rogerdoger
Badges: 6
Rep:
?
#1
Report Thread starter 1 month ago
#1
The correct answer is C, but why ?? Thank you
Name:  Capture.PNG
Views: 23
Size:  110.3 KB
Last edited by rogerdoger; 1 month ago
0
reply
mqb2766
Badges: 19
Rep:
?
#2
Report 1 month ago
#2
(Original post by rogerdoger)
The correct answer is C, but why ?? Thank you
Name:  Capture.PNG
Views: 23
Size:  110.3 KB
have you tried to sketch it?
te key thing is to think about how B and C must be located if its necessary to go back to X after A.
0
reply
rogerdoger
Badges: 6
Rep:
?
#3
Report Thread starter 1 month ago
#3
(Original post by mqb2766)
have you tried to sketch it?
te key thing is to think about how B and C must be located if its necessary to go back to X after A.
the correct answer choice c is the only choice that forms a triangle path, a loop. but i still don't understand.
Last edited by rogerdoger; 1 month ago
0
reply
mqb2766
Badges: 19
Rep:
?
#4
Report 1 month ago
#4
(Original post by rogerdoger)
c is the only choice that forms a triangle path, a loop. but i still don't understand.
Did you sketch the other (correct) ones?
The key to thinking about it is whether ABC form a triangle or lie on a line.
0
reply
rogerdoger
Badges: 6
Rep:
?
#5
Report Thread starter 1 month ago
#5
(Original post by mqb2766)
Did you sketch the other (correct) ones?
The key to thinking about it is whether ABC form a triangle or lie on a line.
abc forms a triangle path or if i draw it in a line they can all be on a line but from c to x would go past ab on it's way to x. how does this help solve the problem?
0
reply
mqb2766
Badges: 19
Rep:
?
#6
Report 1 month ago
#6
(Original post by rogerdoger)
abc forms a triangle path or if i draw it in a line they can all be on a line but from c to x would go past ab on it's way to x. how does this help solve the problem?
Can you get any of the sequences using the shortest paths for either ABC lying on a triangle or a straight line?

B) is probably the easiest one to start with as thats obviously correct when ABC form a triangle? If you understand why A) is possible, you'll understand why C) is impossible.

I think you've got the germ of the answer in the previous post, but Im not sure if you fully understand. It helps if you upload the pictures corresponding to each relevant answer to be clear.
0
reply
rogerdoger
Badges: 6
Rep:
?
#7
Report Thread starter 1 month ago
#7
B) is probably the easiest one to start with as thats obviously correct when ABC form a triangle? If you understand why A) is possible, you'll understand why C) is impossible.

I think you've got the germ of the answer in the previous post, but Im not sure if you fully understand. It helps if you upload the pictures corresponding to each relevant answer to be clear.
"Can you get any of the sequences using the shortest paths for either ABC lying on a triangle or a straight line?"

i don't understand. can you illustrate?

why can't answer choice c be the shortest path?

all i know is having drawn out the paths for all 5 choices, only answer choice c forms a triangle path (a loop). all the other answer choices form a retraced "U" shape path (no loops in the path).
Last edited by rogerdoger; 1 month ago
0
reply
rogerdoger
Badges: 6
Rep:
?
#8
Report Thread starter 1 month ago
#8
(Original post by mqb2766)
have you tried to sketch it?
te key thing is to think about how B and C must be located if its necessary to go back to X after A.
"Can you get any of the sequences using the shortest paths for either ABC lying on a triangle or a straight line?"

i don't understand. can you illustrate?

why can't answer choice c be the shortest path?

all i know is having drawn out the paths for all 5 choices, only answer choice c forms a triangle path (a loop). all the other answer choices form a retraced "U" shape path. choice b forms a square loop.
Last edited by rogerdoger; 1 month ago
0
reply
mqb2766
Badges: 19
Rep:
?
#9
Report 1 month ago
#9
Only B) is a triangle. For the other choices, the ABC towns must lie on a line, because the shortest distance comes back through X in the middle of the trajectory or X is at the end of the line for E).

If C) was a shortest sequence, it would have to return through B at the end to X. Your diagram should make it clear, if not, upload it?
Last edited by mqb2766; 1 month ago
0
reply
rogerdoger
Badges: 6
Rep:
?
#10
Report Thread starter 1 month ago
#10
(Original post by mqb2766)
Only B) is a triangle. For the other choices, the ABC towns must lie on a line, because the shortest distance comes back through X in the middle of the trajectory or X is at the end of the line for E).

If C) was a shortest sequence, it would have to return through B at the end to X. Your diagram should make it clear, if not, upload it?
"Only B) is a triangle. "

choice B makes a square when i draw it out. not a triangle. i'm confused. i don't see the triangle you're talking about.

