# A1 mechanic question will there always be 2 tensions on eg a string pulling a mass t

Watch
Announcements

Page 1 of 1

Go to first unread

Skip to page:

will there always be 2 tensions on eg a string pulling a mass tension up and below?

0

reply

Report

#2

(Original post by

will there always be 2 tensions on eg a string pulling a mass tension up and below?

**interlanken-fall**)will there always be 2 tensions on eg a string pulling a mass tension up and below?

If Im right, you're asking about a string connecting two objects which will generally act to pull one object and drag the other object via the tension. In a sense, the string is just transferring the force between the two objects, so one object would drag / pull the other in the same way if they were directly connected.

Instead of considering a single system composed of the two masses, the tension allows you to break it up into two parts. When you add the seperate equations of motion together, the +/-tension cancels and you end up with the equation of motion of the composite system.

Last edited by mqb2766; 1 month ago

0

reply

Why is there 2 forces of tension? Should there only be one and the one pulling the mass

0

reply

Why is there 2 forces of tension one up and one down, shouldn’t there only one pulling the mass

0

reply

Report

#5

(Original post by

Why is there 2 forces of tension? Should there only be one and the one pulling the mass

**interlanken-fall**)Why is there 2 forces of tension? Should there only be one and the one pulling the mass

0

reply

Report

#6

(Original post by

Why is there 2 forces of tension one up and one down, shouldn’t there only one pulling the mass

**interlanken-fall**)Why is there 2 forces of tension one up and one down, shouldn’t there only one pulling the mass

Last edited by mqb2766; 1 month ago

1

reply

Will there always be 2 tensions? In this example they found the tension going up, will the tension going down be the same ?

0

reply

Report

#8

(Original post by

Will there always be 2 tensions? In this example they found the tension going up, will the tension going down be the same ?

**interlanken-fall**)Will there always be 2 tensions? In this example they found the tension going up, will the tension going down be the same ?

If its a "normal" string, under tension then yes. Newton 3 basically applies.

https://physics.stackexchange.com/qu...tons-third-law

(probably better examples if you google).

Last edited by mqb2766; 1 month ago

0

reply

(Original post by

As per the previous post, the "two" tensions are equal and opposite. If you consider P, then Q is dragging P through the tension. If you consider Q, then P is pulling Q through the tension. If you add the equations of motion together, you get the motion of the composite system PQ with no tension being represented.

**mqb2766**)As per the previous post, the "two" tensions are equal and opposite. If you consider P, then Q is dragging P through the tension. If you consider Q, then P is pulling Q through the tension. If you add the equations of motion together, you get the motion of the composite system PQ with no tension being represented.

(Original post by

Can you make it a bit easier to read pls ... orientation, size, which part ...

If its a "normal" string, under tension then yes. Newton 3 basically applies.

https://physics.stackexchange.com/qu...tons-third-law

(probably better examples if you google).

**mqb2766**)Can you make it a bit easier to read pls ... orientation, size, which part ...

If its a "normal" string, under tension then yes. Newton 3 basically applies.

https://physics.stackexchange.com/qu...tons-third-law

(probably better examples if you google).

0

reply

Report

#10

(Original post by

still a bit confused, a the string if facing down the tension is the reason why it still up, wouldn't there be a equal and opposite force on the string so it pushs the masses equally down

**interlanken-fall**)still a bit confused, a the string if facing down the tension is the reason why it still up, wouldn't there be a equal and opposite force on the string so it pushs the masses equally down

Last edited by mqb2766; 1 month ago

0

reply

"find the tension in the string" but shouldn't there be a equal and opposite force on the string so it doesn't go up?

Last edited by interlanken-fall; 1 month ago

0

reply

Report

#12

The tension is pulling up the "object" which consists of the pan and two masses. There must be an equal and opposite tension pulling down the *** (roof?) which is not on your diagram. If the string was not there, the roof(?) would pull up the pan/masses and the pan/masses would pull down the roof(?).

Last edited by mqb2766; 1 month ago

0

reply

Report

#14

(Original post by

diagram in the book

**interlanken-fall**)diagram in the book

Last edited by mqb2766; 1 month ago

0

reply

Report

#15

You are getting mixed up about the objects that the forces are acting on.

First make sure you understand Tension. The best explanations I found were here:

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/307840/182137

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/340573/182137

If that still does not make sense, some people describe Tension as a bit like a "3D pressure":

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/567808/182137

If you can kind of get your head around that, then you need to follow mqb2766's advice and then think about Newton's 3rd laws.

Have a look at this first diagram:

From here:

https://deutsch.physics.ucsc.edu/6A/...ces/node7.html

First you need to consider the forces acting

Now consider the forces acting on the rope. This is labelled in blue. The rope is under tension due to the mass. So at the bottom, there is a force

Now consider the force acting

Unfortunately, a lot of diagrams do not often show the forces in blue (acting

First make sure you understand Tension. The best explanations I found were here:

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/307840/182137

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/340573/182137

If that still does not make sense, some people describe Tension as a bit like a "3D pressure":

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/567808/182137

If you can kind of get your head around that, then you need to follow mqb2766's advice and then think about Newton's 3rd laws.

