Do you think Cheryl Cole is too thin?

There's a lot in magazines and newspapers these days about Cheryl Cole being too thin, and how she's 'wasting away' and 'emaciated'. I personally think she looks perfectly healthy and not underweight at all. She doesn't have a figure like Kelly Brook because of her genes, not because she's underweight. She's short and has a small frame so even if she's a size 4 or 6 it doesn't mean she's unhealthy. I think it's unfair on all the girls who are naturally thinner than Cheryl and aren't blessed with a shape as nice hers who probably feel even more insecure about being 'too skinny' even though they can't do anything about it.

Reply 1

Simpsonsmania

1

Shes slim alrite.... Her accent is a bit annoying as well.

Reply 2

an_end_has_a_start

16

her weight seems to fluctuate alot... i think on some photos she looks painfully skinny but on others it suits her small frame

Reply 3

Eragon452

2

She looks too thin to be healthy, yeah

Reply 4

Ilora-Danon

3

Having seen pictures of her at a size 10, I can wholeheartedly say I think she looks rough at a size 6. She was absolutely STUNNING as a size 10, I don't understand why she has to look like a rake, tbh. There was nothing wrong with her before, imo.

Reply 5

ViolatedTreason

13

definately.

people being too thin makes them highly unattractive too..

Reply 6

Magnanimity

14

Jennifer_l85

There's a lot in magazines and newspapers these days about Cheryl Cole being too thin, and how she's 'wasting away' and 'emaciated'. I personally think she looks perfectly healthy and not underweight at all. She doesn't have a figure like Kelly Brook because of her genes, not because she's underweight. She's short and has a small frame so even if she's a size 4 or 6 it doesn't mean she's unhealthy. I think it's unfair on all the girls who are naturally thinner than Cheryl and aren't blessed with a shape as nice hers who probably feel even more insecure about being 'too skinny' even though they can't do anything about it.

I think it's the change in weight they mean.

But yeah, too thin in my book.

Reply 7

fastpalladium

Simpsonsmania

Shes slim alrite.... Her accent is a bit annoying as well.

I have to say that Cheryl Cole has caught my eye recently, I think she's very attractive, surprisingly I find her accent quite sexy too and the fact that she's not afraid to stand up for herself. But have to admit that she's bordering on the line of looking too thin at the moment.

Reply 8

All at once

10

Yeah, still wouldn't kick her out of bed, but she looked better before. It's all about The Saturdays now. :yep:

Spoiler

Reply 9

katechar_X

13

Ceryl Cole..I think is gorgeous...and i think shes looks a perfectly fine weight as she does have quite a small frame, but it wouldnt be a disaster if she did gain a couple of pounds..

Reply 10

miki_da_magpie

2

Think she's looking great on the x-factor if thats "recent". Sure on the skinny side, but she looks healthy to me. Her accent btw, is hot as hell. Love the accent up here

Reply 11

jeh_jeh

2

Sorry, OP, but I disagree. She's too thin. If she'd been like that "forever" (a la Keira Knightley), then maybe I'd be inclined to agree with you, but the fact that she has been a size 10, and looked perfectly healthy at it, signals to me that she is too thin and not naturally like that. Although, tbh, the fact that any woman can be the size of a pre-pubescent child (when women are designed to be able to bear children, etc) is still a bit dubious in my book.

caaakeeey

Spoiler

Yeah but

Reply 14

miki_da_magpie

2

jeh_jeh

Although, tbh, the fact that any woman can be the size of a pre-pubescent child (when women are designed to be able to bear children, etc) is still a bit dubious in my book.

Tbh, there is absolutely no need for that.

Ja, she is.

What a disgustingly judgmental topic. I never understand why its acceptable to slate celebs for being thin but not for being fat.

Reply 17

ASprinkleOfPixieDust

I think she is gorgeous but do think she's gotten a bit too thin recently. Sometimes it seems as though Girls Aloud are in competition with each other to see who can be the thinnest, it's a little scary as only Nicola (? red hair) actually seems to be naturally that thin.

Reply 18

Ilora-Danon

3

Because, as a celebrity, you automatically become 'public property' as it were (and I'm not saying I agree with it, but it's the truth). We can discuss anyone we like tbf - whether it's Charlotte Church for being a heffer, or Cheryl Cole for being a twig - it's harmless banter!!

Reply 19

icapturethecastle

16

i think cheryl cole is gorgeous, imo, her figure is nice and so is her weight for her height...although i do agree that she wouldn't look bad if she gained some weight

Do you think Cheryl Cole is too thin?

Related discussions

Articles for you