The Student Room Group

3 charged in Poland for hanging gay flags off public statues

Only seems mildly vindictive by the authorities there. I'm fairly sure there being more serious criminals out there than a couple of flag drapers..



Three people accused of hanging LGBT rainbow flags off statues in Warsaw have been arrested and charged.

Polish police charged them with desecrating monuments and offending religious feelings.

Activists protesting against the anti-LGBT policies of President Andrzej Duda hung the flags off statues of Jesus Christ, the astronomer Copernicus and the Warsaw mermaid.

They also dressed them in pink face masks bearing the anarcho-queer symbol.

Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki denounced the activists, saying the statues symbolise values that are important to millions of Poles.

However, activists who were part of the demonstrations said they were protesting against the homophobic ideology of governing officials.

Prosecutors must now decide whether to bring the case to court.

In Poland, the crime of offending religious feelings is punishable by a fine or up to two years in prison.

What has Duda said about LGBT rights?

President Duda, an ally of the ruling nationalist Law and Justice Party (PiS), is being sworn in for his second term in office on Thursday.

He was re-elected on 13 July, narrowly beating challenger Rafal Trzaskowski. It was Poland's slimmest presidential election victory since the end of communism in 1989.

During his campaign earlier this year, he proposed incorporating a ban on same-sex marriage and adoption into Poland's constitution.

Mr Duda and his government have also frequently used inflammatory, homophobic language against the LGBT community.

During the presidential campaign, for example, Mr Duda said the LGBT movement is "more destructive" than communism.

He also accused the community of trying to "force" LGBT rights on the nation.

Poland does not currently recognise same-sex unions - whether those are marriages or civil unions. Same-sex couples are also legally banned from adopting children.

Last month, the EU said it would deny funding to six Polish towns that declared themselves "LGBT-free zones". Helena Dalli, the EU's commissioner for equality, tweeted: "EU values and fundamental rights must be respected by Member States and state authorities."

Separately, Poland also announced last month that it was withdrawing from a European treaty aimed at preventing violence against women.

Justice Minister Zbigniew Ziobro said the treaty, known as the Istanbul Convention, was "harmful" because it required schools to teach children about gender.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-53673411

Scroll to see replies

:frown:

The EU really needs to put their foot down on this one and withdraw all funding from Poland till they get their **** together.
Reply 3
Original post by DiddyDec
The EU really needs to put their foot down on this one and withdraw all funding from Poland till they get their **** together.

Indeed, then again, if they let the emerging dictatorship in Hungary go with a free pass i'm not overly hopeful Poland is going to have any attention paid to it.
Original post by Napp
Indeed, then again, if they let the emerging dictatorship in Hungary go with a free pass i'm not overly hopeful Poland is going to have any attention paid to it.

The EU is becoming much more like the UN, a toothless puppy that writes angry letters telling nations how angry they are.
Original post by Napp
Only seems mildly vindictive by the authorities there. I'm fairly sure there being more serious criminals out there than a couple of flag drapers..


https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-53673411


Poland and Hungary are ran by future autocrats.
Democracy strikes again!
These fools have overwhelming support from their foolish voters, statistically the oldest, with the lowest education in the country, and more often than other living outside towns.


Original post by DiddyDec
The EU really needs to put their foot down on this one and withdraw all funding from Poland till they get their **** together.

Probably they should, but it will reinforce the Siege mentality, the ruling party heavily relies on.


I'm personally ashamed of my country. It was once the vanguarde of Europe, one of the first working multicultural societies (if not the first and only in modern Europe), only a few know one of the elder modern works on civil toleration, and the first treaty for atheism come from there. And it has fallen so low to persecute people for something like this.

Next to the Polish tax system, this is probably the main reason why 130 thousand people run away from the country every year, and the number keeps increasing.
(edited 3 years ago)
Original post by PTMalewski
Democracy strikes again!
These fools have overwhelming support from their foolish voters, statistically the oldest, with the lowest education in the country, and more often than other living outside towns.



Probably they should, but it will reinforce the Siege mentality, the ruling party heavily relies on.


I'm personally ashamed of my country. It was once the vanguarde of Europe, one of the first working multicultural societies (if not the first and only in modern Europe), only a few know one of the elder modern works on civil toleration, and the first treaty for atheism come from there. And it has fallen so low to persecute people for something like this.