" For the other choices, the ABC towns must lie on a line, because the shortest distance comes back through X in the middle of the trajectory or X is at the end of the line for E)."
yes, i see that.

"If C) was a shortest sequence, it would have to return through B at the end to X. Your diagram should make it clear, if not, upload it?"
the end town could be either B or C at the end to X, couldn't it?
i still don't get why C couldn't be the shortest route compared to choice A. if you flatten the path into a line, choice A and C could travel the same distance.
0
reply
mqb2766
Badges: 19
Rep:
?
#11
Report 1 month ago
#11
(Original post by rogerdoger)
"Only B) is a triangle. "

choice B makes a square when i draw it out. not a triangle. i'm confused. i don't see the triangle you're talking about.

" For the other choices, the ABC towns must lie on a line, because the shortest distance comes back through X in the middle of the trajectory or X is at the end of the line for E)."
yes, i see that.

"If C) was a shortest sequence, it would have to return through B at the end to X. Your diagram should make it clear, if not, upload it?"
the end town could be either B or C at the end to X, couldn't it?
i still don't get why C couldn't be the shortest route compared to choice A. if you flatten the path into a line, choice A and C could travel the same distance.
I was talking about just the towns ABC. So when you add X in, then it could lie inside or outside the triangle, so ...

As for further explanation, pls upload your diagram / what you think. I've given the answer, if you think there could be a different scenario, upload the diagram.
0
reply
rogerdoger
Badges: 6
Rep:
?
#12
Report Thread starter 1 month ago
#12
A) A=X=B=C
B) X-A
| |
B-C
C) A=X-B
\ |
C
D) C=X=B=A
E) X=A=B=C

best i could do. it won't do spacing.

now what?
Last edited by rogerdoger; 1 month ago
0
reply
mqb2766
Badges: 19
Rep:
?
#13
Report 1 month ago
#13
(Original post by rogerdoger)
A) A=X=B=C
B) X-A
| |
B-C
C) A=X-B
\ |
C
D) C=X=B=A
E) X=A=B=C

best i could do. it won't do spacing.

now what?
For C) can you see why the sequence wants them both to be in line, but also not be in a line? Hence its impossible. On the way from A-C, it passes through X and B which means theyre in a line. But on the way back to X, B is omitted, hence they're not in a line. Hence impossible.
0
reply
rogerdoger
Badges: 6
Rep:
?
#14
Report Thread starter 1 month ago
#14
A) A=X=B=C
B) X-A
| |
B-C
C) A=X-B
\ |
C
D) C=X=B=A
E) X=A=B=C


now what?

(Original post by mqb2766)
For C) can you see why the sequence wants them both to be in line, but also not be in a line? Hence its impossible. On the way from A-C, it passes through X and B which means theyre in a line. But on the way back to X, B is omitted, hence they're not in a line. Hence impossible.
"On the way from A-C, it passes through X and B which means theyre in a line."
yes, i see that.

"But on the way back to X, B is omitted,"
yes, i see that

"...hence they're not in a line."
ok, yes, i see that now.


Hence impossible."
this part i don't understand. couldn't the triangle be made infinitesimally smaller and smaller to make the route shorter and shorter?

why couldn't choice B the answer? it makes a bigger loop of 4 cities where choice C makes a loop of 3 cities.
0
reply
mqb2766
Badges: 19
Rep:
?
#15
Report 1 month ago
#15
(Original post by rogerdoger)
A) A=X=B=C
B) X-A
| |
B-C
C) A=X-B
\ |
C
D) C=X=B=A
E) X=A=B=C


now what?


"On the way from A-C, it passes through X and B which means theyre in a line."
yes, i see that.

"But on the way back to X, B is omitted,"
yes, i see that

"...hence they're not in a line."
ok, yes, i see that now.


Hence impossible."
this part i don't understand. couldn't the triangle be made infinitesimally smaller and smaller to make the route shorter and shorter?

why couldn't choice B the answer? it makes a bigger loop of 4 cities where choice C makes a loop of 3 cities.
Without being funny, it really would help for you to draw what you're suggesting and upload the image.

For C) you need C to be both inline with A, B and X (outward journey) and not inline with B, X (return journey). It can't be both?
B) is when A, B, C are in a triangle?
Last edited by mqb2766; 1 month ago
0
reply
rogerdoger
Badges: 6
Rep:
?
#16
Report Thread starter 1 month ago
#16
A) A=X=B=C
B) X-A
| |
B-C
C) A=X-B
\ |
C
D) C=X=B=A
E) X=A=B=C


now what?

