# Maximum and minimum valueWatch

#1
If and , find
a) the greatest possible value of .
b) the smallest possible valus of .

a) Can the answer be "undefined number"? The book wrote the value is = undefined number.
b) Can the answer be "undefined number"? The book wrote the value is = undefined number.

So I'm confused. Thanks.
0
quote
10 years ago
#2
Yes.
0
quote
#3
Yes.
Thanks but why? I don't understand why it can be a undefined number.
If you say the value is +infinity or -infinity respectively...then it's more acceptable to me.
0
quote
10 years ago
#4
How can anything over zero be given as an answer to that question? Surely it needs to be a real number for starters?
0
quote
10 years ago
#5
Sounds like an awful book, to be honest.
0
quote
10 years ago
#6
(Original post by Civ-217)
If and , find
a) the greatest possible value of .
b) the smallest possible valus of .

a) Can the answer be "undefined number"? The book wrote the value is = undefined number.
b) Can the answer be "undefined number"? The book wrote the value is = undefined number.

So I'm confused. Thanks.
Anything number, divided by 0 gives you an undefined answer. And zero is a possibility as y can equal 0.
0
quote
10 years ago
#7
(Original post by Civ-217)
Thanks but why? I don't understand why it can be a undefined number.
If you say the value is +infinity or -infinity respectively...then it's more acceptable to me.
The greatest value is +infinity and the smallest value is -infinity.
0
quote
#8
The greatest value is +infinity and the smallest value is -infinity.
Which means? Sorry I'm slow.
For a number near to 0 from right, the value is +infinity for part a. But is this 'number' acceptable?

(Original post by DFranklin)
Sounds like an awful book, to be honest.

(Original post by kam_007)
Anything number, divided by 0 gives you an undefined answer. And zero is a possibility as y can equal 0.
Yes but why is the answer an undefined number?
0
quote
10 years ago
#9
"Undefined" or "unbounded" looks about the best answer you can give. It's the stuff that's truly horrible. Plus of course it's not a well posed question, given you can't give a proper answer to it (i.e. there is no "greatest value of x/y", so the question shouldn't be asking for it).
0
quote
#10
(Original post by DFranklin)
"Undefined" or "unbounded" looks about the best answer you can give. It's the stuff that's truly horrible. Plus of course it's not a well posed question, given you can't give a proper answer to it (i.e. there is no "greatest value of x/y", so the question shouldn't be asking for it).
Thanks.
0
quote
10 years ago
#11
The greatest value is +infinity and the smallest value is -infinity.
Infinity isn't a real number!
quote
10 years ago
#12
(Original post by Kolya)
Infinity isn't a real number!
In other words, the value of x/y can be made as large as we please or as small as we please.
0
quote
X

new posts
Latest
My Feed

### Oops, nobody has postedin the last few hours.

Why not re-start the conversation?

see more

### See more of what you like onThe Student Room

You can personalise what you see on TSR. Tell us a little about yourself to get started.

### University open days

• Sheffield Hallam University
Thu, 13 Dec '18
• University of Buckingham
Thu, 13 Dec '18
• University of Lincoln
Mini Open Day at the Brayford Campus Undergraduate
Wed, 19 Dec '18

### Poll

Join the discussion

Yes (18)
30%
No (42)
70%