Is one in more need than the other?
They are both very similar - yes Girlguiding has the stigma that it's all crafts and cooking (which admittedly we do do but at the girls request) however my Guide group loves the outdoors. My other guide leader decided to do a 'pamper sleepover' where the girls made face masks etc however the girls decided they wanted to go outside and play in the mud instead.
Scouts however can do more things as they're not as strict - like Scouts can do axe throwing whereas guides can't.
Whatever organisation you get as much out of it as you put in.