Boys, which girl do you prefer?Watch
Has to be the right mix. Too much or too little of any of those attributes will be a turn off. But in my preference it is mainly Innocen, modest and shy until a situation in which confidence is needed.
Innocent and shy is definitely more attractive to me to begin with but I like seeing a girl become more confident as we get closer. So a mix of both
Do guys generally like cute, innocent and shy girls or confident girls?
However, I seem to attract louder confident girls, for some reason... Oh well, I'll take what I'm given lol
This will sound clichéd, but just be yourself. Don't try to conform yourself to what you think guys would like. The real you will become apparent to anyone you're dating sooner or later anyway. If someone doesn't appreciate you for you, it's better to stop dating them and find someone who does appreciate you for you, rather than e.g. trying to force yourself to have some kind of shy personality to hold onto them.