The Student Room Group

failed my driving practical again

can anyone tell me why u have to do 60mph on country roads with blind bends? i've just failed again 4th time for doing 45mph on country roads this time i had to change into 3rd gear to get round safely. i thought u were suppose to drive carefully and with caution on these roads but last two times i got 1 serious and 6 minors and was told i wasn't going fast enough on the country lanes! any advice on this?

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1
Unregistered
can anyone tell me why u have to do 60mph on country roads with blind bends? i've just failed again 4th time for doing 45mph on country roads this time i had to change into 3rd gear to get round safely. i thought u were suppose to drive carefully and with caution on these roads but last two times i got 1 serious and 6 minors and was told i wasn't going fast enough on the country lanes! any advice on this?

i cant really comment without judging the country road for myself. however, if there were blind bends then 45mph seems too fast! sounds a bit unfair for them to fail you for going too slow!
Reply 2
edders
i cant really comment without judging the country road for myself. however, if there were blind bends then 45mph seems too fast! sounds a bit unfair for them to fail you for going too slow!

Tests are a money spinner thesedays I'm afraid to say... Some of my friends swear blind they were failed unfairly, my test is in November and I hope and pray that the Examiner is just.
Reply 3
Petrozzi
Tests are a money spinner thesedays I'm afraid to say... Some of my friends swear blind they were failed unfairly, my test is in November and I hope and pray that the Examiner is just.

ive been failed 3 times (still havent passed :frown:), each time i got one major and like 6 minors. i dont think they were really fair because my overall driving was excellent, just the odd careless (non-dangerous lol) mistake.
Reply 4
edders
ive been failed 3 times (still havent passed :frown:), each time i got one major and like 6 minors. i dont think they were really fair because my overall driving was excellent, just the odd careless (non-dangerous lol) mistake.


Yeah, it's extremely unfortunate. Most my friends passed on their 3/4th time. My instructor says I'll be ready for my test when it comes, but I've said to him I don't expect to pass the first time given the current situation of the tests.
i failed for doing 20 in a 30 the first time..even thou it was cardiff city centre and there were padestrians weaving in and out of cars and i had to do an emergancy stop twice.

did you slow down just for the bends or did you drive all the way at 45mph? it can be dangerous if someone was coming at 55-60 behind you and because they couldnt see you there could be an accident.

love Katy ***
Reply 6
Petrozzi
Yeah, it's extremely unfortunate. Most my friends passed on their 3/4th time. My instructor says I'll be ready for my test when it comes, but I've said to him I don't expect to pass the first time given the current situation of the tests.


I honestly don't think its got anything to do with being ready (well it helps), its more to do with the luck of the day. i.e a nice examiner on the day who gives you nice test routes. Some examiners are awful! In one test the *evil* examiner told me to turn right in 5 different roundabouts, told me to do the worst manoevre-reverse around a corner, told me to take the next right - 4 times (the 4 roads had no entry signs!!!), then told me to turn right at a very confusing junction with traffic lights (no filter arrow), this route he took me on I had never seen in my life :frown:.

I failed :frown: If I have him again I will cry...
Reply 7
ickle_katy
i failed for doing 20 in a 30 the first time..even thou it was cardiff city centre and there were padestrians weaving in and out of cars and i had to do an emergancy stop twice.

did you slow down just for the bends or did you drive all the way at 45mph? it can be dangerous if someone was coming at 55-60 behind you and because they couldnt see you there could be an accident.

love Katy ***



no i was doing 45 all the time but the bends were really winding there was no one else on the road at the time
Reply 8
depending on where you live, you might want to try taking the test somewhere where there aren't many country roads, eg a bit nearer a city/town. I know its stupid that you have to go 60 on country roads, even though it dangerous, you're not holding anyone up and 60 is the maximum, so maybe try and avoid them.
Reply 9
Unregistered
can anyone tell me why u have to do 60mph on country roads with blind bends? i've just failed again 4th time for doing 45mph on country roads this time i had to change into 3rd gear to get round safely. i thought u were suppose to drive carefully and with caution on these roads but last two times i got 1 serious and 6 minors and was told i wasn't going fast enough on the country lanes! any advice on this?


It is all about the DSA making money... I know loads of people that are perfect drivers but have failed.
I just failed my test today. The stupid examiner just seemed to have it in for me. Made me go round the most stupid routes. And the stingy fool couldn't even wait for my instructor to come to the car at the end.
The route is irrelevent - to pass your test the examiner needs to feel confident that you will be safe driving anywhere...even :gasp: if it involves turning right on a roundabout.

Complaining about the route is rediculous - it's like complaining that the contents of this yrs A level exam was different to the past papers you'd perfected.

The recent changes to the test are excellent if you ask me - instead of learning more after you've passed and are out driving alone they are trying to get learners up to the standard they will be forever.

