Badges: 6
Report Thread starter 3 months ago
Does anyone have any ideas or tips about my A Level Tudor essay?
The question is 'Using your understanding of the historical context, assess how convincing the arguments in these three extracts are in relation to the successfulness of the reign of Henry VII, 1485-1509.'
These are the extracts:
Extract A: Adapted from C. Pendrill, The Wars of the Roses and Henry VII: England 1459-1509, (2004), p. 200:
“… Henry VII was very fortunate to hold onto power and to hand the crown on to his son. Henry’s good fortune can be seen in winning the battles of Bosworth and Stoke; inheriting a nobility that was smaller and less powerful than it had been for a century or more; and inheriting a diplomatic situation where England’s main enemy, France, took a serious interest in Italy. Nonetheless, he did face serious threats at home and abroad which could have unseated his regime at any time in the first fourteen years of his reign. In the end, good fortune was more important than good government in keeping Henry VII on the throne!”

Extract B: Adapted from S. B. Chrimes, Henry VII, (1981), p. 320-321:
‘His reign was unspectacular and though full of surprising and striking events, not at any point sensational, glamorous or dramatic. But his service to the realm were immeasurable, far greater than he himself could have imagined por predicted. His regime produced a pacification, an orderliness, a cohesion, a viability in the forms and machinery of government, a sustained effectiveness without which the stability and consolidation could not have been obtained, and provided an indispensable standpoint for subsequent growth and flowering. It vindicated the achievements of the past, and provided potential for the fluorescence of the later Tudor period. It brought England on towards its ‘manifest destiny’ as Great Britain.

He brought pacification, albeit temporary, into relations with Scotland, the matrimonial alliance that was to usher in the formation of the greater kingdom.’

Extract C: Adapted from Susan Doran, England and Europe, 1485-1603, (1986):
‘Henry’s foreign policy failed in detail; neither the expedition to relieve Brittany, nor the attempts to isolate Ferdinand after 1507 were a success. His policy also proved expensive; between 1505 and 1509 he gave £342,000 in cash, plate or jewels to the Hapsburgs. Yet when Henry died, he left his country and dynasty internationally secure. There was no great threat of foreign military intervention in England’s internal affairs. Henry’s success can be judged by comparing his weakness in 1485 with his strength towards the end of his reign. This success was based on the firm foundation of domestic strength and realistic objectives in foreign policy.’

Thank you so much, I have so many essays and exams this week it will really save my grades!!
Badges: 9
Report 3 months ago
I have some general tips about these essays! Make sure you stay within 5e time period in the question - anything outside of that is irrelevant. Go through each extract and talk about the evidence that supports them, and why they’re convincing, but also talk about each of their limitations - anything that can be disproved or argued against based on something else you’ve learnt.
Make sure you pick out which is most convincing, less convincing, and least convincing. You absolutely should make sure you put which is each in your analysis. Also, mention which is the most convincing, less, and least in your introduction and conclusion.
I know these are pretty basic and general, but I hope these help regardless! I struggled with these so hard at A Level, so these tips definitely helped me up my grades.
Badges: 21
Report 3 months ago
Find some supporting evidence to support your argument. In order to lend more weight to your essay highlight interesting words in each extract that can be used. Make up a short list. Focus on the limitations etc. Pick out the most convincing one and so on from each extract in question too. Circle each one using a blue highlighter pen to do so. Number each paragraph so you have some sort of sensible order to your coursework essay. Never copy directly from the Internet but rather rewrite the facts in your own words as far as possible here.

Quick Reply

Attached files
Write a reply...
new posts
to top
My Feed

See more of what you like on
The Student Room

You can personalise what you see on TSR. Tell us a little about yourself to get started.


How do you prefer to get careers advice?

I like to speak to my friends and family (15)
I like to do my own research online using careers specific websites (87)
I like speaking to the careers advisors at school, college or uni (18)
I prefer to listen watch videos or listen to podcasts of people in my chosen career (13)
Something else (let us know in the thread) (3)

Watched Threads

View All