did it - it was pretty clear since they originally planned to apply for things like english, then suddenly changed to arch and anth. Not to mention their GCSEs were pretty rubbish, as were their AS levels.

But yeah, it is frustrating for those who apply the normal way without getting all sneaky about it.

Original post by LauriC
Although it's not the only factor as to why they have them, some people prefer single sex collages for religious reasons. But whatever, just wanted to point that out :smile:


There should be no single sex colleges at all.
Reply 2265
Hi, any one can tell me something about Jesus college?
I'm going to study engineeing there but i was fished so donno much abt it.
Original post by Spaz Man
Ilford County High Sixth Form

or

Seven Kings Sixth Form

or

Beale Sixth Form

Need to choose between the three. If anyone has pros and cons then that would be total awesomeness :biggrin:


I'm definitely applying for Ilford County High School :smile:
Reply 2267
Original post by Amy Luo
Hi, any one can tell me something about Jesus college?
I'm going to study engineeing there but i was fished so donno much abt it.


They are teh worst college ever and I hate them. Then again I might be biased because I applied there for engineering, got pooled and sent to a different college. Guess they took you instead of me :tongue:

Nah its a great college, wish I had got in :frown:
Reply 2268
Original post by Plutoegg
They are teh worst college ever and I hate them. Then again I might be biased because I applied there for engineering, got pooled and sent to a different college. Guess they took you instead of me :tongue:

Nah its a great college, wish I had got in :frown:


haha, that's like what i think about Churchill!:tongue:
but the offer is quite high tho.
Can you tell me the reason you chose there ? have you been there before?
Reply 2269
Original post by LauriC
Although it's not the only factor as to why they have them, some people prefer single sex collages for religious reasons. But whatever, just wanted to point that out :smile:


I understand that some people may prefer them for religious reasons, that's quite reasonable. But what other factors are you talking about?
Original post by NK2009
I understand that some people may prefer them for religious reasons, that's quite reasonable. But what other factors are you talking about?


Their personal preferance, whether or not they feel comfortable etc. But I left them out because I think it's much harder to justify that.
Reply 2271
Hi everyone! I've got a PGCE interview at Cambridge in March and am trying to narrow down my college options. I went to visit yesterday, but didn't have time to view all of the colleges so feel free to suggest any alternatives.

Things that are important to me:
*Accommodation: I'd prefer a single, ensuite room in reasonably priced college accommodation. My schedule will be all wacky and I'll be on even more of a crazy schedule since I'll be doing a long-distance relationship with my husband and I don't want to keep housemates up with my talking to him at silly hours, etc. And if it's at all possible to live on-site at a pretty college with a nice view, that would be wonderful (though admittedly a pipedream)!

*Proximity to the education department. I'm fine to cycle or get a bus from a college in the centre, but it has to be easily accessible.

*Lively grad community (both in terms of socializing and research). I'm Oxford right now, and my college has a really small MCR with few events and no research agenda. I'd love to be at a college that brought in big speakers, had lots of opportunities to meet new people, etc.

*Perks. Some Oxford colleges offer much better facilities like free printing, free laundry, free coffee machine use and heavily subsidized meals and accommodation. Does any Cambridge college have a reputation for having lots of perks?

My thoughts so far:
Homerton is the most popular choice for education students and also where most of my lectures will be if I'm accepted. Didn't get the chance to visit since it was so far out, but I'm going for a dinner there in Feb. so I'll at least be able to see it before the interview. The biggest drawback is that they're all out of PGCE accommodation.

Hughes Hall guarantees PGCE accommodation, but when I went to visit I just couldn't picture myself living there. I've heard negative things from other Cambridge students, so I'll probably rule it out? The only thing keeping it in the running is the fact that it's recommended as a second choice by the education department and has a good PGCE community.

I really liked Downing College! It's so spacious, and not too far from the education department. They also offer 50% of postgrad students on-site accommodation. It's my number 1 choice at the moment, but I've heard the facilities aren't great (bar isn't fun, meals are expensive, etc.). Can anyone else weigh in with pros and cons?

Corpus Christi was also gorgeous and their graduate housing complex is really interesting. Anyone have any more info on the pros and cons of the Leckhampton site? Seems to have the whole tight-knit community, research thing going on but it's weird that it's not on the main site. There are also few single ensuite rooms.

I also really liked St John's, but they don't offer accommodation on-site and their grad accommodation is all hostels.

Any help would be much appreciated!
Original post by tem11
Hi everyone! I've got a PGCE interview at Cambridge in March and am trying to narrow down my college options. I went to visit yesterday, but didn't have time to view all of the colleges so feel free to suggest any alternatives.

