The Student Room Group

Dissertation marked 0

My dissertation was marked zero. Can I still receive a MSc degree from the university? My university is Durham University.

Reply 1

From my understanding, I’m afraid not. If you don’t pass all modules, you’ll receive a postgraduate diploma and not a degree as, in order to complete a MSc degree, you must receive all 180 credits. At least that’s how my course was (UWE).

From what I’ve seen online, it says you’ll be offered a chance to resit it but given the time of year, I’m assuming you’ve just done the resit (please forgive me if I’m wrong). I would suggest having a discussion with your course leader and seeing what opportunities can be offered.

EDIT:
Source: https://www.durham.ac.uk/media/durham-university/governance/programme-regulations/postgraduate/coreregsmtmd.pdf

"14. A student must gain credits as follows subject to the requirements of the relevant programme regulations: a) for the award of a Master’s degree: a total of 180 credits including at least 150 credits at Level 4. b) for the award of a Postgraduate Diploma: a total of 120 credits including at least 90 credits at Level 4. c) for the award of a Postgraduate Certificate: a total of 60 credits including at least 40 credits at Level 4."
(edited 1 year ago)

Reply 2

Original post
by RedElf
My dissertation was marked zero. Can I still receive a MSc degree from the university? My university is Durham University.

Presumably you were given a reason for your mark?

Reply 3

Original post
by Scienceisgood
From my understanding, I’m afraid not. If you don’t pass all modules, you’ll receive a postgraduate diploma and not a degree as, in order to complete a MSc degree, you must receive all 180 credits. At least that’s how my course was (UWE).
From what I’ve seen online, it says you’ll be offered a chance to resit it but given the time of year, I’m assuming you’ve just done the resit (please forgive me if I’m wrong). I would suggest having a discussion with your course leader and seeing what opportunities can be offered.
EDIT:
Source: https://www.durham.ac.uk/media/durham-university/governance/programme-regulations/postgraduate/coreregsmtmd.pdf
"14. A student must gain credits as follows subject to the requirements of the relevant programme regulations: a) for the award of a Master’s degree: a total of 180 credits including at least 150 credits at Level 4. b) for the award of a Postgraduate Diploma: a total of 120 credits including at least 90 credits at Level 4. c) for the award of a Postgraduate Certificate: a total of 60 credits including at least 40 credits at Level 4."

Hi, thank you for your support. This was not a resit, but rather a regular submission of my dissertation (the deadline was in early September), and the marks are due to be released shortly. Recently, the university contacted me regarding a suspicion of plagiarism. Today, I attended a panel where my work was marked zero.
I fully agree with another post here about Turnitin being a flawed system that academia should not rely on exclusively. Unfortunately, people tend to judge based solely on the similarity report, and if the score is high, it is immediately assumed to be plagiarism. The "discussion" arranged by the university was not a discussion at all; it was a meeting marked by bias and prejudice, where I was expected to defend myself. I want to emphasize that I did not plagiarize anything.
At this point, I am hoping to at least receive a Postgraduate Diploma.
By the way, as an international student, given my situation, would I still be eligible to apply for a Graduate Visa? I understand that it is available only after successful course completion. Is a Postgraduate Diploma considered a successful course completion for this purpose?

Reply 4

Original post
by RedElf
Hi, thank you for your support. This was not a resit, but rather a regular submission of my dissertation (the deadline was in early September), and the marks are due to be released shortly. Recently, the university contacted me regarding a suspicion of plagiarism. Today, I attended a panel where my work was marked zero.
I fully agree with another post here about Turnitin being a flawed system that academia should not rely on exclusively. Unfortunately, people tend to judge based solely on the similarity report, and if the score is high, it is immediately assumed to be plagiarism. The "discussion" arranged by the university was not a discussion at all; it was a meeting marked by bias and prejudice, where I was expected to defend myself. I want to emphasize that I did not plagiarize anything.
At this point, I am hoping to at least receive a Postgraduate Diploma.
By the way, as an international student, given my situation, would I still be eligible to apply for a Graduate Visa? I understand that it is available only after successful course completion. Is a Postgraduate Diploma considered a successful course completion for this purpose?


I’m afraid I can’t say anything about a graduate visa as I don’t work in academia, nor am I an international student (technically by definition, I’m only a student for an additional 12 days as my graduation is on the 26th November). So I’m afraid I can’t comment on this.

I would discuss anything regarding this with your course leader (or hope someone may happen upon this thread more knowledgable than myself on this). If you are in a position, perhaps they may allow you an additional attempt at it but I’m afraid I can’t say much beyond that as I don’t know the regulations for your position I’m afraid, I just know what I was told when I joined the course.

Good luck and I hope it works out for you!

