The Student Room Group

Rejected a woman because she had a child, now not sure of my decision

This is an older persons issue but I don't know where to post some young people are wise. I rejected a woman because she has a child. Now I'm not sure if my decision because she is a rarity and absolutely lovely, we had some really sincere conversation and were both into it it looked promising. But I got cold feet because she had a kid and I am childless. Have I made the right decision?

Reply 1

'Not sure OF my decision' that should read

Reply 2

Hmmm this is a really deep one. so if i'm to get you right, you rejected her because she has a child and you are childless.?
Are you sure that's why or because you think the child will not accept you.
Either way, no one can decide whether you made the right decision except you. People can only give opinions.

However, if you think you don't want her because of the child, i'd advise you think really deep about it and make sure that later on you won't regret your decision but if you don't want her because you think the child will not accept you, you can talk to her about it and try to build a strong bond/ connection with the child and see the child as your own because you can't love the mother and hate the child in this case they are one and you can't separate them by taking one and ignoring the other

Reply 3

What's the exact issue with her having a child; eg, do you think you won't be have as much time together as you hope and that the child will be prioritised? Is it because of the relationship she's had with someone to have produced a child? Is it something you could overcome?

Do you want children in a future relationship?

Reply 4

Original post
by Anonymous
Hmmm this is a really deep one. so if i'm to get you right, you rejected her because she has a child and you are childless.?
Are you sure that's why or because you think the child will not accept you.
Either way, no one can decide whether you made the right decision except you. People can only give opinions.
However, if you think you don't want her because of the child, i'd advise you think really deep about it and make sure that later on you won't regret your decision but if you don't want her because you think the child will not accept you, you can talk to her about it and try to build a strong bond/ connection with the child and see the child as your own because you can't love the mother and hate the child in this case they are one and you can't separate them by taking one and ignoring the other

Yes I am childless she has one child. Thanks for the advice.

Reply 5

I don't want children no, it's too complicated. Her and I are too old to do that now anyhow. I feel that her having had a kid with a guy complicates things. I'm not sure if the guys even still around actually. But yeah the child would need a lot of attention at least for the next ten years, I mean at least ten years until she's 18 I think. It's not the same as being on a level playing field and both being childless

Reply 6

I have done that myself, I absolutely despise children.

Reply 7

Original post
by random_matt
I have done that myself, I absolutely despise children.

I don't think hers would be a best though,if it's anything like her the opposite

Reply 8

Original post
by Anonymous
I don't think hers would be a best though,if it's anything like her the opposite

'Would be a brat' that should read, it's autocorrect

Reply 9

There is no one here can simply tell you if you made the right choice, you'd be quicker tossing a coin.

If I have to guess? you prob made a choice you'll regret. The older we get, esp for men seeking women, the more chance the women we seek either has children, or is in a bit of a rush to do so. It is what it is.

My partner has two teenage girls and tbh we're largely indifferent to each other, we'll say hello and chat a bit, I'll put in a bit towards gifts/treats and give the occasional lift somewhere, that's pretty much it.

Reply 10

Original post
by Anonymous
Yes I am childless she has one child. Thanks for the advice.

you're welcome😊

Reply 11

Original post
by Anonymous
I don't want children no, it's too complicated. Her and I are too old to do that now anyhow. I feel that her having had a kid with a guy complicates things. I'm not sure if the guys even still around actually. But yeah the child would need a lot of attention at least for the next ten years, I mean at least ten years until she's 18 I think. It's not the same as being on a level playing field and both being childless

It's pretty easy to challenge a lot of this. At your age (I'm guessing roughly 35-40) any women that you meet is going to have a significant amount of background, friends, former partners and so on. They will have lived a lot of their life before meeting you, so there will always be people who know them better, knew them first, and shared significant and intimate experiences with them. They will also have more obligations, demands, and quirks than younger people because they have lived longer. There's generally more to adjust to when you're dating at a younger age.

For me, children are one of those things that can naturally be added to that mix. Is a child a significant obligation? Of course. Is it a significant obligation on you as a new partner? To a degree. There's always an obligation on you when you're interacting and spending time with someone else's child, particularly as a new partner. There is potential for you to become that child's family. I don't necessarily see how that complicates things, because as I say, there will always be family and friends of hers that you meet and interact with, and she will always have other obligations in terms of career, interests and so on even if she didn't have a child. I also think you're over estimating the time obligation. If this was a newborn then that's different, but an 8 year old will also her own hobbies and interests. You won't suddenly become a full time father. Your partner would be well used to being a single parent, and would naturally introduce you gradually rather than suddenly making you her new parent. Equally, her daughter may spend some time with her father, but that doesn't place any obligation on you. In fact it does the opposite, as it would give you two more time alone. I get the thoughts around your partner having had a child with another man, but at your age any woman you date will have likely had a notable number of partners. The fact of one of those resulting in a child is just, again, something that can happen.

All of that said, I am saying that to you as someone who has children with my wife, and we've been together since we were teenagers. My circumstances are different and my experiences, both in my relationship and in having children, are different. It would not be right of me to dismiss your concerns simply because I have had children and enjoy having children, because we're different people. I'm also not naive enough to think that my experience of having several children means you won't have an issue with one who is not your own. If you don't want to have children and don't want to be involved with children, that is your choice.

