- Forums
###### Roots of unity

In your answer to (b), I don't think you can assume that the z in this part is the same as the z in (a). In other words, I don't think you can replace the 1 by z^{5}. But you have got to a point where you effectively have (something)^{5} = 1, so you could now use your answer to (a) to write (something) = (a list of different options that you've already worked out), and take it from there.

Original post by Pangol

In your answer to (b), I don't think you can assume that the z in this part is the same as the z in (a). In other words, I don't think you can replace the 1 by z^{5}. But you have got to a point where you effectively have (something)^{5} = 1, so you could now use your answer to (a) to write (something) = (a list of different options that you've already worked out), and take it from there.

Ok, i've got to the required solution by saying that (z-1)^5/(z+1)^5=1

so (z-1)/(z+1)=w^k

z=(w^k+1)/(1-w^k) which is correct

however what i don't understand is you don't reach the same conclusion if you start with (z+1)^5/(z-1)^5=1 and im not sure why?

Edit: just looked at it a bit more and is it because having (z-1) as the denominator could run into problems due to one of the roots being 1, so dividing by 0?

(edited 1 year ago)

Original post by Skiwi

Ok, i've got to the required solution by saying that (z-1)^5/(z+1)^5=1

so (z-1)/(z+1)=w^k

z=(w^k+1)/(1-w^k) which is correct

however what i don't understand is you don't reach the same conclusion if you start with (z+1)^5/(z-1)^5=1 and im not sure why?

Edit: just looked at it a bit more and is it because having (z-1) as the denominator could run into problems due to one of the roots being 1, so dividing by 0?

so (z-1)/(z+1)=w^k

z=(w^k+1)/(1-w^k) which is correct

however what i don't understand is you don't reach the same conclusion if you start with (z+1)^5/(z-1)^5=1 and im not sure why?

Edit: just looked at it a bit more and is it because having (z-1) as the denominator could run into problems due to one of the roots being 1, so dividing by 0?

That seems likely to be it. I hadn't actually done it myself, but if it has got you the answers you were expecting, it's got to be the way to go.

Original post by Pangol

For (e), I think you need to look at the polynomial you vertified in (d) and apply your knowledge of what it means for it to have a z^{2} coeffiecient of 10, in terms of the roots of the polynomial.

Do you mind expanding on this slightly, im not too sure what to do?

Original post by Skiwi

Ok, i've got to the required solution by saying that (z-1)^5/(z+1)^5=1

so (z-1)/(z+1)=w^k

z=(w^k+1)/(1-w^k) which is correct

however what i don't understand is you don't reach the same conclusion if you start with (z+1)^5/(z-1)^5=1 and im not sure why?

Edit: just looked at it a bit more and is it because having (z-1) as the denominator could run into problems due to one of the roots being 1, so dividing by 0?

so (z-1)/(z+1)=w^k

z=(w^k+1)/(1-w^k) which is correct

however what i don't understand is you don't reach the same conclusion if you start with (z+1)^5/(z-1)^5=1 and im not sure why?

Edit: just looked at it a bit more and is it because having (z-1) as the denominator could run into problems due to one of the roots being 1, so dividing by 0?

Agree about the approach, but note you'll only have 4 solutions (on the imaginary axis) and the divide by 0 is still a problem when you have

z=(w^k+1)/(1-w^k)

with k=0

(edited 1 year ago)

Original post by mqb2766

Agree about the approach, but note you'll only have 4 solutions (on the imaginary axis) and the divide by 0 is still a problem when you have

z=(w^k+1)/(1-w^k)

z=(w^k+1)/(1-w^k)

The next part of the question introduces a restriction of k having to be 1,2,3,4 which i think removes the problems

Original post by Skiwi

The next part of the question introduces a restriction of k having to be 1,2,3,4 which i think removes the problems

Agree, the problem is w=1, so k=0, but the answer to b) is 4 values. The other representation should work, why do you think it doesnt?

(edited 1 year ago)

Original post by mqb2766

Agree, the problem is w=1, so k=0, but the answer to b) is 4 values.

So i list the expression of z 4 times replacing k with 1,2,3,4 each time?

Original post by Skiwi

Do you mind expanding on this slightly, im not too sure what to do?

It's an idea from the roots of polynomials topic. You should know things about certain combinations of the roots of a polynomial and the coefficients of that polynomial. (Sorry this is vague, don't want to spell it out too much!)

