The Student Room Group

What should I think about before deciding on medicine?

Hi all, at the moment I am unsure as to what degree to choose, and I am deciding between medicine and other science courses e.g pharmacology, biochemistry and biomedical science. I am doing biology, chemistry, psychology, German, in Year 12, and im hoping to at least get all As. I just wanted to ask people who are doing medicine / people who decided not to do it, why was it that you decided on medicine / decided against it? What do you think I should take into consideration? Thank you :smile:
Hey there, thanks for posting a question in the Medicine forum. :biggrin:

The Medicine forum gets a high volume of questions being posted, and some of these are already answered by the resources and Megathreads that members of the community and volunteers have created. This is an automatic post which is designed to highlight these resources. Below is a list of threads and articles that could answer your question (you should be looking in the original post of the megathreads). If one of the below threads is a more relevant place to ask your question, please post a reply in that thread to ask your question. If your query is answered by one of the Megathreads or articles linked below, and you would like us to close this thread for you, please reply to this thread with just the words "thank you". A member of our team will then get it locked.

Megathreads
(Please read the first post, before then posting any further questions you have within that thread.)
The "Which Medical School Should I Apply To?" Uberthread
The Ultimate 'Am I Good Enough For Medicine?' Angst Thread
Medicine A-Level subjects queries
Work Experience and Voluntary Work

2023 Applicants:
Official Undergraduate Medicine 2023 Entry
Graduate Entry Medicine 2023 Entry
Medicine 2023 entry for resit / retake / gap year applicants
A100 Medicine for International Students 2023 Entry
Medicine Interview discussion 2023 Entry
2023 entry A100 / A101 Medicine fastest and slowest offer senders
Index of Individual Medical School Applicants' threads 2023 Entry

2024 Applicants :
Official Undergraduate Medicine 2024 Entry
Graduate Entry Medicine 2024 Entry
GAMSAT 2024 / 2025 entry discussions megathread
UCAT 2024 Entry Discussions Megathread
Medicine 2024 entry for resit / retake / gap year applicants
A100 Medicine for International Students 2024 Entry
Medicine Interview Discussion 2024 Entry
2024 entry A100 / A101 Medicine fastest and slowest offer senders
Medical Schools Index 2024 Entry

2025 Applicants :
Official Thread: (Undergraduate) Medicine 2025 entry
Official Thread: Graduate Entry Medicine 2025 Entry
GAMSAT 2025 / 2026 entry discussions megathread
UCAT 2025 Entry Discussions Megathread


Other application years:
Official Thread: (Undergraduate) Medicine 2026 entry
Official Thread: Graduate Entry Medicine 2026 Entry

Useful Articles:
GCSE Requirements for Medicine
Everything you need to know about the BMAT
Work Experience as a Graduate or Mature student
Medicine Personal Statement Advice
Medicine Personal Statement Advice (Graduate Entry)
Interview Frequently Asked Questions
MMI Medicine Interview Tips
What to do after an unsuccessful first application
Funding medicine as a second degree

If your query is answered by one of the Megathreads or articles linked above, and you would like us to close this thread for you, please reply to this thread with just the words "thank you". A member of our team will then get it locked.
Original post by raindropxox
Hi all, at the moment I am unsure as to what degree to choose, and I am deciding between medicine and other science courses e.g pharmacology, biochemistry and biomedical science. I am doing biology, chemistry, psychology, German, in Year 12, and im hoping to at least get all As. I just wanted to ask people who are doing medicine / people who decided not to do it, why was it that you decided on medicine / decided against it? What do you think I should take into consideration? Thank you :smile:


I think the primary question has to be, do you want to be a medical doctor (with all that entails) or not? There's really no point in doing medicine for any other reason. If you don't want to be a medical doctor, just do one of the other (shorter) degrees. You have the same potential career outcomes outside of being a medical doctor with those other degrees as with a medicine degree (as while yes you can do other things after a medicine degree and some do, there's no point going into the medicine degree if you are already planning a non-medical career! Save yourself the time and money and get started on your non-medical career earlier with the alternative options in that case).

As for determining whether you want to be a medical doctor, this is in part what the mandatory work experience for medicine is for! To get you to engage with the realities of being a doctor (in the NHS) and understanding what is involved in it, and then for you to reflect on those experiences. If you're a current year 11 going into year 12, you don't need to immediately make that decision but just keep in mind to explore work experience opportunities for the spring and summer holidays in/after year 12. If you're a current year 12 going into year 13, start looking now at lining up some work experience :smile:
Original post by raindropxox
Hi all, at the moment I am unsure as to what degree to choose, and I am deciding between medicine and other science courses e.g pharmacology, biochemistry and biomedical science. I am doing biology, chemistry, psychology, German, in Year 12, and im hoping to at least get all As. I just wanted to ask people who are doing medicine / people who decided not to do it, why was it that you decided on medicine / decided against it? What do you think I should take into consideration? Thank you :smile:

Hi Raindropxox, I'm a Yr 13 student who is in the interlude waiting to see if I get accepted into medicine, and was the Founder & President of my school's medical society. From my experience surveying my peers and doctors during work experience, the most common reasons were:

For medicine: 👍️

Want to help people in a way that matters / rewarding - My father has received so much praise from his patients, as a lot of the time he was the first doctor to consider their issues without complete dismissal of their worries. The impact he has made on them is so evident, from the kind words and the gifts that they needn't send, but still do, simply because he listened. The impact you can make on a person in medicine is arguably unparalleled compared to every single profession, especially if you are a good doctor who does right by their patients.


Decent pay / good pay progression - Medical consultants are some of the highest earners, earning between £93,666 and £126,281, depending on where they sit on the pay scale.


Respect - may not be as applicable to yourself, but abroad and in certain communities e.g. Asian, being a doctor will garner respect and sometimes even privileges e.g. as a medical professional, in your own and family member's healthcare you can often times have more of a say, to a certain extent. A caveat to this point is other professions, not just medicine garner respect, but I just wanted to highlight how having medical knowledge may put you in good stead in certain situations.


Job security - doctors are needed everywhere, so employment prospects are almost guaranteed.

Ease of travel for work (due to job security) as doctors are needed everywhere - can work internationally and if you decide to settle abroad it will often be much easier to attain citizenship.


Interest in science - science, particularly biology and chemistry, forms a large foundation of medical training.


Interest in teaching - As you progress in training and become more senior, you will be expected to teach your juniors e.g. junior doctors and medical students.

Interest in puzzle-solving / challenges - medicine often requires many differential diagnoses and you will need to use your medical knowledge, the information and symptoms the patient is presenting with and the process of elimination to arrive at a diagnosis.


Enjoy working in a team - you will be working in a multi-disciplinary team of other doctors, nurses, therapists, dieticians, etc., eventually taking more of a lead, if you progress to become more senior.


People-person / Patient-centred care - patients are at the centre of everything, ad you will be working with them on the regular e.g. check-ups (although there are professions such as radiology where you can avoid major patient contact if it's not your thing.)


Lifelong learning - medicine is always changing and as a doctor, it is your responsibility to maintain a current standard of medical knowledge for your patients


Opportunity to branch out into other careers e.g. Pharmacy rep, research, teaching etc.


Opportunity to earn extra money through locum - 'locum' means you work temporarily in another hospital, which often pays very well.


Against medicine: 👎️

The training pathway - long: 5 years med school, 2 years F1 & F2, then 5-7 years specialising, although it can take even longer. My father, for example, only finished his training to be a consultant urologist at the age of 50!


Constant exams to progress in training, so you will be studying even whilst working as a junior doctor.


Stressful / Emotional toll / Burnout - big workload + understaffed + responsibility for your patient's wellbeing + long shifts + possible lack of sleep + subsequent difficulty to maintain a social life and you may experience difficult scenarios such as a patient death first-hand. All of this can be exhausting to deal with. And if the stress of the job isn’t addressed soon, burnout is likely to occur, as well-documented among medics.

Working hours - longer and different to the normal 9-5, so may be difficult to coordinate with non-medical peers e.g. night shifts, and you may work overtime often. Work-life balance is often quoted as being difficult to maintain.


The NHS - understaffing / staff retention, junior doctor pay, budget cuts, A&E wait times and the bed crisis are all examples of reasons / NHS hot topics as to why some of my peers have been dissuaded from medicine, and why those who haven't are strongly considering moving abroad.


Debt - longer time in higher education + exam fees + relatively poor pay as a junior doctor means you will have a lot of student debt to pay off.


Blood / too gory - some people may have enjoyed the prospect of becoming a doctor, however upon entering university to study had to drop out due to their fear of blood/uneasiness with dissections. Make sure you’re not queasy, or apply for universities with no cadaveric dissection e.g. Exeter. But even so, if dissections aren’t your thing, maybe think twice about applying for medicine!


For me personally, I find the concept of studying medicine to be extremely exciting and intriguing. I love learning about how the human body works, with all the theory and pedantic details, and the idea of using my knowledge to help others in a perhaps life-changing way is very appealing. However, I am also aware of the challenges that a career in medicine will entail, both from talking to doctors, and medical students, as well as from first-hand experience growing up with medical parents. Medicine isn't a job you can just clock in and out for. It will take up a large aspect of your life, and risk engulfing it, especially in the early years. Even more so especially if you don't have a good work-life balance. And if you're not absolutely passionate about the profession, then ultimately all the sleepless nights, exams, stressful situations and the peregrination of the medical journey will wear you down. Ultimately, you need to be dead certain this is what you want to do for the rest of your life.

As for what you should take into consideration, you should first ascertain your interests and life goals. Do you enjoy the academic challenges of pushing your knowledge to a new level, perhaps indefintely? Of puzzle-solving as you would when a patient presents with certain symptoms? Working with other people, both medical colleagues and patients? How much time do you want to dedicate to your work? How comfortably do you want to live in the future? Would you be willing to do 13-hour night shifts, have responsibility over someone elses well-being and possibly life, and spend an unceremonious amount of time on patient paperwork? These are the questions you should be asking yourself and know the answers to.

Now I’m assuming you’re in year 11 / just started year 12? Perfect timing, as year 12 is the year you should be dedicating to garnering as much insight into medicine as possible, something that will come in handy in not just your decision to pursue medicine, but the interviews, should you choose to apply for medicine.
I've been quite lucky to have medical parents to provide personal insight into the ongoing highs and lows of medicine. In your case, try to reach out to any medical professional relatives or contacts you may have, assuming you have any. If not, books such as 'Trust Me I'm a Junior Doctor' by Max Pemberton and 'This is Going to Hurt' by Adam Kay are great starts. Also check out online sources such as YouTube channels e.g. Kharma Medic and Ali Abdaal, who left medicine, for differing views. The news is also a great place to keep up-to-date with the latest developments in medicine, especially in the NHS. I'd also strongly recommend joining virtual medical societies such as Medic Mentor, who amongst many things, host weekly medical club meetings, provide virtual work experience as well as ‘Get into Medicine’ Conferences, which should really give you a good taste of what is required to go into medicine. And the holy grail of all is to get in-person work experience, albeit this can be difficult to acquire. Volunteering at a hospital is another great way to gain some insight into the medical profession, and will be invaluable to your CV. Overall, just make sure you know what you’re getting into!

If you are in Year 12 / just starting Year 13 (just in case I misinterpreted your message), then don’t worry, there is still some time. You will need to dedicate this summer to what I’ve just detailed above, but double the emphasis on the work experience and volunteering! You will also need to start preparing for the UCAT, which is the entrance exam for both medical and dental students to get into university, with test dates 8/07/24 - 27/09/24. You will need to dedicate a substantial amount of time to revising for this, and websites such as MedEntry and Medify are vital tools for this.

Overall, you have some time. Find out what is important to you, and whether a career in medicine fits in place with everything you have planned for your life. Maybe after doing all of the research now, you find medicine is not for you, decide to do another degree, and then a few years later, change your mind! That’s also completely okay. There are graduate-entry medical schools (albeit much more competitive to get into), and by the end of it, you will still be a doctor! Or maybe, medicine just isn’t for you, and that’s completely okay. I’m just saying that, at the end of the day, do what makes you happy and what is best for you, and everything else will fall into place. For me, the pros of medicine make the cons worth it. Ask yourself whether they do for you too.

All the best :smile:,

(p.s. Obviously make sure to do your research on the other professions you’re interested in!)
Reply 4
Thank you very much both, you’ve given me some things to think about! I am a Year 12 going into Year 13, so I know I don’t have a lot of time, but have been doing things, like the Medic Mentor virtual work experience, different MOOCs (I’ve done quite a few already for general science) and I’ve applied for volunteering at my local hospital. I definitely love a challenge, and all of the things about medicine like using science which I am interested in and being able to help people in that regard is very appealing to me. And one of the reasons I started thinking about medicine was visiting my nan in the hospital and seeing all of the medical professionals doing their jobs and how much the good ones made her day. I’d love to have the chance to do that for someone. But it’s the long hours and hard work that scare me. I love studying, and working hard, but I am scared that that’s not good enough. I also am scared of making the ‘wrong’ decision, i.e choosing medicine and becoming a doctor, and having taken that place away from someone else who really wanted it and could have been a ‘better’ one. I’ve never made a decision that felt ‘right’, as I’ve always been interested in so many things, and I’ve always just chosen the path that ‘makes sense’ so it scares me to decide to do medicine without feeling that burning passion to do it! But I will definitely think more about what you both have said, and reflect on the work experience and volunteering I do to see if that changes my mind one way or the other! Thank you :smile:)
Original post by raindropxox
Thank you very much both, you’ve given me some things to think about! I am a Year 12 going into Year 13, so I know I don’t have a lot of time, but have been doing things, like the Medic Mentor virtual work experience, different MOOCs (I’ve done quite a few already for general science) and I’ve applied for volunteering at my local hospital. I definitely love a challenge, and all of the things about medicine like using science which I am interested in and being able to help people in that regard is very appealing to me. And one of the reasons I started thinking about medicine was visiting my nan in the hospital and seeing all of the medical professionals doing their jobs and how much the good ones made her day. I’d love to have the chance to do that for someone. But it’s the long hours and hard work that scare me. I love studying, and working hard, but I am scared that that’s not good enough. I also am scared of making the ‘wrong’ decision, i.e choosing medicine and becoming a doctor, and having taken that place away from someone else who really wanted it and could have been a ‘better’ one. I’ve never made a decision that felt ‘right’, as I’ve always been interested in so many things, and I’ve always just chosen the path that ‘makes sense’ so it scares me to decide to do medicine without feeling that burning passion to do it! But I will definitely think more about what you both have said, and reflect on the work experience and volunteering I do to see if that changes my mind one way or the other! Thank you :smile:)

No worries, I'm glad we were able to provide some assistance! Don't worry, having to figure out what career you want to pursue, potentially for the rest of your life, is no easy task. When I was where you were at this stage, I recall having many friends who were still undecided, and that's okay! I think what you did and are doing right now is great, and getting the volunteering and the virtual work experience hopefully should help you come to a decision!

As for your concerns, they are completely valid. As much as you enjoy studying and academic pursuits, entering medicine will mean being immersed with other students who are of equal mentality and capability, meaning the standards are inevitably higher. However, as a junior doctor once told me ' The hardest thing about medical school isn't necessarily the exams, the hours taken studying or the overall content, it's believing that you can do it. ' And I feel this holds true even before applying for medical school. It will be tough and arduous, from the volunteering, work experience, wider reading, keeping up to date with medical hot-topics, UCAT and all the work that is required for interviews, but know it'll be hard for everyone! So please don't worry that you won't be a good enough doctor if you were to apply and get in, as it means you've done everything right to be one. Any persons whose place you would have theoretically 'taken', wouldn't have then necessarily done everything required to progress to become a medical student as you would have. This is great as it means if they were really passionate about medicine, they would work on themselves and reapply to be up to the standard required for medical school, and therefore to be a practising doctor, optimising patient care. So overall, don't worry about what others are doing, do what feels right for yourself.

As for the long hours and hard work, I'd say it's difficult to circumvent in a field like medicine, especially in the early years. Once you become more senior (e.g. a consultant or a GP), which could take more than a decade, the workload will die down, but still be quite high relatively speaking. Of course, there's the option to do only part-time or locum, which means you may earn less (although if you have a good locum contract perhaps you could earn equal or more) but ultimately have more free time. But I agree that the long hours and difficulty of the work are one of the major turn-offs for medicine generally speaking, with most defecting to Dentistry, which has a great pay-to-working-hour ratio. However, as a dentist once told me 'Being a dentist means you're extremely minted but also extremely bored.' Overall, again, it's a question of what you prioritise.

To conclude, from what I've seen from your messages, you would be well-suited to the fields you've mentioned interest in, as all have a big emphasis on science (well duh 😂). The factor of visiting your nan and seeing the effect of healthcare professionals is a great personal motivation and something you can definitely consider to a greater degree. The only deciding factor now I'd say is where your interests lie. I've already mentioned this before, but ascertain what you enjoy the most and what you prioritise in your life, and see which profession aligns the most. I'd say that compared to the other fields you've mentioned, medicine will have a higher emphasis on people / social interaction, and less on science and research (unless you decide to go down the research route in medicine) as you would with biochemistry and biomedical science and generally a higher salary (perhaps with some exceptions) but also a higher workload. Ultimately, I can't speculate much more, it's up to you to decide!

All the best :smile:,

Quick Reply