At the same time, I do agree with Strider that if I was to guess, this is something that you may regret. To my mind the more sensible approach to take, particularly given what else you've said about her, would be to pursue this, and if you simply cannot get on board with her having a child, or there are other complications such as with her ex, then break it off at that point. But it does seem to be that the decision was at least premature. In your position I would have least had given it a chance. If it's still an option, I'd seriously consider going back and seeing if you can pick things up again. The worst that happens is that after a relatively short time your concerns are realised and you break up. But it seems to me that there is a decent chance that this doesn't play out how you accept, that having a partner with a child isn't the negative experience you think it is, and that you end in a long term relationship with a wonderful partner. To my mind, I think that's worth taking a chance on.

Reply 12

Original post
by Anonymous
This is an older persons issue but I don't know where to post some young people are wise. I rejected a woman because she has a child. Now I'm not sure if my decision because she is a rarity and absolutely lovely, we had some really sincere conversation and were both into it it looked promising. But I got cold feet because she had a kid and I am childless. Have I made the right decision?

Are you afraid Of being a father or something of that matter if you really love and care about her and you only backed out because of the kid is it because you don't think you will be a good father or you don't think the kid will like you I would just like some elaboration you don't have to if you don't want to but I need to know why the child affects the relationship before I can give a proper helpful answer

Reply 13

Original post
by Anonymous
Are you afraid Of being a father or something of that matter if you really love and care about her and you only backed out because of the kid is it because you don't think you will be a good father or you don't think the kid will like you I would just like some elaboration you don't have to if you don't want to but I need to know why the child affects the relationship before I can give a proper helpful answer

Just that how could we be together alone when the kid has needs? And yeah I don't want the added complication of trying to get on with the kid, not that I'm saying it's a bad kid.

Reply 14

Original post
by Crazy Jamie
It's pretty easy to challenge a lot of this. At your age (I'm guessing roughly 35-40) any women that you meet is going to have a significant amount of background, friends, former partners and so on. They will have lived a lot of their life before meeting you, so there will always be people who know them better, knew them first, and shared significant and intimate experiences with them. They will also have more obligations, demands, and quirks than younger people because they have lived longer. There's generally more to adjust to when you're dating at a younger age.
For me, children are one of those things that can naturally be added to that mix. Is a child a significant obligation? Of course. Is it a significant obligation on you as a new partner? To a degree. There's always an obligation on you when you're interacting and spending time with someone else's child, particularly as a new partner. There is potential for you to become that child's family. I don't necessarily see how that complicates things, because as I say, there will always be family and friends of hers that you meet and interact with, and she will always have other obligations in terms of career, interests and so on even if she didn't have a child. I also think you're over estimating the time obligation. If this was a newborn then that's different, but an 8 year old will also her own hobbies and interests. You won't suddenly become a full time father. Your partner would be well used to being a single parent, and would naturally introduce you gradually rather than suddenly making you her new parent. Equally, her daughter may spend some time with her father, but that doesn't place any obligation on you. In fact it does the opposite, as it would give you two more time alone. I get the thoughts around your partner having had a child with another man, but at your age any woman you date will have likely had a notable number of partners. The fact of one of those resulting in a child is just, again, something that can happen.
All of that said, I am saying that to you as someone who has children with my wife, and we've been together since we were teenagers. My circumstances are different and my experiences, both in my relationship and in having children, are different. It would not be right of me to dismiss your concerns simply because I have had children and enjoy having children, because we're different people. I'm also not naive enough to think that my experience of having several children means you won't have an issue with one who is not your own. If you don't want to have children and don't want to be involved with children, that is your choice.
At the same time, I do agree with Strider that if I was to guess, this is something that you may regret. To my mind the more sensible approach to take, particularly given what else you've said about her, would be to pursue this, and if you simply cannot get on board with her having a child, or there are other complications such as with her ex, then break it off at that point. But it does seem to be that the decision was at least premature. In your position I would have least had given it a chance. If it's still an option, I'd seriously consider going back and seeing if you can pick things up again. The worst that happens is that after a relatively short time your concerns are realised and you break up. But it seems to me that there is a decent chance that this doesn't play out how you accept, that having a partner with a child isn't the negative experience you think it is, and that you end in a long term relationship with a wonderful partner. To my mind, I think that's worth taking a chance on.

Thanks for this detailed post I will think about this answer.

Reply 15

Original post
by Anonymous
Just that how could we be together alone when the kid has needs? And yeah I don't want the added complication of trying to get on with the kid, not that I'm saying it's a bad kid.

Well yeah I see your point there but you have to be willing to take a chance depending on how old the kid is they will still go to bed and you guys will be alone and stuff you can get babysitters to have date nights and things I don't think getting in with the kid will be to hard depending on how young they are but I think if you really love this women give it a shot and remember you never need to rush anything hope this helps 🤗

Reply 16

Original post
by Anonymous
Just that how could we be together alone when the kid has needs? And yeah I don't want the added complication of trying to get on with the kid, not that I'm saying it's a bad kid.

If you don’t want the hassle of getting on with the kid, you made the right decision. Not for your sake, but for hers. As a mother, she wouldn’t want to bring a man into her child’s life who does not care for the child. To a mother, her child’s wellbeing always comes first.

Reply 17

Original post
by Anonymous
This is an older persons issue but I don't know where to post some young people are wise. I rejected a woman because she has a child. Now I'm not sure if my decision because she is a rarity and absolutely lovely, we had some really sincere conversation and were both into it it looked promising. But I got cold feet because she had a kid and I am childless. Have I made the right decision?

It is not wise to play another man’s saved game and raise his kid. If you had your own kid, it would balance it but making that move could be risky imho.

Personally, i would not do it

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.