The Student Room Group

Boyfriend close to another girl

Basically, I have been going out with my boyfriend for about 6 months and am completely in love. We met at uni, and are apart in the holidays. Hes in a brass band at home and they went to New York on a trip a couple of weeks ago. Hes friends with this one girl a few years younger than us. When at uni, she started sending him massive long messages on facebook, and he seemed to fine it annoying at first but was soon sending massive ones back. Now they've just got back from this "amazing" lifechanging trip, facebook is covered in photos of them together, there are loads of little in jokes between them.

I went to see him when he got back, and went bowling with some of his friends one night. The other girls he is friends with are lovely and talked to me, I made a special effort to talk to her as I was feeling a bit paranoid about her beforehand and wanted to convince myself I was being silly. He warned me she was shy but she didn't seem to be, shouting over other people in conversations, being all silly and giggly. When I talked to her, she said a couple of things them turned to the girl next to her and they walked off. She seemed to be making a real effort to talk to my boyfriend about their trip and music stuff I don't understand.

Am I being stupid? I feel trapped in a rubbish situation, I'm being eaten up by jelousy. I don't need to be really, I know he loves me. I'm fairly convinced she fancies him, I had that feeling before hand, just from her body language in photos and things like that I guess. He reckons I'm being silly. I really want him to cool his friendship with her, but I can't say that to him, I'm not being the silly controlling girlfriend, it has to be his own idea. But what can I do?

Please help.

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1

From what you said, she sounds like she does have feelings for him. Theres nothing you can do about that, so i guess you just have to trust your boyfriend. Does he make any signs of liking her more than he should? If its a one-way thing from the girl to your boyfriend then you just have to trust that nothing will happen between them. Maybe say to him that she seems to be really clingy with him. Just keep it really relaxed and calm, if you decide to talk to him some more about it.

I think really, it just goes down to trust. I hope everything works out for you :smile:

Reply 2

It sounds like they're just really good friends, although I have a feeling she might like him in that way. However, if you trust him you have nothing to worry about :smile: I was that other girl, in exactly the same situation. And I'm best friends with the guy who had a gf at the time :smile:

Reply 3

She sounds like she fancies him and that she's a bit of an attention seeker. But to be honest, as long as you and your boyfriend are cool, and he only has feelings for you, you have to accept he's chosen to be with you, not her. From what you've said, she sounds unattractively insecure.
Maybe mention to your boyfriend that she makes you feel a bit uncomfortable, particularly as you've made an effort to talk to her, and just go from there.

Good luck, hope you and your boyfriend stay cool :smile:
xx

Reply 4

The main thing you need to remember is that he is your boyfriend. Girls aswell as boys flirt without knowing it and you boyfriend may not even see it as flirting, just mention it to your boyfriend and make sure he knows you werent comfortable with it!

Reply 5

princess1729
Basically, I have been going out with my boyfriend for about 6 months and am completely in love. We met at uni, and are apart in the holidays. Hes in a brass band at home and they went to New York on a trip a couple of weeks ago. Hes friends with this one girl a few years younger than us. When at uni, she started sending him massive long messages on facebook, and he seemed to fine it annoying at first but was soon sending massive ones back. Now they've just got back from this "amazing" lifechanging trip, facebook is covered in photos of them together, there are loads of little in jokes between them.

I went to see him when he got back, and went bowling with some of his friends one night. The other girls he is friends with are lovely and talked to me, I made a special effort to talk to her as I was feeling a bit paranoid about her beforehand and wanted to convince myself I was being silly. He warned me she was shy but she didn't seem to be, shouting over other people in conversations, being all silly and giggly. When I talked to her, she said a couple of things them turned to the girl next to her and they walked off. She seemed to be making a real effort to talk to my boyfriend about their trip and music stuff I don't understand.

Am I being stupid? I feel trapped in a rubbish situation, I'm being eaten up by jelousy. I don't need to be really, I know he loves me. I'm fairly convinced she fancies him, I had that feeling before hand, just from her body language in photos and things like that I guess. He reckons I'm being silly. I really want him to cool his friendship with her, but I can't say that to him, I'm not being the silly controlling girlfriend, it has to be his own idea. But what can I do?

Please help.


