The Student Room Group

Sunni and Shia Muslims

Hi, im Shia and i just wanted to know why many sunnis dislike shias so much cos theres barely any difference between us except a few beliefs.

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1

Im a sunni and I rlly dont mind actually, I guess some believe your going against rules and changing things they dont want to

Reply 2

Original post by Anonymous
Hi, im Shia and i just wanted to know why many sunnis dislike shias so much cos theres barely any difference between us except a few beliefs.

For starters, Abu Bakr should have been the first caliph.
Secondly, Shias place too much importance to Ali, so much so to the point where some can argue it is Shirk.

I am not too knowledgeable on Shiaism so I will ask a mowlana that I know and come back to you

Reply 3

Original post by hh1209
For starters, Abu Bakr should have been the first caliph.
Secondly, Shias place too much importance to Ali, so much so to the point where some can argue it is Shirk.
I am not too knowledgeable on Shiaism so I will ask a mowlana that I know and come back to you

ur talking about the alawites. thats a very small section of shia islam who think imam Ali (AS) is more important than the porphet (pbuh) and im not one of them. We do believe that Imam Ali (AS) is very important because he is the cousin of the prophet, as well as his son in law and one of the most important people to the prophet because he declared him his successor. Of course i disagree with the alawites, but many sunnis believe that all shias have this belief but that is wrong.

Reply 4

Original post by Anonymous
ur talking about the alawites. thats a very small section of shia islam who think imam Ali (AS) is more important than the porphet (pbuh) and im not one of them. We do believe that Imam Ali (AS) is very important because he is the cousin of the prophet, as well as his son in law and one of the most important people to the prophet because he declared him his successor. Of course i disagree with the alawites, but many sunnis believe that all shias have this belief but that is wrong.

Alright then. That was a misunderstanding from me. I apologise for that. As I said above, because I am not knowledgeable on Shia Islam, I will go ask a mowlana that I know and will come back to you. Insha'Allah I will be able to do it today and be back here for 2pm or 2:30.

Reply 5

Original post by Anonymous
Hi, im Shia and i just wanted to know why many sunnis dislike shias so much cos theres barely any difference between us except a few beliefs.

people have diff beliefs and thats ok but like i think some sunnis think of u guys as outcasts sort of?? im sunni myself but i definitely dont hate shias or think they're unworthy but maybe we have the wrong interpretation cuz i remember my cousin telling me he had a shia friend who whipped themselves as some form of worship but i made a shia friend of my own and she told me they did nothing of the sort so i think it's just that some of us dont understand the reasoning behind another branch of islam's beliefs

Reply 6

Original post by Anonymous
people have diff beliefs and thats ok but like i think some sunnis think of u guys as outcasts sort of?? im sunni myself but i definitely dont hate shias or think they're unworthy but maybe we have the wrong interpretation cuz i remember my cousin telling me he had a shia friend who whipped themselves as some form of worship but i made a shia friend of my own and she told me they did nothing of the sort so i think it's just that some of us dont understand the reasoning behind another branch of islam's beliefs

yh, but i js hate how so many people have the wrong interpretation of shia islam, the two branches are rlly not that different at all and even the small differences dont matter that much

Reply 7

Original post by Anonymous
yh, but i js hate how so many people have the wrong interpretation of shia islam, the two branches are rlly not that different at all and even the small differences dont matter that much

Sorry, I won't be able to ask my mowlana today. I will try to come back tmrw at 2pm with the info about this. Thanks.

Reply 8

when u said that u think abu bakr should have been the first caliph, could u elaborate. why??

Reply 9

Original post by Anonymous
when u said that u think abu bakr should have been the first caliph, could u elaborate. why??

Sorry. Because I am not that knowledgeable on Shia Islam, I can't directly explain it. But I have got this video from Dr Yasir Qadhi that might explain it pretty well. It is just over an hour long, but it is worth it if we gain knowledge on Islam. I will watch it as well and try to learn myself. Just so you know, I think I specialise more in Fiqh or the Quranic aspect of Islam, not the Seerah or history as you can see.

Reply 10

ive watched abt 20 mins. ill finish it when i get back from Duke of Edinburgh expedition on Wednesday cos i leave tmr, but i js wanted to know ur opinion. Why dont u think Imam Ali should have been the first caliph??

Reply 11

Original post by Anonymous
ive watched abt 20 mins. ill finish it when i get back from Duke of Edinburgh expedition on Wednesday cos i leave tmr, but i js wanted to know ur opinion. Why dont u think Imam Ali should have been the first caliph??

Honestly, I don't know enough to be making statements like that yk. When it comes to the Seerah and history of Islam, I kind of rely on my mowlana for knowledge and would repeat that to whoever asks. I will try and get more info for you for tmrw at 2pm.

Good luck with your DoE trip. Have you just finished Y11?

Reply 12

Original post by hh1209
Honestly, I don't know enough to be making statements like that yk. When it comes to the Seerah and history of Islam, I kind of rely on my mowlana for knowledge and would repeat that to whoever asks. I will try and get more info for you for tmrw at 2pm.
Good luck with your DoE trip. Have you just finished Y11?

no acctually im in yr 10, just finished half of my GCSEs cos my skl lets some students take some of them earlier. Inshallah i get good grades, wbu? did u js finish yr 11??

Reply 13

Original post by Anonymous
no acctually im in yr 10, just finished half of my GCSEs cos my skl lets some students take some of them earlier. Inshallah i get good grades, wbu? did u js finish yr 11??

Yh. It's good that ur asking about this stuff at this young age. Keep asking things and strengthening your islamic knowledge.

Reply 14

Original post by hh1209
Yh. It's good that ur asking about this stuff at this young age. Keep asking things and strengthening your islamic knowledge.

thank you. i love learning more abt islam and enjoy taking part in islamic debates, but the barrier between sunni and shia muslims always comes up, and i hate how we r so segregated. i mean not all the time cos i have many sunni friends, but countless times i have heard people in my classes mocking shias until they find out that im one. im not sure if shias do the same, but i dont know any shias who have a problem with sunnis. is it because we're a minority??

Reply 15

also, how do u feel about shiaism. u can be completely honest i dont mind

Reply 16

Original post by Anonymous
also, how do u feel about shiaism. u can be completely honest i dont mind

I have never really understood it if I am honest. There are some parts that I just don't get, but that might be from the minority of Shias. tbh, I've just always been taught not to not like Shias and to disagree with them. But I honestly never rlly paid attention to it much. There are some things that make me laugh about it, but that is just a couple of videos that mean nothing:

Reply 17

Original post by hh1209
I have never really understood it if I am honest. There are some parts that I just don't get, but that might be from the minority of Shias. tbh, I've just always been taught not to not like Shias and to disagree with them. But I honestly never rlly paid attention to it much. There are some things that make me laugh about it, but that is just a couple of videos that mean nothing:

😂😂

Reply 18

Original post by User_09
😂😂

It is bloody funny lol

Reply 19

have u seen the video of sufi muslims

btw, im Anonymous #1, but its js not giving me the anonymous option anymore. But anyway, have u seen it?? This always makes me laugh

Quick Reply