# Basic torque problem

#1
So I saw two very similar problems on Youtube videos:

https://ibb.co/YjNQSGr
https://ibb.co/NTTmFSF

I'm a bit confused now. For the first image, the person said that only the vertical component of the tension provides moments so that
L/2 *Tcosθ =W1*L.

However, for the second image, the other guy said that the the whole tension provides moments so that T*Lsinθ = mg* L +Mg*L/2

So for a question like this, is the vertical component of the tension the only part that provides moments? Or it's actually the whole tension.
In my opinion, I think only the vertical component of the tension contributes to the equilibrium because the horizontal component of the tension acts directly on the pivot, which means no turning effect would be caused by it. Hence, only the vertical component provides moments

Thanks
Last edited by long_vacation; 9 months ago
0
9 months ago
#2
(Original post by long_vacation)
So I saw two very similar problems on Youtube videos:

https://ibb.co/YjNQSGr
https://ibb.co/NTTmFSF

I'm a bit confused now. For the first image, the person said that only the vertical component of the tension provides moments so that
L/2 *Tcosθ =W1*L.

However, for the second image, the other guy said that the the whole tension provides moments so that T*Lsinθ = mg* L +Mg*L/2

So for a question like this, is the vertical component of the tension the only part that provides moments? Or it's actually the whole tension.
In my opinion, I think only the vertical component of the tension contributes to the equilibrium because the horizontal component of the tension acts directly on the pivot, which means no turning effect would be caused by it. Hence, only the vertical component provides moments

Thanks
They are both correct.
The tension in the cable privides an anticlockwise moment about the pivot. That is clear.
To calculate it you either:
Take the vertical component of the tension and multiply by the whole length of the beam. (If the cable is attached to the end)
or
Take the whole tension and multiply it by the perpendicular distance of the cable from the pivot. (d3 in the diagram he has there)
Last edited by Stonebridge; 9 months ago
0
#3
(Original post by Stonebridge)
They are both correct.
The tension in the cable privides an anticlockwise moment about the pivot. That is clear.
To calculate it you either:
Take the vertical component of the tension and multiply by the whole length of the beam. (If the cable is attached to the end)
or
Take the whole tension and multiply it by the perpendicular distance of the cable from the pivot. (d3 in the diagram he has there)
Thank you. So these two methods will give us the same moment right?
0
9 months ago
#4
(Original post by long_vacation)
Thank you. So these two methods will give us the same moment right?
Yes, so long as you get the correct angle and formula for the vertical component, and the correct geometry for the perpendicular distance.
0
#5
(Original post by Stonebridge)
Yes, so long as you get the correct angle and formula for the vertical component, and the correct geometry for the perpendicular distance.
Thank you so much
0
X

new posts
Back
to top
Latest
My Feed

### Oops, nobody has postedin the last few hours.

Why not re-start the conversation?

see more

### See more of what you like onThe Student Room

You can personalise what you see on TSR. Tell us a little about yourself to get started.

### Poll

Join the discussion

#### Have you done work experience at school/college?

Yes (155)
41.67%
Not yet, but I will soon (69)
18.55%
No (148)
39.78%