Hi, did you study A Christmas Carol. If u did, i would rlly appreciate if u could mark this and tell me how many marks and what level i would get.
The question is:How does Dickens present redemption as essential for change?
In ‘A Christmas Carol’, Dickens presents Scrooge as a character who transmogrifies from a misanthropic miser who disagrees with the idea of Christmas and charity, to a warm-hearted, philanthropic father figure by the end of the novella. This change is influenced by the ghosts who reveal to Scrooge the importance of Christmas spirit and charitable acts, and the repercussions of those who do not comply with them, prompting Scrooge’s redemption. It soon becomes clear that redemption is necessary for change as Scrooge is only able to reach his epiphany after the visit of the ghost of Christmas Yet to come who sparks his redemption by revealing his fate and presenting Christmas and charity as the only path to redemption. As a result, Dickens is able to “raise the ghost of an idea” through Scrooge’s redemption, in order to emphasise the importance of charity and Christmas and encourage them to be practiced in society in order to implement change.
In the extract, Scrooge’s transformation is revealed as a result of being exposed to the ramifications of his misanthropic lifestyle in order to encourage Christmas spirit, leading to his redemption. After seeing his abandoned and “neglected” future self, Scrooge experiences his epiphany where he asks the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come “Am I that man who lay upon the bed?”, crying “upon his knees”. The body language of Scrooge kneeling before the Ghost reveals his reformation as he humbles himself and accepts the superiority of the Ghost which contrasts to his “covetous” behaviour at the start of the novella. Scrooge then tells the Ghost “Why show me this, if I am past all hope!” suggesting that Scrooge is willing to accept his fate and possibly doesn’t believe that he deserves redemption, generating sympathy from the readers as well as the ghost, who’s hand “for the first time (…) appeared to shake”. The fact that the ghost’s hand shaking was unprecedented highlights Scrooge’s unprecedented repentance. Furthermore, the Ghost was previously described as being “immovable”, suggesting that Scrooge’s fate remained unchanged, however, Scrooge was able to cause his hand to “shake” revealing the possibility of his transformation as a result of his redemption. He then asks if “I yet may change these shadows you have shown me, by an altered life!” His tone has gradually become more respectful and courteous, reinforced by his reference of the ghost as “Good Spirit”. Scrooge asks for a chance to change his fate by an “altered life”, clearly highlighting his intentions to change his ways in an attempt to avoid the undesirable future he has been shown due to his redemption. He states that he will “honour Christmas in (his) heart, and try to keep it all the year”. To “honour” Christmas doesn’t just mean that Scrooge intends to celebrate it, but respect it as many Victorians did. Christmas was a very important traditional celebration in the Victorian era and was widely celebrated by Christians as a time to spend with family and reflect on religion. Perhaps Scrooge sees Christmas as a means of becoming closer to God in order to repent for his past actions after having learnt the importance of Christmas from the ghosts. Scrooge says he will “not shut out the lessons that they teach”. At the start the of the novella, Scrooge is described as having a “shut up heart” which prevented him from celebrating and enjoying Christmas before his redemption, so by “not shut(ting) out” the ghosts’ lessons, he is finally able to change and experience Christmas cheer. Perhaps Dickens wanted to emphasise the essential need for Christmas cheer in order to achieve redemption and therefore live a good, moral Christian life and used Scrooge’s redemption to encourage Christmas spirit among his readers. Therefore, Scrooge’s change, triggered by his redemption, urges the celebration of Christmas and emphasises its importance.
At the start of the novella ‘A Christmas Carol’, Scrooge is described as a stingy and ignorant character who rejects the idea of Christmas and charity. This is evident in Stave 1 when he tells Fred that “every idiot who goes about with ‘merry Christmas’ on his lips should be boiled with his own pudding and buried with a stake of holly through his heart”. His response to ‘Merry Christmas’ is comical yet excessively aggressive as he turns images of Christmas into images of violence. This hyperbolic statement exaggerates Scrooge’s ignorance towards the celebration of Christmas, and perhaps Scrooge directs his distaste towards the readers in order to make them aware of their own ignorance. As the contemporary readers of Dickens were likely to be rich and have the same ideas as Scrooge, he is used as an audience surrogate to force the readers to reflect on their own morality in an attempt to disassociate themselves from Scrooge who is portrayed as a disliked character. Scrooge’s ignorance is yet again evident in Stave 1 when he tells the charity workers that he “can’t afford to make idle people merry”. With Scrooge’s wealth, the words “can’t afford” emphasise his disbelief in charity. As Scrooge is symbolic of the quintessential Victorian upper class, his Malthusian views reflect the apathetic beliefs of the rich that the poor were too “idle” to break out of the cycle of poverty. Thus Scrooge believes that charity is rewarding ‘bad behaviour’ and so doesn’t contribute to charitable acts. Dickens’ novella was written in a post-Industrial Revolution society where poverty was rife, and so Dickens used the novella to express the need for collective contribution to charity in order to solve the crisis of poverty, which the upper class viewed as the “surplus population”. Therefore, at the start of the novella, Scrooge’s stinginess and ignorance towards Christmas and charity are used to highlights the essential need for change in society, foreshadowing Scrooge’s redemption which is necessary for his reform.
