The Student Room Group

The greatest, and worst, moment in British history?

Scroll to see replies

Original post by Napp
There is a vast chasm between selling opium to a country to extract money (specifically to lower the huge trade deficit with the celestial kingdom) and plotting to overthrow it through narco terrorism.
Any history on the matter will happily affirm the former and rubbish the latter. Britain not planning for any war with China on the matter, least of all to grab Hong Kong - that being purely incidental and a byproduct of the war not planned.

So why did Britain accept Hong Kong in exchange for peace?
Reply 21
Original post by Gundabad(good)
So why did Britain accept Hong Kong in exchange for peace?

Why wouldnt they? That doesnt mean they orchestrated the opium trade and the war to simply nab the island :lol:
Original post by Napp
Why wouldnt they? That doesnt mean they orchestrated the opium trade and the war to simply nab the island :lol:

I thought you knew your stuff. :confused:

"In order to stop this, the East India Company and other British merchants began to smuggle Indian opium into China illegally, for which they demanded payment in silver." - https://www.nam.ac.uk/explore/opium-war-1839-1842
Reply 23
Original post by Gundabad(good)
I thought you knew your stuff. :confused:

"In order to stop this, the East India Company and other British merchants began to smuggle Indian opium into China illegally, for which they demanded payment in silver." - https://www.nam.ac.uk/explore/opium-war-1839-1842

Apparently better than you, that doesnt say Britain started sending opium to China as a plot to nab HK, did you even read this :lol:
Original post by Napp
Apparently better than you, that doesnt say Britain started sending opium to China as a plot to nab HK, did you even read this :lol:

East India Company was the United Kingdom you dum dum. :rolleyes:
Reply 25
Original post by Gundabad(good)
East India Company was the United Kingdom you dum dum. :rolleyes:

Oh dear :rofl: 10/10 for trying, alas you lose that for still not bothering to either read your 'source' nor understand it.
If this thread was a boxing match the referee would have had to stop it by now.
Greatest - End of WWI
Worst - Beginning of WWII
Greatest- some of the Hundred Years War victories, Crecy or Agincourt
Worst- any number of Empire-related atrocities
Reply 29
Original post by ageshallnot
If this thread was a boxing match the referee would have had to stop it by now.

It's all done in good jest.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending