The Student Room Group

Economics at a "worse uni" or Accounting and Finance at a "better" uni

Which of these choices should I select, (Manchester/Sheffield/Lancaster BA Economics or Durham/Exeter Acc+Finance) I'm not bothered about the location just purely about job prospects. Will a degree considered slightly worse (Accounting and finance) than economics be viable if its at a university like Durham, need an answer soon as I am looking to send in my UCAS this week.

Reply 1

Which degree are you going to enjoy the most?
It doesnt matter what you think the 'job prospects' are, or how you think you can measure that, if the degree bores you sideways,

Reply 2

Which a levels do you take? That might be significant.

Reply 3

Original post
by ajj2000
Which a levels do you take? That might be significant.

Business, History and Psychology with an A* in EPQ. Currently predicted A*AB

Reply 4

Original post
by Ted Buggle
Business, History and Psychology with an A* in EPQ. Currently predicted A*AB

With that subject combination if you like Manchester as a city I would apply for the BA Econ course. You can chose to go the accounting route within the course, or specialise in economics, or if neither really appeal when you've had a year of experience of studying them you have lots of more social science type options.

Reply 5

Original post
by ajj2000
With that subject combination if you like Manchester as a city I would apply for the BA Econ course. You can chose to go the accounting route within the course, or specialise in economics, or if neither really appeal when you've had a year of experience of studying them you have lots of more social science type options.

I was originally going to apply for economics and that was one of my options but I thought the uni mattered more than the degree to lots of employers and so chose for A+F at Durham/Exeter. Lancaster was also one of my choices previously for BA Economics.

Reply 6

I don't think that university matters more than degree to many employers - although it might for front office investment banking.

Reply 7

Original post
by ajj2000
I don't think that university matters more than degree to many employers - although it might for front office investment banking.

So you think that I should choose economics over accounting and finance, assuming I don't go into IB which I probably won't. My 2 questions are: would A+F at Durham be better than BAEcon at Manchester or are the differences very minimal, and whether Lancaster BAEcon with a placement year is as good of a choice as Manchester. I appreciate the help so far.

Reply 8

Original post
by Ted Buggle
So you think that I should choose economics over accounting and finance, assuming I don't go into IB which I probably won't. My 2 questions are: would A+F at Durham be better than BAEcon at Manchester or are the differences very minimal, and whether Lancaster BAEcon with a placement year is as good of a choice as Manchester. I appreciate the help so far.

My guess is that the courses at Manchester and Durham are perceived the same. Of course if you prefer the environment at Durham, or you think it would be a better fit that should be a really strong factor for you.

The reason I recommend the BA Econ course at Manchester (and its well worth looking through the website) is that you can join the accounting and finance stream in the first year should you wish to and change focus for subsequent years when you've done both economics and accounting courses and learned more about what you enjoy.

The degree is structured as a very flexible social sciences course. Given you A levels that might be a really good fit, and 'de-risk' the choice of degree hugely.

Reply 9

Original post
by ajj2000
My guess is that the courses at Manchester and Durham are perceived the same. Of course if you prefer the environment at Durham, or you think it would be a better fit that should be a really strong factor for you.
The reason I recommend the BA Econ course at Manchester (and its well worth looking through the website) is that you can join the accounting and finance stream in the first year should you wish to and change focus for subsequent years when you've done both economics and accounting courses and learned more about what you enjoy.
The degree is structured as a very flexible social sciences course. Given you A levels that might be a really good fit, and 'de-risk' the choice of degree hugely.

Im not aware on how to check whether you can transfer courses at Lancaster but would Lancaster BAEcon with a placement be worse than the same at Manchester? I'm struggling to choose between A+F or Econ. However Lancaster say that they will ask for a subject specific personal statement if required so I could always put it down among other A+F options.
Original post
by Ted Buggle
Which of these choices should I select, (Manchester/Sheffield/Lancaster BA Economics or Durham/Exeter Acc+Finance) I'm not bothered about the location just purely about job prospects. Will a degree considered slightly worse (Accounting and finance) than economics be viable if its at a university like Durham, need an answer soon as I am looking to send in my UCAS this week.

Hello @Ted Buggle

Glad to hear you are considering Lancaster as one of your uni options. It is important that you look at the bigger picture when selecting a course/uni because, although important, university is much more than graduate prospects but also about the experience you will have and the people you will meet, as well as the things you will learn about yourself and the world around you. In terms of graduate prospects for BA Economics at Lancaster, we are ranked 9th in the country in The Guardian's 2025 league table.

Our degrees are designed to prepare you for a career in industry, business, finance, consultancy or government. Recent Economics graduates have joined banks and financial consultancies such as HSBC and Deloitte, while others have been employed on graduate schemes with major companies, including BAE and the Swire Group.

I think from your options, you have selected a great group of universities and am sure that a job prospect would be viable when you do well in your studies.

I hope this has helped a little bit, if you have any further questions regarding BA Economics at Lancaster, then I would encourage you to make use of our online chat system where you can speak to current students studying your desired course, this is available here.

Please feel free to ask any other questions!

Taylor (Lancaster Uni Student Ambassador)

Reply 11

Original post
by Ted Buggle
Im not aware on how to check whether you can transfer courses at Lancaster but would Lancaster BAEcon with a placement be worse than the same at Manchester? I'm struggling to choose between A+F or Econ. However Lancaster say that they will ask for a subject specific personal statement if required so I could always put it down among other A+F options.

I'm not sure that 'worse' is the right term to use. Courses can be very different without one being superior to the other.

The BA Econ course at Lancaster looks really interesting. It doesn't seem to offer as wide a set of options as the course at Manchester - for example you can't focus on accounting.

Quick Reply