Original post by Pangol

It's an idea from the roots of polynomials topic. You should know things about certain combinations of the roots of a polynomial and the coefficients of that polynomial. (Sorry this is vague, don't want to spell it out too much!)

I think i'm somewhat on the right lines,

what i've done is:

The equation has 4 roots w,w^2,w^3,w^4

we know from roots of polynomials that ab+ay+ad+by+bd+yd=2

so w^3+w^4+2w^5+w^6+w^7=2

w+w^2+w^3+w^4=0

a bit stuck on how to progress as this is clearly wrong as they should add to -1

@Pangol @mqb2766 thanks for the help, i finally managed to show that is was equal to 2.

5z^4+10z^2+1=0 has 4 roots, the ones found in part c.

if we let y=z^2 then we get 5y^2+10y+1=0

this quadratic has 2 roots, (icotpi/5)^2 and (icot2pi/5)^2. ( i picked these because it's what the question required but you could use the 3pi and 4pi terms as well due to the fact that the pi/5 and 4pi/5 square to the same value, ditto for 2pi/5 and 3pi/5)

from roots of polynomials alpha+beta=-b/a

(icotpi/5)^2+(icot2pi/5)^2=-2

cot^2(pi/5)+cot^2(2pi/5)=2 as needed.

If i've missed anything/made an assumption or i've done it in a slightly harder way please tell me.

5z^4+10z^2+1=0 has 4 roots, the ones found in part c.

if we let y=z^2 then we get 5y^2+10y+1=0

this quadratic has 2 roots, (icotpi/5)^2 and (icot2pi/5)^2. ( i picked these because it's what the question required but you could use the 3pi and 4pi terms as well due to the fact that the pi/5 and 4pi/5 square to the same value, ditto for 2pi/5 and 3pi/5)

from roots of polynomials alpha+beta=-b/a

(icotpi/5)^2+(icot2pi/5)^2=-2

cot^2(pi/5)+cot^2(2pi/5)=2 as needed.

If i've missed anything/made an assumption or i've done it in a slightly harder way please tell me.

Sounds like you're there / nearly there. Did you get it sorted last night why

(z-1)/(z+1)=w^k => z = (1+w^k)/(1-w^k)

(z+1)/(z-1)=w^k => z = -(1+w^k)/(1-w^k)

give the same result (k=1..4) for b)? k=0 is not a solution in both cases.

For e) going down your original approach, though its z, not w:

- cot(pi/5)cot(2pi/5) - cot(pi/5)cot(3pi/5) - cot(pi/5)cot(4pi/5) - cot(2pi/5)cot(4pi/5) - cot(2pi/5)cot(3pi/5) - cot(3pi/5)cot(4pi/5) = 2

Then just use cot(x) = -cot(pi-x) supplementary identity and stuff cancels. It follows directly on from c) and d).

Note here that the transformation (z+1)/(z-1) maps a circle (root of unity) to a line (imaginary axis). Its a simple Mobius transformation.

(z-1)/(z+1)=w^k => z = (1+w^k)/(1-w^k)

(z+1)/(z-1)=w^k => z = -(1+w^k)/(1-w^k)

give the same result (k=1..4) for b)? k=0 is not a solution in both cases.

For e) going down your original approach, though its z, not w:

- cot(pi/5)cot(2pi/5) - cot(pi/5)cot(3pi/5) - cot(pi/5)cot(4pi/5) - cot(2pi/5)cot(4pi/5) - cot(2pi/5)cot(3pi/5) - cot(3pi/5)cot(4pi/5) = 2

Then just use cot(x) = -cot(pi-x) supplementary identity and stuff cancels. It follows directly on from c) and d).

Note here that the transformation (z+1)/(z-1) maps a circle (root of unity) to a line (imaginary axis). Its a simple Mobius transformation.

(edited 1 year ago)

Original post by mqb2766

Sounds like you're there / nearly there. Did you get it sorted last night why

(z-1)/(z+1)=w^k => z = (1+w^k)/(1-w^k)

(z+1)/(z-1)=w^k => z = -(1+w^k)/(1-w^k)

give the same result (k=1..4) for b)? k=0 is not a solution in both cases.