Things that are important to me:
*Accommodation: I'd prefer a single, ensuite room in reasonably priced college accommodation. My schedule will be all wacky and I'll be on even more of a crazy schedule since I'll be doing a long-distance relationship with my husband and I don't want to keep housemates up with my talking to him at silly hours, etc. And if it's at all possible to live on-site at a pretty college with a nice view, that would be wonderful (though admittedly a pipedream)!

*Proximity to the education department. I'm fine to cycle or get a bus from a college in the centre, but it has to be easily accessible.

*Lively grad community (both in terms of socializing and research). I'm Oxford right now, and my college has a really small MCR with few events and no research agenda. I'd love to be at a college that brought in big speakers, had lots of opportunities to meet new people, etc.

*Perks. Some Oxford colleges offer much better facilities like free printing, free laundry, free coffee machine use and heavily subsidized meals and accommodation. Does any Cambridge college have a reputation for having lots of perks?

My thoughts so far:
Homerton is the most popular choice for education students and also where most of my lectures will be if I'm accepted. Didn't get the chance to visit since it was so far out, but I'm going for a dinner there in Feb. so I'll at least be able to see it before the interview. The biggest drawback is that they're all out of PGCE accommodation.

Hughes Hall guarantees PGCE accommodation, but when I went to visit I just couldn't picture myself living there. I've heard negative things from other Cambridge students, so I'll probably rule it out? The only thing keeping it in the running is the fact that it's recommended as a second choice by the education department and has a good PGCE community.

I really liked Downing College! It's so spacious, and not too far from the education department. They also offer 50% of postgrad students on-site accommodation. It's my number 1 choice at the moment, but I've heard the facilities aren't great (bar isn't fun, meals are expensive, etc.). Can anyone else weigh in with pros and cons?

Corpus Christi was also gorgeous and their graduate housing complex is really interesting. Anyone have any more info on the pros and cons of the Leckhampton site? Seems to have the whole tight-knit community, research thing going on but it's weird that it's not on the main site. There are also few single ensuite rooms.

I also really liked St John's, but they don't offer accommodation on-site and their grad accommodation is all hostels.

Any help would be much appreciated!


I don't know anything about postgrad (being an undergrad myself!) but I don't think the food is that expensive. Our formals are a bit more expensive than other colleges, but the food is amazing and obviously they're optional. Evening meals are reasonably priced and we tend to get a good choice everyday :smile:

The bar is one of the cheapest student bars and I always find it pretty fun, although it can get quite packed (especially if there's an ent on).

As for other facilities, we've got lots of sports stuff, like tennis courts and a gym etc and I know there's a music room with a piano anyone can use.

If you have anymore general questions, feel free to ask me :biggrin:
What are the best colleges for computer science ?
Reply 2274
Original post by ExplosiveSam
What are the best colleges for computer science ?


I would say Churchill is the best, the most competitive for CompSci, it has the highest student intake each year. You can also try Trinity.
Original post by ExplosiveSam

Original post by ExplosiveSam
What are the best colleges for computer science ?


Yes, most computer scientists apply to Churchill probably partly because they give the most offers for the subject. But really, you'll be going to the same lectures so there's little real difference. I wouldn't concentrate too much on choosing a college based on the subject you want to study but on other things.
Reply 2276
Original post by ExplosiveSam
What are the best colleges for computer science ?


No such thing.

You learn the same things, regardless of college.

It's all about which college you think you'll fit best in to.
Original post by n_251
No such thing.

You learn the same things, regardless of college.

It's all about which college you think you'll fit best in to.


This. But at the same time if you're a lazy bastard who finds it hard to get up for a 9am lecture then perhaps the 'best' college would be whichever is nearest your department. Cambridge may be a small town but I'd guess that extra minute in bed might well be worth it :biggrin: And all the other stuff like atmosphere, feel, big college small college, their sports/music/other facilities etc.
Hey everyone

I'm thinking of applying to Cambridge for MML (German and Spanish) for 2012, but I'm struggling to narrow down my college choices! I know I've got a while yet before I have to make my decision though.

I'd rather not make an open application because I don't really want to go to one of the all-girls' colleges.

My short list (at the moment - it keeps changing!:biggrin:) is:

St Catharine's

Emmanuel

Corpus Christi

Girton



With the exception of Girton, I'm thinking about these because I want to be near the centre of Cambridge so that I can get to Sidgewick and also the shops/bars etc quite quickly. I went to Girton for the Shadowing Scheme last week and loved it, so I'd feel a bit disloyal if I didn't consider it :tongue:

Rent is going to be a pretty big issue - I'm looking for something around the £50 - 60 per week mark. Emma having free laundry service is a massive plus!

Is there anything else I need to think about when I choose a college? Which would you choose of these four?

Sorry for the mammoth post!
Anyone know any good colleges for History of Art with en suite rooms?

Quick Reply

Latest

Latest