(Original post by mqb2766)
For C) can you see why the sequence wants them both to be in line, but also not be in a line? Hence its impossible. On the way from A-C, it passes through X and B which means theyre in a line. But on the way back to X, B is omitted, hence they're not in a line. Hence impossible.
"On the way from A-C, it passes through X and B which means theyre in a line."
yes, i see that.

"But on the way back to X, B is omitted,"
yes, i see that

"...hence they're not in a line."
ok, yes, i see that now.


Hence impossible."
this part i don't understand. couldn't the triangle be made infinitesimally smaller and smaller to make the route shorter and shorter?

why couldn't choice B be the answer? it makes a bigger loop of 4 cities where choice C makes a loop of 3 cities.

(Original post by mqb2766)
Without being funny, it really would help for you to draw what you're suggesting and upload the image.

For C) you need C to be both inline with A, B and X (outward journey) and not inline with B, X (return journey). It can't be both?
B) is when A, B, C are in a triangle?
"For C) you need C to be both inline with A, B and X (outward journey) and not inline with B, X (return journey). It can't be both?"
i don't understand. why do all 4 towns have to be inline? the instructions only said the paths between towns are straight lines. that implies the cities can be arranged in any geometry and not limited to a line?


"B) is when A, B, C are in a triangle?"
i don't understand. i don't see a triangle for choice b. when i drew the path out for choice b, i got square XABC. no where did i see a triangle ABC.
X to A, A to B, B to C, C to X. each leg of the trip makes up the 4 sides of a square.
Last edited by rogerdoger; 1 month ago
0
reply
rogerdoger
Badges: 6
Rep:
?
#17
Report Thread starter 1 month ago
#17
couldn't the triangle XBC be made infinitesimally smaller and smaller to make the route shorter and shorter?

why couldn't choice B be the answer? it makes a bigger loop of 4 cities where choice C makes a loop of 3 cities.
0
reply
mqb2766
Badges: 19
Rep:
?
#18
Report 1 month ago
#18
"For C) you need C to be both inline with A, B and X (outward journey) and not inline with B, X (return journey). It can't be both?"
i don't understand. why do all 4 towns have to be inline? the instructions only said the paths between towns are straight lines. that implies the cities can be arranged in any geometry and not limited to a line?

Not if the shortest path is a given. Pls draw the scenario youre describing and upload your diagram.


"B) is when A, B, C are in a triangle?"
i don't understand. i don't see a triangle for choice b. when i drew the path out for choice b, i got square XABC. no where did i see a triangle ABC.
X to A, A to B, B to C, C to X. each leg of the trip makes up the 4 sides of a square.

Again, I was talking just about ABC for the triangle. The X could be in several places, one o which would produce a square. See #11.
0
reply
rogerdoger
Badges: 6
Rep:
?
#19
Report Thread starter 1 month ago
#19
"Not if the shortest path is a given. Pls draw the scenario youre describing and upload your diagram."
i did already. please see #12. here it is again:

A=X-B
\ |
C



"Again, I was talking just about ABC for the triangle. The X could be in several places, one o which would produce a square. See #11."
again see #12.
there is no triangle ABC for answer choice B. where were you seeing triangle ABC for answer choice B? i see a square XABC but i don't know where you are getting this triangle ABC. there is no triangle ABC for choice B. can you draw it out? i have no idea what triangle you're talking about for choice B.
Last edited by rogerdoger; 1 month ago
0
reply
mqb2766
Badges: 19
Rep:
?
#20
Report 1 month ago
#20
(Original post by rogerdoger)
"Not if the shortest path is a given. Pls draw the scenario youre describing and upload your diagram."
i did already. please see #12. here it is again:

A=X-B
\ |
C
The shortest path between A and C here is AC, not the sequence AXBC as given in the question. Sketching the diagram means it must satisfy the "solution". This doesn't.
Last edited by mqb2766; 1 month ago
0
reply
X

Quick Reply

Attached files
Write a reply...
Reply
new posts
Back
to top
Latest
My Feed

See more of what you like on
The Student Room

You can personalise what you see on TSR. Tell us a little about yourself to get started.

Personalise

Feeling behind at school/college? What is the best thing your teachers could to help you catch up?

Extra compulsory independent learning activities (eg, homework tasks) (18)
7.47%
Run extra compulsory lessons or workshops (36)
14.94%
Focus on making the normal lesson time with them as high quality as possible (43)
17.84%
Focus on making the normal learning resources as high quality/accessible as possible (34)
14.11%
Provide extra optional activities, lessons and/or workshops (63)
26.14%
Assess students, decide who needs extra support and focus on these students (47)
19.5%

Watched Threads

View All