For e) going down your original approach, though its z, not w:

- cot(pi/5)cot(2pi/5) - cot(pi/5)cot(3pi/5) - cot(pi/5)cot(4pi/5) - cot(2pi/5)cot(4pi/5) - cot(2pi/5)cot(3pi/5) - cot(3pi/5)cot(4pi/5) = 2

Then just use cot(x) = -cot(pi-x) supplementary identity and stuff cancels. It follows directly on from c) and d).

Note here that the transformation (z+1)/(z-1) maps a circle (root of unity) to a line (imaginary axis). Its a simple Mobius transformation.

(z-1)/(z+1)=w^k => z = (1+w^k)/(1-w^k)

(z+1)/(z-1)=w^k => z = -(1+w^k)/(1-w^k)

give the same result (k=1..4) for b)? k=0 is not a solution in both cases.

For e) going down your original approach, though its z, not w:

- cot(pi/5)cot(2pi/5) - cot(pi/5)cot(3pi/5) - cot(pi/5)cot(4pi/5) - cot(2pi/5)cot(4pi/5) - cot(2pi/5)cot(3pi/5) - cot(3pi/5)cot(4pi/5) = 2

Then just use cot(x) = -cot(pi-x) supplementary identity and stuff cancels. It follows directly on from c) and d).

Note here that the transformation (z+1)/(z-1) maps a circle (root of unity) to a line (imaginary axis). Its a simple Mobius transformation.

I get the bit for part b now. I like your method for part e a lot more than how I approached it, it's solely algebraic and doesn't rely on the calculator to show that the squared roots give the 4 original roots.

Although I have no idea what a mobius transformation is.

Original post by Skiwi

I get the bit for part b now. I like your method for part e a lot more than how I approached it, it's solely algebraic and doesn't rely on the calculator to show that the squared roots give the 4 original roots.

Although I have no idea what a mobius transformation is.

Although I have no idea what a mobius transformation is.

The part e) pretty much followed on from the previous parts and you had the right idea, but seemed to use the roots for w not z. The question was leading you through the map from (points on) the unit circle (w space) to (points on) the imaginary axis (z space) using the w = (z+1)/(z-1) map.

The mobius stuff was for you to google if youre interested there are a few videos etc on it. Its beyond a level, but its a fairly famous complex map and some of the visualizations are intereting. For this mapping

(z+1)/(z-1) = 1 + 2/(z-1) = w

If you think about the complex planes for w and z. The origin in w (0,0) is mapped to z (-1,0). The unit circle in w is mapped to the imaginary axis in z (this question). The positive real axis in z is mapped to the real axis segment (-1,1) in w etc. But w = (1,0) (again this question) has no solution (mapped to infinity in z space).

Its obviously beyond whats necessary for the question though.

(edited 1 year ago)

Original post by mqb2766

The part e) pretty much followed on from the previous parts and you had the right idea, but seemed to use the roots for w not z. The question was leading you through the map from (points on) the unit circle (w space) to (points on) the imaginary axis (z space) using the w = (z+1)/(z-1) map.

The mobius stuff was for you to google if youre interested there are a few videos etc on it. Its beyond a level, but its a fairly famous complex map and some of the visualizations are intereting. For this mapping

(z+1)/(z-1) = 1 + 2/(z-1) = w

If you think about the complex planes for w and z. The origin in w (0,0) is mapped to z (-1,0). The unit circle in w is mapped to the imaginary axis in z (this question). The positive real axis in z is mapped to the real axis segment (-1,1) in w etc. But w = (1,0) (again this question) has no solution (mapped to infinity in z space).

Its obviously beyond whats necessary for the question though.

The mobius stuff was for you to google if youre interested there are a few videos etc on it. Its beyond a level, but its a fairly famous complex map and some of the visualizations are intereting. For this mapping

(z+1)/(z-1) = 1 + 2/(z-1) = w

If you think about the complex planes for w and z. The origin in w (0,0) is mapped to z (-1,0). The unit circle in w is mapped to the imaginary axis in z (this question). The positive real axis in z is mapped to the real axis segment (-1,1) in w etc. But w = (1,0) (again this question) has no solution (mapped to infinity in z space).

Its obviously beyond whats necessary for the question though.

Ok thanks a lot.

I'll pretend i understood half of what you said beyond the first paragraph. I'll try to find some videos and come back later to see if it makes sense then.

