A question in the book seems to be incorrect. My expansion answer didn’t work out as expected so I turned to the solution bank that did agree. However, when I came to try to use th q(0.1) part the values of actual and approximation were miles apart. So have I done something wrong or does the binomial expansion sometimes not work.

Thanks

Thanks

The question and working refer to two different questions? The series expansion for the posted question is correct (well the first two given terms are)

https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=series+at+x%3D0+%289x%5E2%2B26x%2B20%29%2F%28%281%2Bx%29%282%2Bx%29%29

Edit - the wolfram link is losing "+" terms again, just put them in the orange box and hit enter and Ill edit the link later when I remember how to correct the plus symbols.

https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=series+at+x%3D0+%289x%5E2%2B26x%2B20%29%2F%28%281%2Bx%29%282%2Bx%29%29

Edit - the wolfram link is losing "+" terms again, just put them in the orange box and hit enter and Ill edit the link later when I remember how to correct the plus symbols.

(edited 1 month ago)

Hi I'm losing it aren't I. Yes, I've sent the photo of one question and the answer to a different one. And now, although the % error was not required in the actual question, I've tried it and it's much nearer. Thank you so much and very well spotted.

Original post by maggiehodgson

Hi I'm losing it aren't I. Yes, I've sent the photo of one question and the answer to a different one. And now, although the % error was not required in the actual question, I've tried it and it's much nearer. Thank you so much and very well spotted.

Just post your new working if youre still unsure.

Original post by mqb2766

Just post your new working if youre still unsure.

Thanks, but I'm fully with it now. I was comparing my answer to question 15 in Mixed Exercises C whilst actually attempting the Paper 2 question 9. No wonder they didn't match. All is sorted now. Silly me.

Original post by maggiehodgson

Thanks, but I'm fully with it now. I was comparing my answer to question 15 in Mixed Exercises C whilst actually attempting the Paper 2 question 9. No wonder they didn't match. All is sorted now. Silly me.

Good. Im not too sure of how youre taught it, but another way (for the wrong question) is

1/2 * (9x^2+26x+20) * (1 + (3x+x^2)/2)^(-1)

and you can do the binomial series for (1 + (3x+x^2)/2)^(-1) where the usual x is replaced by (3x+x^2)/2 and then multiply that by (9x^2+26x+20) (and 1/2) to get the result

Id guess they want you to do it your way as theyve given you the denominator factorised. Its a bit of an algebra slog whichever way you do it.

(edited 1 month ago)

Original post by mqb2766

Good. Im not too sure of how youre taught it, but another way (for the wrong question) is

1/2 * (9x^2+26x+20) * (1 + (3x+x^2)/2)^(-1)

and you can do the binomial series for (1 + (3x+x^2)/2)^(-1) where the usual x is replaced by (3x+x^2)/2 and then multiply that by (9x^2+26x+20) (and 1/2) to get the result

Id guess they want you to do it your way as theyve given you the denominator factorised. Its a bit of an algebra slog whichever way you do it.

1/2 * (9x^2+26x+20) * (1 + (3x+x^2)/2)^(-1)

and you can do the binomial series for (1 + (3x+x^2)/2)^(-1) where the usual x is replaced by (3x+x^2)/2 and then multiply that by (9x^2+26x+20) (and 1/2) to get the result

Id guess they want you to do it your way as theyve given you the denominator factorised. Its a bit of an algebra slog whichever way you do it.

There is a slight danger to expand that way, because of radius of convergence issues.

But all is good here - we just need to justify that |(3x+x^2)/2| < 1 indeed implies |x|<1, which is probably not required in A-Levels anyway.

Original post by tonyiptony

There is a slight danger to expand that way, because of radius of convergence issues.

But all is good here - we just need to justify that |(3x+x^2)/2| < 1 indeed implies |x|<1, which is probably not required in A-Levels anyway.

But all is good here - we just need to justify that |(3x+x^2)/2| < 1 indeed implies |x|<1, which is probably not required in A-Levels anyway.

It doesn't really matter; regardless of what approach you take - as long as you get a series with a non-zero radius of convergence, it has to match the Taylor series (and therefore have the same radius of convergence).

[

- A level maths binomial expansion question HELP
- ..
- Binomial Expansion Question - A Level Maths
- Binomial expansion- Constant term(Question 2
- Isaac Physics Working with Terms-HELP ME
- Maths question
- A level Maths question
- Edexcel AS Maths Paper 1 (Pure)
- OCR A Level Mathematics MEI Pure maths & comprehension H640/03 - 21 Jun 2022 [Chat]
- OCR A-level Mathematics A Paper 1 (H240/01) - 6th June 2023 [Exam Chat]
- Further Statistics Edexcel 9FM/3B 16th June
- Binomial Expansion
- A level maths Edexcel Binomial Expansion
- Anyone know where to find the 2023 AS Edexcel Further Maths papers?
- How to use Madas Maths
- aqa further maths gcse level 2
- Negative Binomial Question
- Edexcel Further Stats 1 Paper 3B 2023
- Maths help
- weird cosine question

Last reply 1 week ago

Edexcel A Level Mathematics Paper 2 unofficial mark scheme correct me if wrongMaths

72

Last reply 1 week ago

Edexcel A Level Mathematics Paper 2 unofficial mark scheme correct me if wrongMaths

72