Next to the Polish tax system, this is probably the main reason why 130 thousand people run away from the country every year, and the number keeps increasing.

I can't say much better for the UK, just look at the ****wits running us thanks to the public.
Reply 8
A resident of Poland has written an interesting article that might help shed some light on these issues in Poland.

https://www.quora.com/Why-is-the-current-Polish-government-persecuting-homosexuals/answer/Lidia-Fedorska?__filter__=all&__nsrc__=1&__sncid__=6958277775&__snid3__=10572222472

Her name is Lidia Fedorska.

Often, you cannot rely on outlets like the BBC for a complete unbiased picture of events particularly where these events are politically charged in sexuality or gender. They do not tell you the entire story. They sell you a very biased, incomplete story that serves a specific narrative.
(edited 3 years ago)
Reply 9
Original post by Pinkisk
A resident of Poland has written an interesting article that might help shed some light on these issues in Poland.

https://www.quora.com/Why-is-the-current-Polish-government-persecuting-homosexuals/answer/Lidia-Fedorska?__filter__=all&__nsrc__=1&__sncid__=6958277775&__snid3__=10572222472

Her name is Lidia Fedorska.

Often, you cannot rely on outlets like the BBC for a complete unbiased picture of events particularly where these events are politically charged in sexuality or gender. They do not tell you the entire story. They sell you a very biased, incomplete story that serves a specific narrative.

You mean like this article you just posted? Given that it is clearly biased as well..
Original post by Napp
You mean like this article you just posted? Given that it is clearly biased as well..

It is modest and rational, She gave you the complete picture. She didn't do as the BBC did in their article lie to you and tell you that the individuals were arrested for hanging flags when they were in actual fact not arrested for hanging flags but for assaulting people. I think, her article, whether biased or not is very revealing and important. Unlike the BBC where their bias leads to deception, her bias, if she presented any at all, does not in any way affect the rigour of her arguments...
(edited 3 years ago)
Original post by Pinkisk
A resident of Poland has written an interesting article that might help shed some light on these issues in Poland.

https://www.quora.com/Why-is-the-current-Polish-government-persecuting-homosexuals/answer/Lidia-Fedorska?__filter__=all&__nsrc__=1&__sncid__=6958277775&__snid3__=10572222472

Her name is Lidia Fedorska.

Often, you cannot rely on outlets like the BBC for a complete unbiased picture of events particularly where these events are politically charged in sexuality or gender. They do not tell you the entire story. They sell you a very biased, incomplete story that serves a specific narrative.


Original post by Napp
You mean like this article you just posted? Given that it is clearly biased as well..



I can actually confirm this article is the most accurate description of what's happening so far.


The true drama that's happening in Poland is not that some agressive kids are being arrested. It's elsewhere.
Months ago there was a huge investigation over pictures Virgin Mary with rainbow attached to it, that were put over a fence around a church. In Poland there is a ludicrous law that penalises 'offending religious feelings'.

Meanwhile, the Prosecutor's office refuses to take action on priests molesting and raping children, even when there are recorded testimonies, most likely because the General Prosecutor is a member of the ruling party, and the ruling party is supported by the church in exchange for public funds.
Well, not surprising since the ruling party's vice-leader has been accused by three witnesses of raping a 14 years old kidnapped Ukrainian, and all the witnesses commited suicides.
In Poland we ironically call incidents like this 'A serial self-killer'.
(edited 3 years ago)
Reply 12
Original post by PTMalewski
I can actually confirm this article is the most accurate description of what's happening so far.

My point was, accuracy aside, it is still eo ipso biased - there being no such thing as unbiased.
Original post by Napp
My point was, accuracy aside, it is still eo ipso biased - there being no such thing as unbiased.

Not relevant in this discussion.

And knowing what's happening in the country, probably better than any of you, I can tell it's just as objective as human can be.
Reply 14
Original post by PTMalewski
Not relevant in this discussion.

And knowing what's happening in the country, probably better than any of you, I can tell it's just as objective as human can be.

Err it's pretty relevent given the post was an attack on supposed bias :rolleyes:
You'll forgive me for doubting that claim.
Original post by Napp
Err it's pretty relevent given the post was an attack on supposed bias :rolleyes:
You'll forgive me for doubting that claim.

My post was not an attack on bias. That was just the one word in my comment that you chose to make your entire focus whilst conveniently ignoring all the other matters that I raised.