- TMUA yotta mock paper 1
- Using complex numbers to plot coordinates
- How to find ALL roots of this complex number?
- Complex numbers
- Quadratic equation in cos(2pi/5)
- Complex roots
- Complex numbers
- Peace is rooted in the depths of Chinese
- OCR Further Maths Core Pure 1 25th May 2023
- Roots of unity sum
- Complex number question
- Roots of unity and polynomials
- Edexcel A-level Further Mathematics Paper 2 (9FM0 02) - 5th June 2023 [Exam Chat]
- Geometric Sum proof
- Question 1 from 25th British Mathematical Olympiad, 1988
- edexcel further maths core pure paper 1
- Tenancy take over at unity square Liverpool for 2022/23
- Tenancy take over at unity square Liverpool for 23
- Accommodation
- Politics A-Level help

- School won’t enter student for UKMT maths challenge
- September 2024
- Deferral Fees
- will my chosen a levels be too difficult?
- Official Veterinary Medicine Applicants thread 2024 entry
- Official University of the Arts London Applicant Thread for 2024
- Pupillage Application 2023-2024
- Official University of Glasgow Applicant Thread for 2024
- Official: University of East Anglia (UEA) A100 2024 Entry
- asian preference getting annoying
- Official Cambridge Postgraduate Applicants 2024 Thread
- UBS degree apprenticeship 2024
- Verdicts on Glasgow?
- Official Oxford 2024 Postgraduate Applicants Thread
- i’m worried about my relationship
- Official Dental Hygiene and Therapy (Oral Health Science) 2024 Entry Thread
- Oxford MSc in Digital Scholarship 2024
- Next team assessment day! HELP PLZ
- Tatakae L's GYG Journey
- Official University of York Applicant Thread 2024

- University of Sunderland A100 2024 Entry
- CTAM: Count to a million (Part 79)
- Oxford Postgraduate Offer Holders 2024
- Rolls Royce
- York Law 2024
- Is it too late to start Uni at 21?
- Newcastle Dentistry 2024 Entry
- Msc / apprenticeship speech and language therapy
- What is the most social accommodation at the Uni of Notts?
- Law offers - 2024 entry
- is my mum mean to not bail me out of a saturday detention ?
- Business graded unit 2
- Dyson Institute 2024 Applicants
- Really struggling to get a job.
- Official Royal Veterinary College Applicant Thread for 2024
- Is she interested
- Navigating Experience Days: a personal journey
- LNAT for King's college
- Solo Travelling
- Sheffield Dentistry 2024 Entry

- UKMT Intermediate Math Challenge 2024 - Discussion
- Help with complex summation further maths a levels
- GCSE Mathematics Study Group 2023-2024
- Could I have some help with this suvat question?
- MAT practice
- A-level Mathematics Study Group 2023-2024
- Alevel Maths Question
- weird cosine question
- Series function not differentiable at a point
- hyperbolic function catenary problem

- Mock set 4 paper 2 q14 a level maths (4 distinct points)
- can anyone answer this A level vectors question (very challenging)
- STEP foundation module help pls
- Ukmt IMC 2024
- ukmt imc
- This maths question is driving me crazy
- Maths Mechanics
- Confused on surds question
- HNC MATHS A2 Task 3 (Radio Transmitters)
- Senior Maths Challenge 2023

- UKMT Intermediate Math Challenge 2024 - Discussion
- Help with complex summation further maths a levels
- GCSE Mathematics Study Group 2023-2024
- Could I have some help with this suvat question?
- MAT practice
- A-level Mathematics Study Group 2023-2024
- Alevel Maths Question
- weird cosine question
- Series function not differentiable at a point
- hyperbolic function catenary problem

- Mock set 4 paper 2 q14 a level maths (4 distinct points)
- can anyone answer this A level vectors question (very challenging)
- STEP foundation module help pls
- Ukmt IMC 2024
- ukmt imc
- This maths question is driving me crazy
- Maths Mechanics
- Confused on surds question
- HNC MATHS A2 Task 3 (Radio Transmitters)
- Senior Maths Challenge 2023

The Student Room and The Uni Guide are both part of The Student Room Group.

© Copyright The Student Room 2024 all rights reserved

The Student Room and The Uni Guide are trading names of The Student Room Group Ltd.

Register Number: 04666380 (England and Wales), VAT No. 806 8067 22 Registered Office: Imperial House, 2nd Floor, 40-42 Queens Road, Brighton, East Sussex, BN1 3XB