The Student Room Logo

The Big 'Which Cambridge College?' Thread

Scroll to see replies

Original post by Tortious
There's nothing to stop you wandering around Trinity as a student - you're free to come and go as you please. An advantage of Ed's is that it probably doesn't have even half as many tourists. :biggrin:


Hehe I like the sound of that. Mind, King's would have been the first choice if they'd bothered to offer Land Economy but yeah wandering around doesn't sound like a bad idea.

Frankly I am now swaying towards St Edmund's. I've managed to get a hold of the "two references" they're asking for and in an email they sent me they said qualifications I have would make me a "very strong candidate" so I wonder if maybe that should be enough to sway me?

Trinity on the other hand whilst saying they accept my qualifications state that they only accept about 1 or 2 mature students a year and receive around 60 applications annually from mature students and described the competition as such as being "severe". So I wonde rif my chances of getting an interview/offer would be better with St Edmund's where they obviously have a greater capacity to accommodate mature students or battle it out amongst 60-odd other mature students for the one spot at Trinity?

I was keen on St John's but they don't seem to have responded to me and neither have Sidney Sussex who I was also keen on :frown:

But yeah I have to say it's looking increasingly like St Edmund's.
Reply 2961
Does anyone know what the homerton economics "test at interview" involves and can possibly give me some example questions?
Reply 2962
I think Caius is a good choice. They admit quite a few economics students, they have a lot of money so can get good supervisors, and they don't do the TSA for admissions. Plus it looks nice and it's central.

The only downside is, from my experience, the economists at Caius are quite a weird bunch.
Original post by The Mr Z
That's where you're wrong - there doesn't have to be any way for the school to distinguish who gets to apply where. Not only is it completely irrelevant how many people from the same school apply to each college, but if they had to be separated it should only ever be by mutual convenience.

UMS are far from objective when considered alone, without all the obvious unknowns like personal statements, BMAT for medics, and interview performance.

And clearly the other person has chosen a different college, so they were happy not choosing that college. Or are you saying you've been rather a bully?


That's not what we were told - and anyway I was quite happy to let us both apply.

It was my UCAS coordinator who persuaded him to change. She said based on his UMS and 'applicant profile' (whatever that means) he should reconsider, and he went for another i think.
Reply 2964
For English:

Clare, Trinity Hall or Gonville and Caius?

Clare is the one I'm most leaning towards, but it's the most competitive for English :frown:
Hi all,

I can't decide between Fitzwilliam and Murray Edwards.
I was wondering if any of you can give me some extra information about both?

I would prefer an en-suite room if possible, what are the chances of getting one at Fitz (I was told all freshers have one at ME)?

I will probably do quite a bit of self catering, so decent cooking facilities would be a plus. In saying that, I will also use the catered option when I need to but I am quite fussy and so would like lots of good choices.
I have read that the food at Fitz is not very good, can anyone say why?
Also, the internet charges at Fitz are a little confusing, how does this work? Are there any additional charges at ME?

I have visited both of these colleges, Fitz on an open day, and Murray Edwards on an individual tour.
I don't really have any negatives about Murray Edwards but I didn't really get a feel for the college atmosphere the same as when I visited Fitz (due to not many people being around).

They are both brilliant colleges and I just can't decide between them!
I have 4 days before my college internal deadline for UCAS

Please help me to sort through these last minute niggles!!
Thank you!
Right I made my decision. I've decided to go for............................. St Edmund's. I gave it some thought and when all's considered I.e. facilities, atmosphere, chances of getting an interview, chances of an offer etc. I think St Edmund's is my best choice. Besides if I get I'll no doubt visit Trinity either way it's Cambridge I'd happily sleep in a cardboard box outside senate house if it meant I'd be a student there and get a Cambridge degree. Good luck to everyone applying.
what is the most competative one for medicine? is it Caius?
Original post by elljay
Hello :smile:

I'm applying for Cambridge this year for English and I'm having a hard time deciding which college I want to go for. I've narrowed it down to two main choices - Emmanuel and Clare - but I'm also still considering Corpus Christi, Pembroke, Gonville and Caius, Trinity.

I'm really basing my choice on location, atmosphere and aesthetics, and I'm not going to try any tactics in terms of which college I'm most likely to get into. The reason I love Clare is because it's right next to the river and in a really pretty area. It's also quite close to the Sidgwick Site, which (if I'm not completely wrong) is where the English faculty is? I love Emmanuel because it has absolutely beautiful grounds.

I was wondering if anyone could tell me what these colleges are like in terms of atmosphere:

- Is the community quite close-knit?
- Are there a disproportionate number of arts/science students?
- Are they notoriously 'rah-ish' or pretentious?
- Are they quiet during exam time or generally quite touristy?
- Most importantly, is the environment hugely pressured? I was at the Oxford open day with a friend on Friday, and one of the tutors was saying that some colleges there drive their students to achieve much more (Merton was the main example) whereas others are more relaxed, which I would prefer. Is this also the case at Cambridge? Obviously I know that there will be pressure at all colleges, but I don't really want to apply for a college with a reputation for it. The fact that both Emmanuel and Clare are consistently near the top of the Tompkins table made me worry that they might fall into that category.

Also, what are the various college societies like? Can you join the societies of colleges of which you're not a student?

Sorry for the essay, any advice would be much appreciated!


I'm applying for English too! For me it was very close between Clare and Pembroke but I choose Pembroke in the end because it seems more 'homey' :smile:
After much stalking of all the Cambridge college websites I have made the following observations: :tongue:

-Emmanuel/Clare/Trinity are very popular
-Clare is 'the' English college, but I doubt this means its actually better for English, just that they take a lot of people for English/Lots of competition for places
- All the ones you are considering are beautiful
- Trinity is massive and very touristy but I also think its the most visually stunning
- Pembroke has the best food:biggrin:
- Apparently Pembroke is very quite at exam time
- Clare/Emmanuel have a rep for being the friendly colleges, no idea how true this is?
- Trinity/Clare have awesome libraries
- Regarding work ethic/pressure I have no idea I was wondering the answer to this myself :smile:

I think ultimately go somewhere where you feel comfortable, good luck :tongue:
Reply 2969
Original post by AspiringGenius
what is the most competative one for medicine? is it Caius?

Not really, it varies pretty wildly from year to year, plus its hard to say for certain because of the effect pooling has on admissions. But this year, the college with the highest applicants : offer ratio was Pembroke.

Stats are here. I would take them with a pinch of salt though, since they don't really paint the full picture. Knowing the subtle differences in the admissions requirements/process between colleges is probably more useful.
Original post by AspiringGenius
what is the most competative one for medicine? is it Caius?


You can check the numbers on the website, it used to be under "Undergraduate Admissions".
Original post by SabreT
Not really, it varies pretty wildly from year to year, plus its hard to say for certain because of the effect pooling has on admissions. But this year, the college with the highest applicants : offer ratio was Pembroke.

Stats are here. I would take them with a pinch of salt though, since they don't really paint the full picture. Knowing the subtle differences in the admissions requirements/process between colleges is probably more useful.


Thanks, :smile:
Reply 2972
Original post by oreo-cookies
Hi all,

I can't decide between Fitzwilliam and Murray Edwards.
I was wondering if any of you can give me some extra information about both?

I would prefer an en-suite room if possible, what are the chances of getting one at Fitz (I was told all freshers have one at ME)?

I will probably do quite a bit of self catering, so decent cooking facilities would be a plus. In saying that, I will also use the catered option when I need to but I am quite fussy and so would like lots of good choices.
I have read that the food at Fitz is not very good, can anyone say why?
Also, the internet charges at Fitz are a little confusing, how does this work? Are there any additional charges at ME?

I have visited both of these colleges, Fitz on an open day, and Murray Edwards on an individual tour.
I don't really have any negatives about Murray Edwards but I didn't really get a feel for the college atmosphere the same as when I visited Fitz (due to not many people being around).

They are both brilliant colleges and I just can't decide between them!
I have 4 days before my college internal deadline for UCAS

Please help me to sort through these last minute niggles!!
Thank you!


That applies to pretty much every college at the university.

As for which college, you have to ask yourself, do you really want to go to an all girls college?
Reply 2973
I'm thinking of applying the second time for Natural Sciences (Physical) at Cambridge and I was wondering if anyone knows which colleges are the most and the less competitive for this course, because I'm having a hard time picking out a college.

Also for those of you who applied a second time for uni: do I need to write a new personal statement? I haven't done much the past year due to exams and the first one seems perfect to me ( I kind of poured my heart out there :smile: )

Can't wait to hear your answers :smile:
Reply 2974
I'm applying for Engineering and is considering between Downing, Jesus and Pembroke. Are they good for Engineering? Please give me some adivce.:smile:
Original post by melts
I'm applying for Engineering and is considering between Downing, Jesus and Pembroke. Are they good for Engineering? Please give me some adivce.:smile:


In short, they're no "better" than each other, since all of the teaching is organised through the Faculty. Choose your college based on which one you feel suits you best. :h:
Is there much difference between different medical schools?
I'm having a hard time picking a college for NatSci (Physical) and my school has now set a 7th October internal deadline for those applying to Cambridge or Oxford. Are there any which have a lot of en-suite accommodation? As I'd prefer this at least for the first year. Help is appreciated :smile:
Reply 2978
Not a huge amount of difference. Maybe Trinity. It might be worth looking at the individual DoS you'd have and seeing if they have the same interests.
Reply 2979
P.s. Christ's has guaranteed en-suite accommodation if you pay a certain amount. :smile:

Quick Reply

Latest