The Student Room Logo
Student at University of Edinburgh
University of Edinburgh
This thread is closed

Thread for accommodation questions for 09/10 entry - READ & POST HERE FIRST :o)

Scroll to see replies

Reply 400
TamLu

I'd like to apply for WPC and/or WPR, but from what I gather, they're located at a bit of a distance from the center. The distance is not a problem in and of itself, but I've been thinking... What's it like going home, say, after a night out (on your own, of course)? Is it really quiet and deserted? Lighting?


I lived on WPR in my first year, and have been in Marchmont (the area of the city where WPR/C are) since then, so 3 years now. It's perfectly fine walking around at night, especially if you are heading back home around 1am and 3am (to coincide with the kick out times in pubs and clubs) then the Meadows are really full and there are sometimes more people out and about then than in the morning if it isn't coming in/out of lecture time. There are ALWAYS people on the Meadows, particularly on Jaw Bone Walk which is the path which crosses it that you take to Marchmont. It only takes 4 minutes to get across there anyway if you walk quickly. Don't be put off by the name, it's called that because they have some form whale/sharks jaw at one end of the path! The only time I have ever been worried about walking over the Meadows was around 5am in the morning on a very very foggy December morning in my first year when I was walking to get the airport bus, and then I was genuinely scared because there was no one around to see me. Other than that, in 3 years it hasn't phased me at all, although as the others have said, some people do seem really worried about the safety factor and take taxis constantly. But I do think they have more money than sense in that respect.

I find Edinburgh to be a very safe city - I'm from close to Nottingham originally, and in comparision, Nottingham is a crazy place! Although Nottingham is completely fine too (just incase anyone reads this and thinks they're going to get shot or something if they go there - you won't be).
Student at University of Edinburgh
University of Edinburgh
oxymoronic
The only time I have ever been worried about walking over the Meadows was around 5am in the morning on a very very foggy December morning in my first year when I was walking to get the airport bus, and then I was genuinely scared because there was no one around to see me.


See, I quite like the Meadows when there's no one around - they're so peaceful. Now, I went to Granton late on a Sunday night in February once, that was scary :frown:
Reply 402
artorscience?
But there were plenty of people I knew who were very fearful of something and got cabs all the time, so if you're of a paranoid disposition, you'll easily find people to share cabs with.


oxymoronic
some people do seem really worried about the safety factor and take taxis constantly. But I do think they have more money than sense in that respect.


Sounds like me. Except I find it hard to decide if I've got less money or sense:biggrin:

I get scared very, very easily. I've searched for pictures of the Meadows and, beautiful as they are, walking across them at night is guaranteed to have me scared to death:o: And I don't really fancy the idea of taxis, so I think I should probably apply for one of the more central residences.

Which is really too bad, because I was hoping to apply for a small room. And, having excluded WPC/WPR, looking at the accomm site, I can't seem to find 3 non-Cowgate self-catered residences that offer small rooms. Also, WPC and WPR seemed so nice
Oh well, I guess it doesn't make that much of a difference since it all kinda comes down to luck of the draw.

Do you think someone like me might find walking around The Meadows less scary? Or is it all the same? And would taking that alternate route be very absurd/take way too long to be worth it?
Silly question, I know, but had to try asking:smile:
TamLu
And I don't really fancy the idea of taxis, so I think I should probably apply for one of the more central residences.


Seem to be slightly misunderstanding the geography of central Edinburgh here. You aren't going to be any safer living right in the middle than you will be living the outpost of Marchmont, all of 10 minutes away. If you're not comfortable going outside in the dark then perhaps city living and Scotland are not for you - in winter it is dark here a lot, you can't let that bother you.
Reply 404
I've tried to read through all of this thread, it seems quite a few people are going for things other than the sciences. I'm pretty much decided on being self-catered, but which places would you recommend for someone who's doing Physics? I'm English, going in for an MPhys (5 years :|) in the first year. A bigger place would be nicer, so I can get to know more people. From what I've gathered, it seems a standard room should be fine, and larger rooms are a rip-off?
Reply 405
nearlyheadlessian
Seem to be slightly misunderstanding the geography of central Edinburgh here. You aren't going to be any safer living right in the middle than you will be living the outpost of Marchmont, all of 10 minutes away. If you're not comfortable going outside in the dark then perhaps city living and Scotland are not for you - in winter it is dark here a lot, you can't let that bother you.