Reply 5

Original post
by RedElf
Hi, thank you for your support. This was not a resit, but rather a regular submission of my dissertation (the deadline was in early September), and the marks are due to be released shortly. Recently, the university contacted me regarding a suspicion of plagiarism. Today, I attended a panel where my work was marked zero.
I fully agree with another post here about Turnitin being a flawed system that academia should not rely on exclusively. Unfortunately, people tend to judge based solely on the similarity report, and if the score is high, it is immediately assumed to be plagiarism. The "discussion" arranged by the university was not a discussion at all; it was a meeting marked by bias and prejudice, where I was expected to defend myself. I want to emphasize that I did not plagiarize anything.
At this point, I am hoping to at least receive a Postgraduate Diploma.
By the way, as an international student, given my situation, would I still be eligible to apply for a Graduate Visa? I understand that it is available only after successful course completion. Is a Postgraduate Diploma considered a successful course completion for this purpose?

Why would you not expect to defend yourself?

As you're a graduate student shouldn't you know how to write academically without falling into the trap of plagiarising?

Reply 6

Original post
by RedElf
My dissertation was marked zero. Can I still receive a MSc degree from the university? My university is Durham University.

Did you write anything? Did you plagiarise? Durham is a serious university. Are you?

Reply 7

Original post
by RedElf
Hi, thank you for your support. This was not a resit, but rather a regular submission of my dissertation (the deadline was in early September), and the marks are due to be released shortly. Recently, the university contacted me regarding a suspicion of plagiarism. Today, I attended a panel where my work was marked zero.
I fully agree with another post here about Turnitin being a flawed system that academia should not rely on exclusively. Unfortunately, people tend to judge based solely on the similarity report, and if the score is high, it is immediately assumed to be plagiarism. The "discussion" arranged by the university was not a discussion at all; it was a meeting marked by bias and prejudice, where I was expected to defend myself. I want to emphasize that I did not plagiarize anything.
At this point, I am hoping to at least receive a Postgraduate Diploma.
By the way, as an international student, given my situation, would I still be eligible to apply for a Graduate Visa? I understand that it is available only after successful course completion. Is a Postgraduate Diploma considered a successful course completion for this purpose?

Turnitin used to ignore the so-and-so says and then the quote - "arguing" it was all copied (it was, but with full acknowledgement of who said what when). What gets most ignored by universities (and they know this) is that rich students get tutors for all their subjects. Did you use a tutor? Then the work is not yours.

Reply 8

Original post
by Voxdei
Turnitin used to ignore the so-and-so says and then the quote - "arguing" it was all copied (it was, but with full acknowledgement of who said what when). What gets most ignored by universities (and they know this) is that rich students get tutors for all their subjects. Did you use a tutor? Then the work is not yours.

I wrote my dissertation by myself.

Reply 9

Original post
by Voxdei
Did you write anything? Did you plagiarise? Durham is a serious university. Are you?

1) Yes I did. I wrote a dissertation.
2) No, I did not.
3) Yes, I am a serious student.

Reply 10

Original post
by Scienceisgood
I’m afraid I can’t say anything about a graduate visa as I don’t work in academia, nor am I an international student (technically by definition, I’m only a student for an additional 12 days as my graduation is on the 26th November). So I’m afraid I can’t comment on this.
I would discuss anything regarding this with your course leader (or hope someone may happen upon this thread more knowledgable than myself on this). If you are in a position, perhaps they may allow you an additional attempt at it but I’m afraid I can’t say much beyond that as I don’t know the regulations for your position I’m afraid, I just know what I was told when I joined the course.
Good luck and I hope it works out for you!

Thanks for your support anyway.

Reply 11

From my thinking perspective, if a student does not pass all of the required modules, they would typically be awarded a Postgraduate Diploma rather than a Master’s or PhD degree. This is because, in order to complete an MSc, you need to accumulate all 180 credits.

Moreover, don’t panic in this daunting situation. Students have another chance to resit any failed modules. For the next opportunity not to fail, the student must conduct a meeting with their supervisor to determine the mistakes they have made previously that caused the failure.

While another approach for their satisfaction they can seek assistance from a dissertation editor online which will be a great decision that marks out the key mistakes and helps to gain high academic grades.

Reply 12

TurnItIn is categorically not used in isolation or 'exclusively' in these circumstances. However, it is a useful tool and will show precisely where the similarities have come from, and will show us (markers) the piece of work to which the similarity is attached. There has to be something more to this.

Reply 13

Original post
by RedElf
My dissertation was marked zero. Can I still receive a MSc degree from the university? My university is Durham University.


Hello there, to avoid such just minimize plagiarism, don't use AI anywhere, discuss the topic thoughtfully, and format accordingly. Any more questions or support, let me know.
Original post
by Gagan Snr
Hello there, to avoid such just minimize plagiarism, don't use AI anywhere, discuss the topic thoughtfully, and format accordingly. Any more questions or support, let me know.

The dissertation has already been submitted, so this advice comes about 4 months too late.
Original post
by RedElf
My dissertation was marked zero. Can I still receive a MSc degree from the university? My university is Durham University.

I agree with @gjd800 that there may be a bit more to this than has been shared so far. Advice to you would be to use any advice service that your student union may have, they will have dealt with plenty of plagiarism cases at your university before and will be very familiar with the regs. Usually you can have one of their advisors in the review meetings to support and guide you in the process. Let us know if the university allow you to continue your studies! :redface:

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.