Took me 3 times to pass (edders if you're ever re-taking the examiners in Dorchester are sweethearts...I drove over there from Bournemouth for all 3 of my tests because my instructor had an arguement with the examiners in B'mouth), my sister failed 5 times under the old (pre-theory test) system and has now given up. Passing my test was one of the best things I ever did :smile:
Reply 11
Pencil Queen
The route is irrelevent - to pass your test the examiner needs to feel confident that you will be safe driving anywhere...even :gasp: if it involves turning right on a roundabout.

Complaining about the route is rediculous - it's like complaining that the contents of this yrs A level exam was different to the past papers you'd perfected.

The recent changes to the test are excellent if you ask me - instead of learning more after you've passed and are out driving alone they are trying to get learners up to the standard they will be forever.

Took me 3 times to pass (edders if you're ever re-taking the examiners in Dorchester are sweethearts...I drove over there from Bournemouth for all 3 of my tests because my instructor had an arguement with the examiners in B'mouth), my sister failed 5 times under the old (pre-theory test) system and has now given up. Passing my test was one of the best things I ever did :smile:


I passed first time but I totally disagree with you. I TOTALLY DEPENDS ON THE ROUTE. How can you think it doesn;t? Every time its gonna be different .. there might be a crap driver in front of you, a bus pulling out in front of you etc.... I had none of this and I was very lucky to pass ...

My instructor advised me to drive about 35 in some of those 60 zones..they are so dangerous....i cant believed he failed u cos of that? Was that your major?
Reply 12
*dave*
... Was that your major?


the fact that he cant drive.
*dave*
I passed first time but I totally disagree with you. I TOTALLY DEPENDS ON THE ROUTE. How can you think it doesn;t? Every time its gonna be different .. there might be a crap driver in front of you, a bus pulling out in front of you etc.... I had none of this and I was very lucky to pass ...


If you are a good driver (like if you know your A level syllabus well) you will pass regardless of the route (or the specific questions covered in the exam paper).

Admittedly some people do get lucky and pass on an easy route (or get an exam paper covering the small amount of stuff that they know well), that doesn't mean that a hard route (or paper) is an excuse for failure.
Reply 14
Jesus09
the fact that he cant drive.


'Cant drive'? I wouldnt say the fact u drove 45 on a 60 country lane was 'cant drive' ... I would say it is safer.

So many people think the speed limit is what you should drive AT ... its stupid ... when I drive 38 on a 40 road my friends all say im slow lol
Reply 15
A good driver drives according to the conditions and not what a speed limit sign says.
Reply 16
Pencil Queen
If you are a good driver (like if you know your A level syllabus well) you will pass regardless of the route (or the specific questions covered in the exam paper).

Admittedly some people do get lucky and pass on an easy route (or get an exam paper covering the small amount of stuff that they know well), that doesn't mean that a hard route (or paper) is an excuse for failure.


Hmmm ... but having a bad driver sabotaging your test is unfair ... it makes the test very unreliable
Reply 17
Pencil Queen
If you are a good driver (like if you know your A level syllabus well) you will pass regardless of the route (or the specific questions covered in the exam paper).


Just because you pass your test does not necessarily mean you are a good driver. Similarly, good drivers can also fail because the test conditions are so arbitrary that one other idiot doing something wrong can cause you to do something that isn't entirely "textbook" and fail because of it.

I passed first time, though I have no idea how. I picked up two minors for driving too slowly, but not a major - I think that was rather unfair, whoever got that. I still don't think I'm a good driver, and I won't be for many years.
Reply 18
Helenia
Just because you pass your test does not necessarily mean you are a good driver. Similarly, good drivers can also fail because the test conditions are so arbitrary that one other idiot doing something wrong can cause you to do something that isn't entirely "textbook" and fail because of it.

I passed first time, though I have no idea how. I picked up two minors for driving too slowly, but not a major - I think that was rather unfair, whoever got that. I still don't think I'm a good driver, and I won't be for many years.


me either lol im scared of driving
Helenia
Just because you pass your test does not necessarily mean you are a good driver. Similarly, good drivers can also fail because the test conditions are so arbitrary that one other idiot doing something wrong can cause you to do something that isn't entirely "textbook" and fail because of it.

I passed first time, though I have no idea how. I picked up two minors for driving too slowly, but not a major - I think that was rather unfair, whoever got that. I still don't think I'm a good driver, and I won't be for many years.


Exactly...passing the test doesn't mean you're a good driver...but I doubt that reacting to the road conditions (including other drivers, good bad or indifferent) correctly would cause you to fail.

I didn't think I was a good driver when I passed. It's taken 4 yrs of driving 70 miles a day to make me a confident driver and on a good day I'd say I was bloody good, but like anyone I have bad days when I know I'm not driving as well as I should be...and I give myself more time to react and more space at those times.