The BBC claimed that the individuals to whom you referred in this thread were arrested for hanging flags when they were actually arrested for attacking and physically assaulting an anti abortion activist....all caught on video*!!!! which clearly shows that the BBC was lying in its article.... You conveniently ignored all of this and went off on your own tangent, focusing on the philosophies of bias, which proves and/or disproves nothing.

These people, not very much unlike their counterparts and comrades in Western Europe, the BLM, Antifa and other extremist marxist, communist, feminist, anarchist groups, are prone to authoritarian tactics that often manifest themselves in the form of violence, which many times has since the inception of these draconian ideologies gone so far murder, terrorism and genocide against all those who disagree with them. They impose their ways on others in society by force and anyone that dares oppose them is punished by them. What the police did here is a perfectly justified response to their violence.

*Video of the assault for which these people were arrested...not for their sexuality and not for hanging flags as the BBC claimed.
(edited 3 years ago)
Firstly, it is completely relevant to question how reliable a source is when discussing the events described therein. Provided of course that this does not descend into a generic discussion about impartiality in the news.

Secondly, I am very concerned about the situation in Poland and (more worryingly) the direction it is heading in. Where will this end? :frown:
Reply 17
Original post by Pinkisk
My post was not an attack on bias. That was just the one word in my comment that you chose to make your entire focus whilst conveniently ignoring all the other matters that I raised.

The BBC claimed that the individuals to whom you referred in this thread were arrested for hanging flags when they were actually arrested for attacking and physically assaulting an anti abortion activist....all caught on video*!!!! which clearly shows that the BBC was lying in its article.... You conveniently ignored all of this and went off on your own tangent, focusing on the philosophies of bias, which proves and/or disproves nothing.

These people, not very much unlike their counterparts and comrades in Western Europe, the BLM, Antifa and other extremist marxist, communist, feminist, anarchist groups, are prone to authoritarian tactics that often manifest themselves in the form of violence, which many times has since the inception of these draconian ideologies gone so far murder, terrorism and genocide against all those who disagree with them. They impose their ways on others in society by force and anyone that dares oppose them is punished by them. What the police did here is a perfectly justified response to their violence.

*Video of the assault for which these people were arrested...not for their sexuality and not for hanging flags as the BBC claimed.

Convenient because it had nothing to do with the point i was making. I have not claimed the BBC is impartial, merely that it is rather amusing you attack a source for being biased and then proceed to give an equally, if not more, biased source from quora of all places.

I feel obliged to iterate the point that i am hardly siding with either the government or the protesters/criminals (delete as you will) merely making the point that as a general rule of thumb the BBC can be trusted infinitely more than a stranger on quora or, heaven forbid, a government commissar.
Original post by Napp
Convenient because it had nothing to do with the point i was making. I have not claimed the BBC is impartial, merely that it is rather amusing you attack a source for being biased and then proceed to give an equally, if not more, biased source from quora of all places.


The BBC lied in their article. Their bias rendered their article invalid. Bias is therefore relevant to their article.
The article that I linked was not biased. It merely exposed the lie that the BBC had made in this story. This is perfectly reasonable. Nothing stated in the article that I linked was invalid. Bias is therefore not relevant to my Quora article.

Original post by Napp
I feel obliged to iterate the point that i am hardly siding with either the government or the protesters/criminals (delete as you will) merely making the point that as a general rule of thumb the BBC can be trusted infinitely more than a stranger on quora or, heaven forbid, a government commissar.


Clearly your trust in the BBC was misplaced as it led you to buy into a lie.
(edited 3 years ago)
Reply 19
Original post by Pinkisk
The BBC lied in their article. Their bias rendered their article invalid. Bias is therefore relevant to their article.
The article that I linked was not biased. It merely exposed the lie that the BBC had made in this story. This is perfectly reasonable. Nothing stated in the article that I linked was invalid. Bias is therefore not relevant to my Quora article.



Clearly your trust in the BBC was misplaced as it led you to buy into a lie.

A lie requires intent, can you show intent?
Of course your article was biased, not least of all because the author repeatedly called transpeople men.
Yeah my point on that was theres nothing to prove its right either. A random person on the internet not being an authority on the matter.

Go look up what the definition of a lie is. Being mistaken (which i'm not saying they are or arent) is not the same as lying.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending