The Student Room Logo

The Big 'Which Cambridge College?' Thread

Scroll to see replies

Which college for Economics at Durham?
Original post by TrysBaldai
Which college for Economics at Durham?


You may wish to find a thread specifically for Durham, this is for Cambridge. Someone here may be able to answer though.
Reply 3602


You see this extract: "All applicants in this round (except those for Mathematics and Medicine) who are not offered places by their preference Colleges but have attained an overall average of 93% or more in their three best AS Level subjects MUST be pooled in category P if not in another category.In the case of post-qualification applicants the equivalent criterion is: A*,A*,A* or better at A Level."


Are medicine applicants pooled? If so there is no specific UMS to be pooled? Is there a BMAT criteria? (Cutoff) Thanks
Original post by Corvus
You see this extract: "All applicants in this round (except those for Mathematics and Medicine) who are not offered places by their preference Colleges but have attained an overall average of 93% or more in their three best AS Level subjects MUST be pooled in category P if not in another category.In the case of post-qualification applicants the equivalent criterion is: A*,A*,A* or better at A Level."


Are medicine applicants pooled? If so there is no specific UMS to be pooled? Is there a BMAT criteria? (Cutoff) Thanks


They may be pooled deliberately but I think that pooling purely based on having achieved certain grades on paper (auto-pooling) does not apply to Medicine (nor Maths). This is because they have more than enough very good candidates from the top pool categories to pick from for the spaces. So my answer is that they are simply not auto-pooled.
Reply 3604
Original post by ukdragon37
They may be pooled deliberately but I think that pooling purely based on having achieved certain grades on paper (auto-pooling) does not apply to Medicine (nor Maths). This is because they have more than enough very good candidates from the top pool categories to pick from for the spaces. So my answer is that they are simply not auto-pooled.


Thanks, do Cambridge (for mostly nat sci/med) explicitly want high ums even though achieving A*AA +? Thanks
I wonder if Cambridge will change the auto-pooling criteria again for 2013. 2011 was 7A*s + 90% average, 2012 was 93% average, so perhaps they will change it again. It will probably depend on how well 93% worked.
Original post by Corvus
Thanks, do Cambridge (for mostly nat sci/med) explicitly want high ums even though achieving A*AA +? Thanks


Majority opinion seems to be yes. Also note that average successful applicants end up achieving on average 2.5 A*s anyway so the standard offer actually does not reflect how well people who get into Cambridge do in A-levels.

Original post by A Light Lilt
I wonder if Cambridge will change the auto-pooling criteria again for 2013. 2011 was 7A*s + 90% average, 2012 was 93% average, so perhaps they will change it again. It will probably depend on how well 93% worked.


They might even revise it down, since apparently grades deflated this year.
Original post by Corvus
You see this extract: "All applicants in this round (except those for Mathematics and Medicine) who are not offered places by their preference Colleges but have attained an overall average of 93% or more in their three best AS Level subjects MUST be pooled in category P if not in another category.In the case of post-qualification applicants the equivalent criterion is: A*,A*,A* or better at A Level."


Are medicine applicants pooled? If so there is no specific UMS to be pooled? Is there a BMAT criteria? (Cutoff) Thanks


There is no AUTOpooling for medicine, but pooling still occurs.
Reply 3608
Now i am really confused about which college to choose. Originally i wanted to go for St Johns, i liked the architecture, admission process and numbers of applicant/place, however i was practically told in my school that i am not going to get in since it is very hard college. After taking a look at some other colleges its either that they have additional tests apart from TSA which i am reluctant to take or applicant/place ratio is just terrible. I don't want to make an open application as i am advised to do by my school. So where should i apply? (i don't want additional tests apart from TSA or interview + i would like something like 1 place - 10 people or less, also i would prefer larger colleges).
Original post by soempty
Now i am really confused about which college to choose. Originally i wanted to go for St Johns, i liked the architecture, admission process and numbers of applicant/place, however i was practically told in my school that i am not going to get in since it is very hard college. After taking a look at some other colleges its either that they have additional tests apart from TSA which i am reluctant to take or applicant/place ratio is just terrible. I don't want to make an open application as i am advised to do by my school. So where should i apply? (i don't want additional tests apart from TSA or interview + i would like something like 1 place - 10 people or less, also i would prefer larger colleges).


Johns is no harder to get into than any other college. (The admission process is identical at every college however)

It does have a reputation (which has some truth to it) for being rather dominated by public and grammar schools. If you're ok with that, there's no reason not to go for it.

However I wouldn't worry about additional tests, they're all very similar to the TSA, often no different than a bit of subject-specific questions thrown in.
Original post by soempty
Now i am really confused about which college to choose. Originally i wanted to go for St Johns, i liked the architecture, admission process and numbers of applicant/place, however i was practically told in my school that i am not going to get in since it is very hard college. After taking a look at some other colleges its either that they have additional tests apart from TSA which i am reluctant to take or applicant/place ratio is just terrible. I don't want to make an open application as i am advised to do by my school. So where should i apply? (i don't want additional tests apart from TSA or interview + i would like something like 1 place - 10 people or less, also i would prefer larger colleges).


Just apply to John's. Your chance of getting an offer eventually (even if it's from another college through the pool) is the same wherever you apply. No matter how "hard" John's is (which I seriously doubt in any case), you'll still be fine as long as you can accept your offer might not ultimately come from John's.
Reply 3611
I am also thinking about applying to St John's for Computer Science, still considering few others which I have shortlisted. I was just wondering, it says besides TSA at St. John's there will also be "Problem solving at interview", but that's not a test is it? Its just some maths/computer science questions, which still are asked in most of the colleges, isn't it?
Can anyone gives me some pros and cons for big colleges and small colleges pleasem, there are so many colleges, I cannt decide :rolleyes:
Are you looking at Cambridge or oxford?
In a small college, you are likely to know pretty much everyone in your year, and probably some in other years. In larger colleges you may not know everyone in your year, and maybe a small few in other years.
Are you looking at any colleges specifically? I am about to start at corpus Christi Cambridge, which is smallest in terms of undergrads in Cambridge.
I'm not good on a bike...
I'm hoping to study law at Cambridge, but I'm unsure as to what college I should choose, or whether I should apply openly... I don't really understand what the colleges are about
Reply 3616
Original post by LukeyJB
I'm hoping to study law at Cambridge, but I'm unsure as to what college I should choose, or whether I should apply openly... I don't really understand what the colleges are about


Colleges are where you live, where you socialise and where you're taught.* They vary a lot - some colleges may have been built very recently, while others have been around 800 years. Some are in the middle of town, others are further out. You can look at qhich are close to your lectures, or are on the river. They vary in size a lot - Trinity Hall - where I start tomorrow - is small, on the river, very old and well known for law, while Johns nearby is absolutely HUGE - it's grounds are anyway, I don't know in terms of people. You can think about whether you want to row when you're there, whether you want your college to own its own punts, whether you want a library 24hours a day. You could think about it's location compared to the law library, and look into what the food is like. You can decide whether you want a traditional college where you wear a gown, or whether you would rather be somewhere newer. I hope that's some help - I wouldn't make an open application, take the time this weekend to read the prospectus and the alternative prospectus (http://www.cusu.cam.ac.uk/prospective/prospectus/) and decide based on that. You might also want to look at the rent variation - at some colleges rooms vary a lot in price, whereas at others everyone pays a fixed amount. Let me know if I can be any help!

*Well partly - lectures are university based, supervisions are college based.
(edited 11 years ago)
Original post by mespannerhanz
Are you looking at Cambridge or oxford?
In a small college, you are likely to know pretty much everyone in your year, and probably some in other years. In larger colleges you may not know everyone in your year, and maybe a small few in other years.
Are you looking at any colleges specifically? I am about to start at corpus Christi Cambridge, which is smallest in terms of undergrads in Cambridge.


oh Nice! what are you going to study? hmm Most likely Cambridge :smile: I like the idea of knowing everyone in the college, but so we only spend our social time with the people in the same college?
Original post by mathsymathsy
oh Nice! what are you going to study? hmm Most likely Cambridge :smile: I like the idea of knowing everyone in the college, but so we only spend our social time with the people in the same college?

I'm doing geography. I dont know loads as I have not yet started. You can socialise with.whoever - college mates, course mates or.people from sports and societies you're in.
Remember though that there are other things to consider when choosing a college, such as whether you able to apply there (whether they do course/allfemale if you are male, mature students), distance from your department, how far out of town/is it in centre, accommodation costs.
You could have a look for CUSU alternative prospects to give your info about each college. Oxford may have something similar.
All of them except Girton and Homerton. The closest are Newnham (which I presume isn't in contention for you!) and Selwyn, which are right on the doorstep of the Sidgwick site, where most of the Arts/Humanities lectures are. Then the very central colleges (eg, Clare, Caius, King's, Trinity, Trinity Hall, John's ...) are all less than 10 minutes' walk away, though you should bear in mind that in some of those you probably won't be living on the main site all the time and could be quite some distance away. Those colleges whose main sites are further away, like Jesus, Fitzwilliam, Churchill, are still only 20 minutes' walk. And you should also bear in mind that, while lots of your teaching will take place in the Faculty, you'll also have supervisions which might be in your own College but equally might well be in any College or other building in Cambridge.

Basically, as long as you're not applying to Girton or Homerton I wouldn't worry too much about it. Cambridge isn't that big, and contrary to popular opinion, it is possible to survive here without a bike. I can't ride a bike (no sense of balance!) and I walk everywhere, and it's perfectly doable.

Quick Reply