The Student Room Group

physics question waves

hi, please could I have some help on this question? I'm confused how statement a is correct? I thought for interference to take place, waves must be emitted from coherent sources so the waves must have a zero or constant phase difference?
here is the question: https://ibb.co/0qt4KTJ
thanks!

Reply 1

Original post
by anonymous56754
hi, please could I have some help on this question? I'm confused how statement a is correct? I thought for interference to take place, waves must be emitted from coherent sources so the waves must have a zero or constant phase difference?
here is the question: https://ibb.co/0qt4KTJ
thanks!

Well, they don’t have to be in phase when they leave the speaker. Ie they could be 180 out of phase when they leave the speaker, that would merely shift where the zero amplitude point was.

Bit of a smart arse question rather than being a decent test of understanding waves and phase

Reply 2

Original post
by nerak99
Well, they don’t have to be in phase when they leave the speaker. Ie they could be 180 out of phase when they leave the speaker, that would merely shift where the zero amplitude point was.
Bit of a smart arse question rather than being a decent test of understanding waves and phase

oh, so for this type of interference, coherent sources aren't required?

Reply 3

Original post
by anonymous56754
oh, so for this type of interference, coherent sources aren't required?

i think the waves still need to be coherent (same frequency and wavelength etc.), but they don't necessarily need to be in phase - they can be 180 out of phase as well.

Reply 4

Original post
by anonymous56754
hi, please could I have some help on this question? I'm confused how statement a is correct? I thought for interference to take place, waves must be emitted from coherent sources so the waves must have a zero or constant phase difference?
here is the question: https://ibb.co/0qt4KTJ
thanks!

Original post
by anonymous56754
oh, so for this type of interference, coherent sources aren't required?

What do you understand by "waves must have a zero or constant phase difference"?

Two important questions concerning what you are asking:

What are the conditions for two waves to interfere?

What are the conditions for an observable interference pattern to occur between the waves from two sources?

Reply 5

Original post
by Eimmanuel
What do you understand by "waves must have a zero or constant phase difference"?
Two important questions concerning what you are asking:
What are the conditions for two waves to interfere?
What are the conditions for an observable interference pattern to occur between the waves from two sources?

In order for interference to take place, the waves must have the same frequency and zero or constant phase difference?

Reply 6

Original post
by Eimmanuel
1) What do you understand by "waves must have a zero or constant phase difference"?

Two important questions concerning what you are asking:

2a) What are the conditions for two waves to interfere?

2b) What are the conditions for an observable interference pattern to occur between the waves from two sources?


Which question are you answering? Q2a or Q2b? Or both Q2a and Q2b?
Original post
by anonymous56754
In order for interference to take place, the waves must have the same frequency and zero or constant phase difference?

Reply 7

Original post
by Eimmanuel
Which question are you answering? Q2a or Q2b? Or both Q2a and Q2b?

It was for both sorry

Reply 8

Two important questions concerning what you are asking:
2a) What are the conditions for two waves to interfere?
2b) What are the conditions for an observable interference pattern to occur between the waves from two sources?

Original post
by anonymous56754
In order for interference to take place, the waves must have the same frequency and zero or constant phase difference?


Original post
by anonymous56754
It was for both sorry


The 2 questions are not the same but with some overlapping.
Interference and interference pattern are related but the conditions for observable interference pattern are more “restricted” or “stringent”.

Two waves can interfere but the interference of waves does not guarantee an observable interference pattern, so your answer is mainly for 2(b) NOT 2(a).

However, an observable interference pattern guarantees the interference of waves.

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.