I've been in a situation that was very similar to this in the past (actually it was significantly worse), and it was untenable. You have to act, not just hope it will go away.

First thing to do is to discuss this sensibly with your boyfriend. Explain that this girl's behaviour makes you feel uncomfortable and excluded, and that, though you trust your boyfriend absolutely, you would appreciate some reassurance. Be calm, not jealous.

If your boyfriend responds to that, great. If not, it sounds like he's trying to have his cake and eat it. Put it like this - if you're his (serious) girlfriend, you're supposed to be his priority over other female friends. No questions asked. If they're having all these amazing experiences together, you're being left out in the cold. Point this out calmly.

It's a really difficult situation, and it's difficult not to mentally compare yourself to your 'rival'. The main thing, though, is not to act hysterical and jealous, because that will be counterproductive. In the end, you might have to issue a 'Her or Me' ultimatum if his behaviour becomes unacceptable, but try talking it through first. Good luck! :yep:

Reply 6

Thanks for replying. I trust him completely, hes just a very sweet kind person, and never thinks anyone would fancy him, so he wouldn't notice her behaviour at all.

Reply 7

You'll be fine, she may fancy him, but so what?
You and him are all that matters, boys are often oblivious to girls trying to show they like them anyway so i doubt he reads too much into it!

Reply 8

to be honest, i wouldn't like this sitch either .... seems a bit cosy to me. i would talk to him about how you feel, because it's a slight disrespect to your feelings. however he doesn't know how you feel about this girl so i think you tell him. it's not you being paranoid, you have reason to be worried. i had a similar situation, this girl was sending my boyfriend suggestive facebook messages and comments, and when i met her, she could not look me in the eye and wouldn't talk to me. so i think she def fancied him. this sounds liek whats happening here. is your bf almost too sweet/nice to rebuff her advances?

Reply 9

princess1729
Basically, I have been going out with my boyfriend for about 6 months and am completely in love. We met at uni, and are apart in the holidays. Hes in a brass band at home and they went to New York on a trip a couple of weeks ago. Hes friends with this one girl a few years younger than us. When at uni, she started sending him massive long messages on facebook, and he seemed to fine it annoying at first but was soon sending massive ones back. Now they've just got back from this "amazing" lifechanging trip, facebook is covered in photos of them together, there are loads of little in jokes between them.

I went to see him when he got back, and went bowling with some of his friends one night. The other girls he is friends with are lovely and talked to me, I made a special effort to talk to her as I was feeling a bit paranoid about her beforehand and wanted to convince myself I was being silly. He warned me she was shy but she didn't seem to be, shouting over other people in conversations, being all silly and giggly. When I talked to her, she said a couple of things them turned to the girl next to her and they walked off. She seemed to be making a real effort to talk to my boyfriend about their trip and music stuff I don't understand.

Am I being stupid? I feel trapped in a rubbish situation, I'm being eaten up by jelousy. I don't need to be really, I know he loves me. I'm fairly convinced she fancies him, I had that feeling before hand, just from her body language in photos and things like that I guess. He reckons I'm being silly. I really want him to cool his friendship with her, but I can't say that to him, I'm not being the silly controlling girlfriend, it has to be his own idea. But what can I do?

Please help.


nah you're not stupid, the fact that you actually tried to get to know her and she just went off.. she likes your guy! lets just hope he has more common sense than to get carried away with he.

if you're that worried, talk to him about it. if he thinks you're being silly then leave him to it, but he'll see sooner or later himself what she's like, especially if he really really likes you.. coz if he does no other girl can replace you :smile:

relationships are called relationships because the couple have to work together... which means honesty, which means you should talk to him about it!

Reply 10

To do it this way, you're his girl, she isn't. If the other one fancies him, so what? He's with you for a reason, because he likes you :smile:

Reply 11

tbh if she made me feel any more uncomfortable I would actually confront her. But then again that depends whether or not you're the confrontational type! Seriously though make sure she's aware that you're not gonna put up with her being all over him and getting a bit too cosy with him....

