The Student Room Group

Help Medicine or finance

Hi guys,
I got a pretty daunting situation where I’m stuck on how I want to move on in my life.
I have taken a gap year and in year 13 applied for medicine and 2 economics courses too. I didn’t do well in my medicine application as a whole and I think that influenced my decision into thinking medicine is not for me.
Now im applying again and I’m having doubts about whether I want to have a life in finance.

If I flipped a coin and on one side was medicine the other accounting and finance. I’m afraid my heart seems to push more for the medicine side. But I would need another gap year and start all over again. And if I am not successful yet another gap year.

Please please if anyone was in my situation and you can advise I would appreciate it so much.

Reply 1

Original post
by zynnjah123
Hi guys,
I got a pretty daunting situation where I’m stuck on how I want to move on in my life.
I have taken a gap year and in year 13 applied for medicine and 2 economics courses too. I didn’t do well in my medicine application as a whole and I think that influenced my decision into thinking medicine is not for me.
Now im applying again and I’m having doubts about whether I want to have a life in finance.
If I flipped a coin and on one side was medicine the other accounting and finance. I’m afraid my heart seems to push more for the medicine side. But I would need another gap year and start all over again. And if I am not successful yet another gap year.
Please please if anyone was in my situation and you can advise I would appreciate it so much.

hi, its all about your strengeth and confidence. If you can study and complete medicine. Go for it.

Reply 2

I'm not sure anyone can answer this for you. If you dont have work experience in a healthcare role (HCA ideally or a carer), that might be a good start. Especially for your gap year.

For reference, im just a GEM med applicant (with interviews). I've seen countless posts online advising to avoid medicine. For me personally, I've worked as a physio for 10yrs and know the pressures of the NHS. I know unequivocally that I want to be a doctor and it's the only occupation I'm passionate about. Every doctor I've spoken to in real life, while acknowledging how difficult med is, has said they would never have chosen a different profession and love their jobs. Obviously the money is less than a finance role, but for someone like myself, it's a lot more money, even at just F2.

I've seen many posts online about those who have switched from med to finance, and that it's not an easy transition. And I've seen posts from those who have left and returned to med, or move to medicine from finance. The overriding sentiment seems to be medicine is just more rewarding. But there's plenty of people saying they don't miss medicine either. I don't think finance roles are a walk in the park, you'll have similar difficulty with long hours, difficult workloads and high competition.

It comes down to what your passion is. Which is an enormously difficult thing to decide at 18 years old. You can always apply for grad medicine if you study maths/accounting etc and decide it's not for you. And vise versa. I realise this doesn't answer your question at all, but i hope it was some food for thought.

Reply 3

Original post
by Vanillagorilla5
I'm not sure anyone can answer this for you. If you dont have work experience in a healthcare role (HCA ideally or a carer), that might be a good start. Especially for your gap year.
For reference, im just a GEM med applicant (with interviews). I've seen countless posts online advising to avoid medicine. For me personally, I've worked as a physio for 10yrs and know the pressures of the NHS. I know unequically that I want to be a doctor and it's the only occupation I'm passionate about. Every doctor I've spoken to in real life, while acknowledging how difficult med is, has said they would never have chosen a different profession and love their jobs. Obviously the money is less than a finance role, but for someone like myself, it's a lot more money, even at just F2.
I've seen many posts online about those who have switched from med to finance, and that it's not an easy transition. And I've seen posts from those who have left and returned to med, or move to medicine from finance. The overriding sentiment seems to be medicine is just more rewarding. But there's plenty of people saying they don't miss medicine either. I don't think finance roles are a walk in the park, you'll have similar difficulty with long hours, difficult workloads and high competition.
It comes down to what your passion is. Which is an enormously difficult thing to decide at 18 years old. You can always apply for grad medicine if you study maths/accounting etc and decide it's not for you. And vise versa. I realise this doesn't answer your question at all, but i hope it was some food for thought.

I’m glad I came across your post as an undergrad student looking to do Medicine, this has definitely given me something to think about.

I can’t think of other careers that I’d genuinely be interested in, but due to hearing a lot of negativity from those in the profession it made me doubt whether I was making the right decision.
Original post
by zynnjah123
Hi guys,
I got a pretty daunting situation where I’m stuck on how I want to move on in my life.
I have taken a gap year and in year 13 applied for medicine and 2 economics courses too. I didn’t do well in my medicine application as a whole and I think that influenced my decision into thinking medicine is not for me.
Now im applying again and I’m having doubts about whether I want to have a life in finance.
If I flipped a coin and on one side was medicine the other accounting and finance. I’m afraid my heart seems to push more for the medicine side. But I would need another gap year and start all over again. And if I am not successful yet another gap year.
Please please if anyone was in my situation and you can advise I would appreciate it so much.
I think I'm qualified to answer this question, at least from a personal perspective. I know people who have taken several gap year(s), myself included. It's tough putting studies on hold especially when your friends from college have 'move on' with their life and are finishing their degrees already. However, medicine in itself is a long degree, 5 years plus 1-2 years depending on intercalation and BM6 year 0 years or years out - 'taking a break' from studies. I chose to continue to pursue a career in medicine because of a number reasons, the main one being while I was good at maths during sixth form and I did enjoy it to a degree (was fortunate enough to be able to grasp the concepts without much work and genuinely found it satisfying when a question would click into place nicely) I missed the science of biology and to a lesser degree chemistry (didn't really like Chemistry all that much at A level, haven't come across it as such to a deeper degree at medical school so far). In theory, going for economics would be fairly straightforward as the subject requirements aren't that specific, many accept you if you took maths as an A level and my subjects (maths, chem, bio) were more than enough with the required grades. See if you can do some work experience during your gap years, I know lots of people on various courses across the country who did different jobs from HCAs to office work/administration. Please don't worry about feeling behind and the uncertainty of it all (easier said than done!) as life is a marathon, not a sprint. Everyone has a different journey, there's numerous people who are graduates on the BM5 course and also multiple mature students. It just means you have more life experience etc. Feel free to reply to this message if you have any more questions.