It's not city living and the dark that frighten me, it's more the park aspect of The Meadows. I know artorscience and oxymoronic have said there's always someone around, but going through a park area at night still seems scary to me. And the uni accomm site says that the Meadows are not recommended for single persons at night (yeah, I know they have to say that, but still).
The city is just fine. That's why I'm wondering if it would be completely absurd, distance-wise, to take an alternative route to Marchmont.

But, yeah, I haven't a clue about the geography of Edinburgh:o: I'm basing it all on TSR, the uni site and Google Pictures:biggrin:
hi fellow edinburghians

well havent applied for accommodation yet whats the deadline for international students..??
Edinburgh halls of residents prices are like woaaaaaaa.-.-
so ppl which one is the best,i started reading this thread and died on page 2 .
I am an indianish looking dude and a party animal,so im aiming to end up in an accommo with international students.
I hope i dont end up with a bunch of "yahs"..first time i heard this phrase i thought it was people who said "yah" instead of "yes"..haha
Reply 407
TamLu

Do you think someone like me might find walking around The Meadows less scary? Or is it all the same? And would taking that alternate route be very absurd/take way too long to be worth it?
Silly question, I know, but had to try asking:smile:


Well you could walk around Melville Drive and into Marchmont but that will take much much longer, and frankly, has made me feel more unsafe than walking over the Meadows. Basically, there are ALWAYS going to be people going the same way as you on the Meadows because the majority of people live in Marchmont after first year (meaning even if you don't live in WPR/C in first year chances are you'll end up there in subsequent years, or at least spend a lot of time there at friends flats) whereas if you walk around the Meadows there aren't people around, its dark and you have cars tailing behind you.... that road always seems so so so long at night, and I really don't like it. Walking over the Meadows from George Square for example will literally take you less than 5 minutes, walking all the way around will take you around 20.

Seriously I think you're over analysing this way too much. Yes it is a park, but it is fine to walk over, only takes a couple of minutes and there are always going to be loads more students there too. The majority of students in Edinburgh live in Marchmont so do it on a day to day basis. People wouldn't live there if it were considered unsafe.

'nearlyheadlessian'
See, I quite like the Meadows when there's no one around - they're so peaceful. Now, I went to Granton late on a Sunday night in February once, that was scary :frown:


Yeah they are pretty... but you're a guy though... I was absoutley terrifed that night, as it was so so so foggy and I had that 'what if' feeling as I'd seen literally no one in Marchmont meaning if anything had happened to me no one would have known. But as I said, in 3 years thats the only time I've ever been worried in Edinburgh. I'm much more concerned when I wander around Nottingham!
Reply 408
Drayshak
I've tried to read through all of this thread, it seems quite a few people are going for things other than the sciences. I'm pretty much decided on being self-catered, but which places would you recommend for someone who's doing Physics? I'm English, going in for an MPhys (5 years :|) in the first year. A bigger place would be nicer, so I can get to know more people. From what I've gathered, it seems a standard room should be fine, and larger rooms are a rip-off?


Yeah, you've got it on the room sizes, I personally would go for the smallest room option... but standard is fine, certainly do not opt for large rooms whatever you do. Pick anywhere in the central area (ie: don't select Kitchener, David Horn or West Mains Rd just because you're doing scince) and you'll be fine. There is little to choose between the residences really. Scinnes is probably the least generous by the way of communal space, but other than that they're all the same... regardless of how many people live in your building you probably end up knowing the same amount of people, as even if you have 1000 people in your building you wouldn't know all of them.
Reply 409
oxymoronic


Seriously I think you're over analysing this way too much. Yes it is a park, but it is fine to walk over, only takes a couple of minutes and there are always going to be loads more students there too. The majority of students in Edinburgh live in Marchmont so do it on a day to day basis. People wouldn't live there if it were considered unsafe.