Have a look at this first diagram:

From here:

https://deutsch.physics.ucsc.edu/6A/...ces/node7.html

First you need to consider the forces acting

**on the mass**. This is labelled in red on the diagram. There will be the force due to gravity which goes down (directed towards the centre of the Earth). This is labelled . Now the mass is applying a**downwards**force**By Newton's Third Law, we therefore have an equal but opposite**__on the rope__.**upward**force, labelled applied__on the mass__**.**Now consider the forces acting on the rope. This is labelled in blue. The rope is under tension due to the mass. So at the bottom, there is a force

**which goes downwards, labelled . At the top of the rope the hand (or it could be a pulley), is applying a force upwards to prevent the rope from simply falling to the floor. This is labelled .***acting on the rope*Now consider the force acting

**ON**the hand (pulley). The hand (pulley) is applying an**upwards**force**ON**the string. So the string applies an equal but opposite force on the pulley. It applies a force**ON**the pulley which acts**down.**This is labelled in green as .Unfortunately, a lot of diagrams do not often show the forces in blue (acting

**ON**the rope). They only show the forces in red and green, i.e. the forces acting on the mass and the hand (pulley) respectively. This is fine because there is an assumption that the force throughout the rope is uniform but the side effect is that it leads to the confusion that you have.
Last edited by 0le; 1 month ago

2

reply

Report

#16

(Original post by

You are getting mixed up about the objects that the forces are acting on.

First make sure you understand Tension. The best explanations I found were here:

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/307840/182137

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/340573/182137

If that still does not make sense, some people describe Tension as a bit like a "3D pressure":

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/567808/182137

If you can kind of get your head around that, then you need to follow mqb2766's advice and then think about Newton's 3rd laws.

Have a look at this first diagram:

From here:

https://deutsch.physics.ucsc.edu/6A/...ces/node7.html

First you need to consider the forces acting

Now consider the forces acting on the rope. This is labelled in blue. The rope is under tension due to the mass. So at the bottom, there is a force

Now consider the force acting

Unfortunately, a lot of diagrams do not often show the forces in blue (acting

**0le**)You are getting mixed up about the objects that the forces are acting on.

First make sure you understand Tension. The best explanations I found were here:

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/307840/182137

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/340573/182137

If that still does not make sense, some people describe Tension as a bit like a "3D pressure":

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/567808/182137

If you can kind of get your head around that, then you need to follow mqb2766's advice and then think about Newton's 3rd laws.

Have a look at this first diagram:

From here:

https://deutsch.physics.ucsc.edu/6A/...ces/node7.html

First you need to consider the forces acting

**on the mass**. This is labelled in red on the diagram. There will be the force due to gravity which goes down (directed towards the centre of the Earth). This is labelled . Now the mass is applying a**downwards**force**By Newton's Third Law, we therefore have an equal but opposite**__on the rope__.**upward**force, labelled applied__on the mass__**.**Now consider the forces acting on the rope. This is labelled in blue. The rope is under tension due to the mass. So at the bottom, there is a force

**which goes downwards, labelled . At the top of the rope the hand (or it could be a pulley), is applying a force upwards to prevent the rope from simply falling to the floor. This is labelled .***acting on the rope*Now consider the force acting

**ON**the hand (pulley). The hand (pulley) is applying an**upwards**force**ON**the string. So the string applies an equal but opposite force on the pulley. It applies a force**ON**the pulley which acts**down.**This is labelled in green as .Unfortunately, a lot of diagrams do not often show the forces in blue (acting

**ON**the rope). They only show the forces in red and green, i.e. the forces acting on the mass and the hand (pulley) respectively. This is fine because there is an assumption that the force throughout the rope is uniform but the side effect is that it leads to the confusion that you have.
0

reply

**0le**)

You are getting mixed up about the objects that the forces are acting on.

First make sure you understand Tension. The best explanations I found were here:

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/307840/182137

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/340573/182137

If that still does not make sense, some people describe Tension as a bit like a "3D pressure":

https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/567808/182137

If you can kind of get your head around that, then you need to follow mqb2766's advice and then think about Newton's 3rd laws.

Have a look at this first diagram:

From here:

https://deutsch.physics.ucsc.edu/6A/...ces/node7.html

First you need to consider the forces acting

**on the mass**. This is labelled in red on the diagram. There will be the force due to gravity which goes down (directed towards the centre of the Earth). This is labelled . Now the mass is applying a

**downwards**force

**By Newton's Third Law, we therefore have an equal but opposite**

__on the rope__.**upward**force, labelled applied

__on the mass__**.**

Now consider the forces acting on the rope. This is labelled in blue. The rope is under tension due to the mass. So at the bottom, there is a force

**which goes downwards, labelled . At the top of the rope the hand (or it could be a pulley), is applying a force upwards to prevent the rope from simply falling to the floor. This is labelled .**

*acting on the rope*Now consider the force acting

**ON**the hand (pulley). The hand (pulley) is applying an

**upwards**force

**ON**the string. So the string applies an equal but opposite force on the pulley. It applies a force

**ON**the pulley which acts

**down.**This is labelled in green as .

Unfortunately, a lot of diagrams do not often show the forces in blue (acting

**ON**the rope). They only show the forces in red and green, i.e. the forces acting on the mass and the hand (pulley) respectively. This is fine because there is an assumption that the force throughout the rope is uniform but the side effect is that it leads to the confusion that you have.

0

reply

X

Page 1 of 1

Go to first unread

Skip to page:

### Quick Reply

Back

to top

to top