Throughout the rest of the novella, as Scrooge interacts with the ghosts, he gradually reforms to become a loving “second father” to Tiny Tim, who cherishes Christmas and provides for the poor. This is influenced by the ghosts who use different methods to encourage Scrooge to change. In stave 1, Scrooge is reunited with his old business partner, the ghost of Jacob Marley, who warns Scrooge of the repercussion of his avaricious behaviour and ignorance of the poor. Marley describes purgatory as “incessant torture of remorse” in an attempt to intimidate Scrooge into redemption. The adjective “incessant” emphasises Marley’s pain and agony, and generates sympathy from the readers towards his suffering. This makes Scrooge fear Marley’s fate, and thus fear his own, as he was so similar to Marley in his lifetime; however it is not enough to spark Scrooge’s epiphany. Scrooge is then visited by the ghost of Christmas Past who takes him back to his “long forgotten” hometown. At the sight of this, Scrooge becomes emotional as his “lip is trembling” and he begins to cry. The ghost then takes Scrooge to see his childhood self “solitary” and “neglected”, at which Scrooge recalls the young carol singer stating that “I should like to have given him something”. The change in tone from indifferent to sympathetic marks the start of Scrooge’s transformation as it is his first genuine expression of concern for the poor, however there are still no physical signs of change. He then visits his old workplace where he sees his younger self and another apprentice “pouring their hearts out in praise of Fezziwig”. This suggests that Fezziwig was a generous and kind-hearted employer, who directly contrasts to Scrooge, making him reflect on his treatment of his clerk. This triggers his guilt as he compares himself to Fezziwig, his foil, suddenly feeling the need to “say a word or two to my clerk”. In this way, the ghost of Christmas Past makes Scrooge revisit past events in his life in order to evoke emotional memories to help him reach his epiphany. While the ghost of Christmas Present exposes Scrooge to the reality of the present day Christmas for the poor where they are struggling financially, yet are still able to enjoy the festive season. However, after watching the Cratchit family, Scrooge becomes increasingly concerned about Tiny Tim’s wellbeing, and after hearing of his likely death in the near future, Scrooge becomes distraught. He desperately asks if “these shadows will remain unaltered by the future”, demonstrating his love and affection for the poor boy out of fear for his death. The ghost replies by echoing Scrooge’s words of “he had better do it, and decrease the surplus population” to which Scrooge is “overcome with penitence and grief”. He is finally able to realise the flaws in his beliefs when put in the context of people he cares about, building up to his redemption. Dickens uses the hendiadys to prove the immorality of such beliefs and encourage charity by showing that the only way to stop poor children like Tiny Tim from dying is for the rich to financially support them. This would encourage redemption from Scrooge as well as readers who now feel sympathetic towards the poor, foreshadowing Scrooge’s repentance. This persuades Scrooge to reform by the end of the novella and become a “second father” to Tiny Tim as a result of his redemption which has allowed him to become a philanthropic and warm-hearted character.
In conclusion, Dickens uses Scrooge’s redemption to demonstrate the positive impacts of reform, achieved through charity and Christmas cheer. Dickens reveals the need for change by exposing us to the repercussions of the archetypal avaricious and misanthropic behaviour of the Victorian upper class, as well as using Tiny Tim as a construct to represent the poor population in order to generate sympathy and encourage change as a result. When we compare the character of Scrooge before and after his redemption, it is easy to recognise how beneficial it would be for society to experience change like Scrooge. However, we also notice that redemption is essential for change as Scrooge doesn’t reform until he has undergone it to eventually become the loving character society needs. Therefore, Dickens is able to “raise the ghost of an idea” through Scrooge’s redemption by highlighting its necessity through the positive change it brings.
Edit: I realise now that it might be a bit too long!