Just wanted to thank you for the advice! Decided against WPC/WPR in the end, but really appreciate your help:smile:
Reply 410
Just applied for accommodation! Put Hermit's Croft as first choice, anyone else want that one too?
Reply 411
ikvoria
Just applied for accommodation! Put Hermit's Croft as first choice, anyone else want that one too?


Hermit's croft was one of my choices, my third, though. Then again, the allocation is so random, I don't think it matters by this point!
Reply 412
darroch is my first choice and i've heard from my friends and in TSR as well that it's the most popular and i was wondering if it is?

and when do we hear back from them?

hermit's croft is my 3rd choice as well :smile:
Reply 413
elisabethbridge
There isn't much difference in room sizes.

We only ran out of hot water a few times during the evening when we were doing the dishes. But I did take the occasional shower during night time and there was always hot water available. There were four of us living in the flat. I wasn't even aware of the hot water boost button thingy.

The flats stay pretty warm at all times. And the heaters in each room are really effective. Remember to enjoy the warm flat while you can. When people move to private accommodation they become stingy and don't use the heating, hence I sleep in a sleeping bag under a duvet during the coldest winter. :rolleyes:


thanks, why would people move to private ones?

btw, do people in self catered flats eat/cook together?

i think i'm going to choose college wynd/robinson close/ new arthur place :smile:
I know this is a long shot but has anyone heard back yet? haha
SSze
thanks, why would people move to private ones?

btw, do people in self catered flats eat/cook together?

People move into private accommodation for 4 main reasons. 1) Accommodation Services don't have much accommodation for returning students so if you aren't quick off the mark there's none left. 2) Accommodation Services are fairly poor landlords, they struggle to treat tenants as adults/people taking the approach that they are only students and can put up with poor service. 3) Private accommodation is much nicer, you have absolute freedom over your location, who you live with, and being a city with a high proportion of renters there is lots and lots of choice. 4) If you have a couple of friends to live with it is so much cheaper, unlike most universities, Edinburgh's accommodation is not any cheaper/better value than real world accommodation.

And it depends on who you end up living with, whether you have compatible food tastes/personalities/meal times/schedules/etc. I cooked with some of my flatmates a couple of times at the beginning, and then it became easier to sort ourselves out most of the time with the occasional friendly cooking session. One of my flatmates cooked with friends in the flat above once or twice a week. If you want to do it suggest it when you're there.

Giltterinthegutter
I know this is a long shot but has anyone heard back yet?

30th June is the earliest that you could possibly hear. Don't hold your breath for them.
Reply 416
SSze
thanks, why would people move to private ones?

btw, do people in self catered flats eat/cook together?


well after first year you're not guaranteed a place in uni accomodation so they will help you find private accomodation.

and people do usually cook together when they get to know each other as it saves money cooking for a group than for yourself :smile:
smilelifesgood
hey! i was wandering was the general opinion was on warrender park road/crescent? is it okay location for kings building?


Hi, I lived at Warrender park Cresc. this last year- the flats themselves aren't great, walls are a bit thin and the kitchen units are really old, but the location is gorgeous- right on the meadows with a really nice traffic-free walk/cycle to George sq. If you're lucky you might get a view of the castle from your room which is v nice. Corridors have amazing whistling acoustics and they're also superb for corridor cricket if you're into those things!

It's not too bad at all for KB- it's a 5 min walk to a bus stop then a 5-10 min bus ride.

Hope this helps.
Has anyone else had any trouble accessing the online application for accommodation? I get to the page about email filters, but when I go to confirm, all I get is an error message. I've emailed accommodation services but haven't heard back yet as to what I should do. Was just wondering if anyone else has the same problem?
I was wondering how long you get to reply to an accomodation offer when you recieve one? I was guessing a week but thought I should check.

I am going on holiday and will prob not have internet access from 30th June to 5/6th July, so I was hoping I'd still have time to accept any off.

Latest