Hi all!
Back with another review. So, I forgot to do this yesterday because I did finish the book yesterday in one sitting. (Spoilerπ) I was crying (end of spoilerπ). I finished the book and ten minutes later came on TSR to write up my review but I just couldn't stop the damn tears and decided not to post my review yesterdayππ If you think I'm being dramatic, you're wrong. My younger sister walked past my room giving me a dirty ass look because my eyes were red and there was snot running down my nose with a pile of used tissue next to me (i was a mess ok?π my boy deserved better. and plus i'm not good with emotional/traumatic things but i love to read them anyways??). This book literally had me crying, screaming, throwing, up, pulling my hair out. It really left me devastated, distraught and utterly sure that I'm going to think about Achilles and Patroclus for everyday for the rest of my lifetime.
So, with that being said, let's get into the review.
THE SONG OF ACHILLES : MADELINE MILLER
genre: contemporary fantasy/romance/historical fiction
age rating: 14+ (mild but not explicit content)
characters: 5/5 (unexpected, but i feel that it's deserved)
plot: 4/5 (enjoyed it; it's where the 'historical' element comes in)
overall rating: 4.5/5 (loved it)
Firstly, I was to start by taking a moment to appreciate Miller writing. I mean it was very good. Certain things/events/moments she described so impeccably. From my own observation, Miller has a way of manipulating words to make them sound beautiful to read on paper and at the same time, make them power enough to elicit strong emotion out of readers (well at least me). There are certain moments where this is obvious, but I'm trying my best to refrain myself from giving any spoilers so I will not be giving out any examples. I just feel like the words in the book oozed eloquence. I don't know if this is a dramatic statement to make, but I personally felt this way. Her writing is gorgeous and made my personal reading experience a 10/10 because even with the wordiness, I found the book relatively easy to understand. It wasn't complex or pseudo-coded. Just simple yet powerful and beautiful. Oh, and the way she writes the romance is to amazing too. The whole story is dedicated to the love and bond between Achilles and Patroclus, however I feel like this book didn't have their romance sticking out like a sore thumb like you would expect. It's there, holistically and all throughout, but so carefully placed that it's a clear vessel that capture the essence of their love story without overriding the overarching plot of the story which the pre, during and post Trojan war. It stays perfectly true to the plot whilst Miller adds the uniqueness of her interpretation of Homer's Iliad which is the homosexual, rather than familial, love between the two main heroes and incorporates it in such a way the plot that the two flow in perfect rhythmic harmony. She pulled it off so well and I'm sure this is a thing not many writers can do, not to even say do it well.
Secondly, I want to talk about the characters. The characters. I grew very attached from Patroclus from the beginning and all throughout the continuity of the story. I don't know if this was because it was simply written in his POV, but something about his character really made me create a strong emotional bond with him. (SPOILER) He is the black sheep of his family, someone who struggles to live up to expectations and social norms. He is not the Prince his land wishes for. He is not the soldier his Father wanted. He is like his mother, who too is outcasted and neglected from society simply because she is deemed 'different'. He is simply a mortal who is 'clumsy' and 'weak'. Yet
still so powerful in his own ways. This resonated with me so well, and I love characters like Patroclus. He was my favorite character in this book. Also, I loved his relationship with Briseis. From the moment, he saved her I just knew. I just knew Patroclus was just going to be
that character for me. Their relationship is tragic, as is every other relationship and character in this book. So that brings me nicely on to the next character, Briseis. I loved this women, like truly from the bottom of my heart. She was just so pure and whole-hearted. She loved Patroclus right through the very end even though he rejected the only thing she ever asked of him. I feel like that's just so beautiful, because it shows that a man and woman do not need to be
in love to have a relationship with one and another that's just filled
with love. Up next is Achilles. I will say that I didn't expect to feel so distant from this character. But then again, this might just also be due to the fact that the book is in Patroclus' POV. So Achilles, is a very interested character. I didn't like him as per say, at least not as much as a I did Patroclus because there was just some things that he did that rubbed me off in the wrong way. I'm not going to say what these were since it would give spoilers (duh. well i'm acting like i didn't give spoilers about patroclus just a few sentences upπ. sorry about that.) BUT, major but, these were things towards the end. or like just before the end. I feel like, it's valid to say that at the end of the day, we've got to cut Achilles some slack. Like come on now, he might have done some **** things, made some questionable choices all for the sake of his reputation, but he is the Iliad's tragic hero. And key word 'tragic'; his struggles in life are saddening and should not be overlooked in any way, shape or form. He did (quite literally) everything for love. He had to go through the hardships of fighting during the Trojan war. Seeing his best friend, closest companion and lover die out in the war he was trying to protect him from. He had to sacrifice his own life knowingly in a brute way so that he could reunite with his lover. But he couldn't even truly do that after either because Patroclus' was not named on his monument as he wanted it to be and it was the only way (somehow) that the two could reunite in their afterlife. And the person who was the reason behind them finally rejoicing and uniting in love that's going to be eternal? Achille's mother. Look I hated this ***** at the start, but Thetis' (very late and overdue) character development had me sobbing. I couldn't believe she was the person that would etch Patroclus' name, with her own hands, on Achilles' grave. I think this is a key moment, since it shows how everything Thetis did, no matter how cruel and unfair, was for her son. Although she was against the relationship between Patroclus and Achilles, at least she realised that the only way her son will be at rest is if she lets him reunite with his lover. And this must've been very hard on her as a mother, like I get it. The one thing she tried so hard resisting and trying to block, is ultimately what she gave into in the end and I think she truly was the perfect ending.
Thirdly, this book was just so good... (ik you're wondering, when's she gonna stop yapping out this same thingπ€£, but hear me out) Miller's take on Homer's Iliad and the heroic decline of both Patroclus and Achilles is told in the POV of the lover who feels weaker than the other, is belittled to be the 'less handsome' one, told he's undeserving of his significant other and in the end he's the one that bets all the odds and comes out better than anyone else in his life. Patroclus deserves the world and I would give that to him if I could. The story is filled with themes of love, violence and redemption, fate, belief and control, honor, pride and legacy, gender, power and agency, stereotypes, responsibility and ownership- and overall very skillfully executed.
To finish this off, I would like to present to you all my favorite (and also famous) piece of dialogue in the story shared between none other than our two star crossed lovers; Achilles and Patroclus.:
Sooo, that is it for today. Let me know what you thought, if you've red this book, want to read or are going to be adding it on your TBR.
Keep hydrated, eat well, stay safe and have a lovely rest of you day
!! π