Reply 12

Well, maybe she is jealous. It doesn't necessarily mean that she wants him for herself but that she wants to keep their special bond and shes worried that you'll interfere. Just stick it through and after a while you'll both hopefully see that you aren't a threat to each other. Maybe she is shy with new people but not her old friends? I'm a bit loud with people I know but with people I don't know, I can hardly talk to them. Give the girl a chance, there must be a reason why he is such good friends with her.

Reply 13

Milady de Winter
I've been in a situation that was very similar to this in the past (actually it was significantly worse), and it was untenable. You have to act, not just hope it will go away.

First thing to do is to discuss this sensibly with your boyfriend. Explain that this girl's behaviour makes you feel uncomfortable and excluded, and that, though you trust your boyfriend absolutely, you would appreciate some reassurance. Be calm, not jealous.

If your boyfriend responds to that, great. If not, it sounds like he's trying to have his cake and eat it. Put it like this - if you're his (serious) girlfriend, you're supposed to be his priority over other female friends. No questions asked. If they're having all these amazing experiences together, you're being left out in the cold. Point this out calmly.

It's a really difficult situation, and it's difficult not to mentally compare yourself to your 'rival'. The main thing, though, is not to act hysterical and jealous, because that will be counterproductive. In the end, you might have to issue a 'Her or Me' ultimatum if his behaviour becomes unacceptable, but try talking it through first. Good luck! :yep:


Brilliant advice. I also went through something like this and couldn't agree more with what you've said :wink:

Reply 14

The thing is, I can't confront her or get to know her, she is about 200miles from me and I won't be back there for months (and have no reason to see her when I do). The only option is to send her a message on facebook or something, which would probably result in her complete denial and a forwarding to my boyfriend with "I think your girlfriend has some problems, look at this..."

Reply 15

Serious, don't be jealous. I have a very close friend who has got a girlfriend and she hates me to death. I call my friend names and he calls me back (Jackipie and Mireipie), but we just good friends. His girlfriend has harassed me several times and she even added me on Facebook to check out my profile! She left me a message saying "**** off **** off Jack is mine dont call him Jackipie your a fat ugly bitch and he doesnt fancy u x" [sic]. I am in no ways attracted to Jack and even if I were I wouldn't try a thing, he's got a partner! Don't act the desperate girlfriend, try to get to know this girl, maybe she is dead nice, and you'll understand why they are friends!! xx

Reply 16

I don't want to be the jelous girlfriend. I can't get to know her because I'll never get to see her. The one time I saw her I wanted to get to know her and she was really unfriendly! All his friends are nice people, I thought he was a good judge of character, but she seems to be a silly immature giggly girl who was downright mean to me!

Reply 17

princess1729
I don't want to be the jelous girlfriend. I can't get to know her because I'll never get to see her. The one time I saw her I wanted to get to know her and she was really unfriendly! All his friends are nice people, I thought he was a good judge of character, but she seems to be a silly immature giggly girl who was downright mean to me!


I think that your boyfriend is the one you need to talk to. Don't 'confront' her, because the potential for it to go wrong is huge - either you'll say something you don't mean, or you'll be misinterpreted, and you'll sound like a nutter (which I assume you're not!) :p:

The issue is not the fact that your boyfriend has a female friend. The issue is that your status as his "priority" is under threat if he has more/better social experiences with this girl than with you, and you are not in the wrong if you have a problem with that.

Reply 18

Milady de Winter
I think that your boyfriend is the one you need to talk to. Don't 'confront' her, because the potential for it to go wrong is huge - either you'll say something you don't mean, or you'll be misinterpreted, and you'll sound like a nutter (which I assume you're not!) :p:

The issue is not the fact that your boyfriend has a female friend. The issue is that your status as his "priority" is under threat if he has more/better social experiences with this girl than with you, and you are not in the wrong if you have a problem with that.


You're right, its what I was thinking but didn't know how to word. His best friend is a girl but she is lovely, and we get on. Its just this unknown hes been messaging without me really knowing is suddenly a huge part of his life.

Reply 19

I've talked to him but it hasn't really helped. He says there is nothing going on (which I know), says I'm being silly, there is nothing wrong with having female friends (which I agree with, I like all the other ones!), and doesn't see what he can do about it. He can't explain her odd behaviour, can't see that he can ask her about it. Can't see how he can be less friendly with her. Oh sigh.