The Student Room Group

Likelihood of an applied ethics essay (AQA a level philosophy)?

Scroll to see replies

Reply 20

Original post
by hbrown2626
Honestly, i would just get a general idea on what each ethical theory states about each bit of applied, but the likelihood of a full 25 marker coming up on it is very low, so I would spend that time doing an essay plan for other bits like direct and indirect realism (seems more likely to show)

why do you think the likelihood of a 25 marker on applied ethics coming up is very low?

Reply 21

Original post
by hbrown2626
Honestly, i would just get a general idea on what each ethical theory states about each bit of applied, but the likelihood of a full 25 marker coming up on it is very low, so I would spend that time doing an essay plan for other bits like direct and indirect realism (seems more likely to show)

my ex teacher is the head of the british philosophy teachers association and said that it could easily come up, prepare for it

Reply 22

Original post
by eliza98760
my ex teacher is the head of the british philosophy teachers association and said that it could easily come up, prepare for it

this is good to know, how would you go about planning it?

Reply 23

Original post
by wily-sunflower
this is good to know, how would you go about planning it?


Use this website

https://alevelphilosophyandreligion.com/philosophy/moral-philosophy/notes-essay-applied-ethics/

Reply 24

Reply 25

Original post
by wily-sunflower
thank you x

saying this I have emailed Christian feest (the guy who runs the alevelphilosophy.com website and the yellow textbook How to get an A in A level philosophy) he said this:

I don't have any special information, but I don't think you would get an applied ethics 25 mark question this year.
The reason I think this is that it becomes too broad a question. Say they were to ask "Is eating animals morally acceptable? (25 marks)". This might seem like a reasonable question at first, but in order to answer it you'd first need to say which ethical theory is correct. For example let's say Kant and Aristotle say eating animals is morally acceptable but utiltiarianism says it isn't. In order to say eating animals is wrong you'd have to argue utilitarianism is correct and against Aristotle and Kant are incorrect. So any applied ethics question basically becomes "assess every ethical theory (25 marks)" if that makes sense.
I might be wrong, though. But I think there's a reason there's never been a 25 mark applied ethics question before. Applied ethics topics make much more sense as 12 mark questions where you just have to explain (i.e. AO1), not evaluate (i.e. AO2), what an ethical theory says about a particular issue.

Reply 26

Original post
by eliza98760
saying this I have emailed Christian feest (the guy who runs the alevelphilosophy.com website and the yellow textbook How to get an A in A level philosophy) he said this:
I don't have any special information, but I don't think you would get an applied ethics 25 mark question this year.
The reason I think this is that it becomes too broad a question. Say they were to ask "Is eating animals morally acceptable? (25 marks)". This might seem like a reasonable question at first, but in order to answer it you'd first need to say which ethical theory is correct. For example let's say Kant and Aristotle say eating animals is morally acceptable but utiltiarianism says it isn't. In order to say eating animals is wrong you'd have to argue utilitarianism is correct and against Aristotle and Kant are incorrect. So any applied ethics question basically becomes "assess every ethical theory (25 marks)" if that makes sense.
I might be wrong, though. But I think there's a reason there's never been a 25 mark applied ethics question before. Applied ethics topics make much more sense as 12 mark questions where you just have to explain (i.e. AO1), not evaluate (i.e. AO2), what an ethical theory says about a particular issue.

thank you so much! so is it best to just revise it as a 12 marker then as normal?

Reply 27

Original post
by wily-sunflower
thank you so much! so is it best to just revise it as a 12 marker then as normal?

id say revise it briefly so if it comes ur not shocked in an exam, because technically they can and a lot of teachers have differing opinions on this

Reply 28

Original post
by eliza98760
id say revise it briefly so if it comes ur not shocked in an exam, because technically they can and a lot of teachers have differing opinions on this

that's true, thank you so much

Reply 29

I emailed AQA and they didn't really answer straight but implied that they could ask it.

Also - they have asked applied ethics essay questions in the past in the old spec.

So overall I'd say it's necessary to be prepared for this. Anyway, if you read my guide on how to answer them linked above, you'll see that it doesn't actually require any additional knowledge than what you need for lower mark questions in terms of applying the normative theories, and then the standard evaluations you'd use for those theories - but used as attacks on their answer to the morality of the applied ethics issue.

At least, that's what the mark scheme for the applied ethics essay questions said you should do on the old version of the spec. I wish I had kept that but unfortunately can't find it.

Reply 30

Original post
by marleym56
this would finish me off if it came up. im hoping and praying its utilitarianism since that hasnt come up since 2019, but aqa are evil so u never know ..

hate to break it to you but utilitarianism was asked last year

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.