Reply 5

Original post
by Unistudent2101
I’m glad I came across your post as an undergrad student looking to do Medicine, this has definitely given me something to think about.
I can’t think of other careers that I’d genuinely be interested in, but due to hearing a lot of negativity from those in the profession it made me doubt whether I was making the right decision.

I'm happy to hear that. Before approaching doctors at work (and one from my gym), my only contact was doctors on Reddit. And the doctors Reddit is pure hatred for: the profession, healthcare professionals, PAs, ANPs/ACPs and basically everything. But I think they only represent a very small amount of doctors, and a very specific demographic. It's an echo chamber of extremely upset people, and it won't give you the full picture.

This week I've been reading the book Your Life In My Hands by Rachel Clarke. Talks about all the doctor struggles up to 2017. Talks about all the ups/downs of the life of a doctor in the UK. Has spurred me on more to want to pursue medicine.
(edited 1 year ago)

Reply 6

Original post
by medic0975
I think I'm qualified to answer this question, at least from a personal perspective. I know people who have taken several gap year(s), myself included. It's tough putting studies on hold especially when your friends from college have 'move on' with their life and are finishing their degrees already. However, medicine in itself is a long degree, 5 years plus 1-2 years depending on intercalation and BM6 year 0 years or years out - 'taking a break' from studies. I chose to continue to pursue a career in medicine because of a number reasons, the main one being while I was good at maths during sixth form and I did enjoy it to a degree (was fortunate enough to be able to grasp the concepts without much work and genuinely found it satisfying when a question would click into place nicely) I missed the science of biology and to a lesser degree chemistry (didn't really like Chemistry all that much at A level, haven't come across it as such to a deeper degree at medical school so far). In theory, going for economics would be fairly straightforward as the subject requirements aren't that specific, many accept you if you took maths as an A level and my subjects (maths, chem, bio) were more than enough with the required grades. See if you can do some work experience during your gap years, I know lots of people on various courses across the country who did different jobs from HCAs to office work/administration. Please don't worry about feeling behind and the uncertainty of it all (easier said than done!) as life is a marathon, not a sprint. Everyone has a different journey, there's numerous people who are graduates on the BM5 course and also multiple mature students. It just means you have more life experience etc. Feel free to reply to this message if you have any more questions.

Hiiii,
dude for some reason this never came on my notifications.

I so appreciate hearing someone was in a similar position. When I tell you I am literally the same as you, I love biology, love the science of medicine and how I can be an excellent professional and lead in cracking down on people’s health issues.
I also hate chemistry so it’s good to hear u don’t see much of it.

The thing with medicine, is sure it’s a longer course, but if I do get the degree and I want to enter finance I still very much can.
It’s a very good degree infact possibly the most impressive bachelors to have on a Cv.

I was thinking of going finance related things like private qualifications and exams and gaining experience and things.
All which mean I could easily apply for a 1 year masters at top 5 or 10 uni. And overall be more competitive than other students who perhaps did finance courses from the start.

Also it gives me the flexibility of either moving fully into a career doctor position or doing something else in finance.

Does that make sense ? It’s like I can still enter it. And the 5 years gives me lots of time to decide for sure. And I gain incomparable skills too.

If you think I’m thinking wrong please let me know.

Reply 7

Original post
by zynnjah123
Hi guys,
I got a pretty daunting situation where I’m stuck on how I want to move on in my life.
I have taken a gap year and in year 13 applied for medicine and 2 economics courses too. I didn’t do well in my medicine application as a whole and I think that influenced my decision into thinking medicine is not for me.
Now im applying again and I’m having doubts about whether I want to have a life in finance.
If I flipped a coin and on one side was medicine the other accounting and finance. I’m afraid my heart seems to push more for the medicine side. But I would need another gap year and start all over again. And if I am not successful yet another gap year.
Please please if anyone was in my situation and you can advise I would appreciate it so much.


i mean medicine is a very stable career, and u become a junior doctor straight away, whereas in finance it can be difficult to land a job and competition is immense.

Reply 8

Original post
by Vanillagorilla5
I'm happy to hear that. Before approaching doctors at work (and one from my gym), my only contact was doctors on Reddit. And the doctors Reddit is pure hatred for: the profession, healthcare professionals, PAs, ANPs/ACPs and basically everything. But I think they only represent a very small amount of doctors, and a very specific demographic. It's an echo chamber of extremely upset people, and it won't give you the full picture.
This week I've been reading the book Your Life In My Hands by Rachel Clarke. Talks about all the doctor struggles up to 2017. Talks about all the ups/downs of the life of a doctor in the UK. Has spurred me on more to want to pursue medicine.

Same with me, Reddit was the only place where I could read about doctor’s opinions and was making me doubt whether it is the right decision to pursue med. I thought surely if all these doctors have a negative outlook on the profession, that’s a sign that I shouldn’t ignore.

But then again like you also said, I came across someone saying that Reddit doesn’t represent everyone’s opinion in the profession which helped me put things into perspective.

The only thing I’m a bit concerned about is funding med as a graduate but I’ll figure that out if and when I get an offer.

Sounds like a good book, I’ll check it out.

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.