The Student Room Group

Solution by Substitution 1

https://isaacphysics.org/questions/solution_by_substitution1?stage=a_level

I managed to solve this question but I dont think I did it with the right method.

In the first part of my working out (before the dashed line) I feel pretty confident in the method, but after that to be honest I didnt really know what I was doing.

I just used some form of trial and error and it led me to the right answer, but I dont think this was the intended way.
If anyone could help that would be greatly appreciated.
Reply 1
Working:
Reply 2
Original post by mosaurlodon
Working:

Youve got the main idea in there, and its a case of noting the left hand side is the derivative of y^2. You could note that the derivative of the right hand side is
LHS + 1
so that suggests modifying the ODE by adding 1 to both sides so
2y dy/dx + 1 = y^2+x + 1
Then define
z = y^2 + x
so the ode becomes fairly simple and could be solved using seperation of variables or a simple linear first order ode or ...
Reply 3
Original post by mosaurlodon
In the first part of my working out (before the dashed line) I feel pretty confident in the method, but after that to be honest I didnt really know what I was doing.
I just used some form of trial and error and it led me to the right answer, but I dont think this was the intended way.
If anyone could help that would be greatly appreciated.
I would expect IsaacPhysics expects you to know how to solve a first order equation of the form

dydx+P(x)y=Q(x)()\dfrac{dy}{dx} + P(x) y = Q(x) \quad (\dagger)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrating_factor#Solving_first_order_linear_ordinary_differential_equations

In this particular case, you'd rewrite as dk/dx - k = x and then multiply by exe^-x to get

dkdxexkex=xex\dfrac{dk}{dx}e^{-x} - ke^{-x} = xe^{-x} and then note the LHS is

ddx(kex)\dfrac{d}{dx}\left(ke^{-x}\right), so integrating both sides w.r.t. x gives the desired result.

mqb's solution is neater, but I think the **intent** was "make a substitution to get it in the form ()(\dagger) that you know how to solve, and then do so".
Reply 4
Thank you both of you

Quick Reply