Going by your desire to please your traditionalist parents, only marry someone of the same religion as yourself and probable intention to raise your own children to follow the same religious & family traditions that you were brought up with- your most compatible marriage options are:
1) a young religious traditionist virgin from an almost identical background but not biologically related to your family who has never been married and shares your ambitions and values,
2) an arranged marriage with a distant relative that your parents know very well and who meets your personal dealbreakers.
I'm female and support both interfaith marriages & friendships.
Since I was a teenager, I've had so many religious guys of different persuasions try to convert me or ask about an arranged marriage with one of their relatives.
My family tree includes centuries of arranged marriages and many of my friends had arranged marriages as teenagers.
I'm 26 and won't go down the arranged marriage route.
I have a lot of dating dealbreakers and avoid all close involvement with guys that are religious or have enthusiasm for the extended family lifestyle.