The Student Room Group

tips on choosing oxford college

Hi, year 12 here. I'm applying to Oxford this year (eeeek) and would like some advice on choosing oxford colleges. I know this isn't hugely important as most people don't have a preferred college anyway but I feel like it would be better to do as it might show the uni that you have done some research on colleges and also as of 2023 only 26.7% applicants didn't get into the college of their choice. Deciding what could be your preferred college isn't very time-consuming either so all in all I think it's nice to actually know what you want.

Any response (especially from current oxford students) would be extremely helpful. Thanks in advance.

Reply 1

Original post
by based_J
Hi, year 12 here. I'm applying to Oxford this year (eeeek) and would like some advice on choosing oxford colleges. I know this isn't hugely important as most people don't have a preferred college anyway but I feel like it would be better to do as it might show the uni that you have done some research on colleges and also as of 2023 only 26.7% applicants didn't get into the college of their choice. Deciding what could be your preferred college isn't very time-consuming either so all in all I think it's nice to actually know what you want.
Any response (especially from current oxford students) would be extremely helpful. Thanks in advance.


Admission decisions are made by the colleges and not by the university, after some initial sifting at university level. Those making admission decisions won't judge you on whether or not you have researched the colleges. You won't be asked "why this college?", be expected to know how to recite the college grace, list its famous alumni, or say what colour its oars are.

There are virtual tours of many colleges on their websites and on youtube. Try to visit as many colleges as you can, virtually or in real life, to get a feel for them.

Don't worry about location, as Oxford is small and walkable. Type and quality of accommodation vary widely. A lot of the student rooms in Oxford colleges are quite scruffy and basic. The quality of college food varies widely, but the food is almost always cheap. None of that matters much.

Ultimately, the best college in Oxford is always the college which makes you an offer of a place.

Good luck!

Reply 2

Original post
by based_J
Hi, year 12 here. I'm applying to Oxford this year (eeeek) and would like some advice on choosing oxford colleges. I know this isn't hugely important as most people don't have a preferred college anyway but I feel like it would be better to do as it might show the uni that you have done some research on colleges and also as of 2023 only 26.7% applicants didn't get into the college of their choice. Deciding what could be your preferred college isn't very time-consuming either so all in all I think it's nice to actually know what you want.
Any response (especially from current oxford students) would be extremely helpful. Thanks in advance.

Start here: https://apply.oxfordsu.org/colleges/suggester/

Of course, it would be best if you could attend an open day (the next one should be some time in late June - failing that, there’s always one in mid-September) to get a feeling of what the top 3 colleges as per the suggester’s recommendations are like.

If St John’s happens to be one of the colleges it recommends, I can give you some insight into what life is like there. Also, if you are applying for chemistry, I can also give you further insights into what the course is like (at least in the first and second years).

Reply 3

Original post
by based_J
Hi, year 12 here. I'm applying to Oxford this year (eeeek) and would like some advice on choosing oxford colleges. I know this isn't hugely important as most people don't have a preferred college anyway but I feel like it would be better to do as it might show the uni that you have done some research on colleges and also as of 2023 only 26.7% applicants didn't get into the college of their choice. Deciding what could be your preferred college isn't very time-consuming either so all in all I think it's nice to actually know what you want.
Any response (especially from current oxford students) would be extremely helpful. Thanks in advance.

My usual advice, re: choosing colleges, is to treat any Oxford college as the primary place for eating, sleeping, and socialising. Think about what kinda place you'd like to do those things in. Some questions you might ask yourself:

Do I want a big or small college?

Does it matter to me whether my college is old and more 'traditionally Oxford', or do I want a newer/younger Oxford college?

What are the nearest/furthest colleges from my department? This is a question for those who have access/mobility needs, but also those (like me) who are lazy and don't want to walk around that much. (I can't ride a bike, so that was never an option for me, but if you can ride/already have a bike, then distance is less of a consideration)

Do I want an ensuite?

Do I need a kitchen/self-catering options?

Do I want my college to have grass I can walk on? Gym/sports pitches on-site within the college?

Do I want to be accommodated for the duration of my course, or am I OK with 'living out' for a bit?


Your answers, plus course choice, will naturally start to narrow down the list for you :yes:

Reply 4

OP, my daughter looked at Lincoln, Christ Church, and St Peter's. She applied to and was accepted by St Peter's. She liked its small size and friendly vibe. She starts her second term there next week. She is loving her college, and Oxford in general.

St Peter's does not have glorious architecture, but it's a pleasant space, very centrally located. Its current Master Professor Judith Buchanan is warm and energetic, and the college appears to be well run. It has what is generally acclaimed to be the best college bar in Oxford. The food is OK, with formal Hall twice a week, which is always popular and full.

My daughter has been allocated a room in college for the second year so will live in college for all three years of her degree. About half of the second years live out.

My nephew recently graduated from Exeter College, where he had a good time. Exeter is a pretty college, in one of the best locations in Oxford. Its garden offers a marvellous view of the Old Bodleian, the Radcliffe Camera, All Souls College and the University Church of St Mary.

A friend from work is currently the President of Magdalen, where she was an undergraduate a while back, and she naturally enthuses about her college, which is indeed a magnificent college, with great facilities. Another college to look at might be Trinity, which has recently spent a lot on some refurbishment works. If you like modern architecture, St Catz is great. It's Arne Jacobsen's masterpiece. My friends from Somerville and New College sing their praises.

I studied at Wadham many years ago and had a great time. It's a beautiful college and I shall always Iove it, but I don't currently recommend Wadham to any student. This is because of the ideological capture of a significant component of its student body by belief systems which I regard as inimical to the idea of what a university should be. I dined in Hall with the Warden and Fellows of Wadham early last year. Only one of the student tables in the (large) Hall was occupied during dinner (it was early in the term and no exams were in progress or in prospect). That does not give a good impression of the state of the college.

As an undergraduate I hung out a lot with friends at Queen's and Balliol, both fun at that time. That was long ago, but I have no reason to suppose that they are not still fun.

Reply 5

If it’s possible for you to make it to an open day, you can look round lots of colleges and talk to current students. All the students will say their college is the best, of course, but it can be interesting to see what it is they say they like about it.

The list of practical questions given above is really good. There is also nothing wrong with choosing on the basis of gut feeling. If you go somewhere and it just sticks in your mind, go for it.

Don’t stress about it too much. You may as well make a choice since you are allowed to, but if you were to end up at a different college you’d end up loving it.

Also just to say that you will definitely not be asked about college choice at an interview so you don’t need to choose to show you have researched it or anything. People choose a college for the most random of reasons and that’s okay.

Reply 6

Original post
by TypicalNerd
Start here: https://apply.oxfordsu.org/colleges/suggester/
Of course, it would be best if you could attend an open day (the next one should be some time in late June - failing that, there’s always one in mid-September) to get a feeling of what the top 3 colleges as per the suggester’s recommendations are like.
If St John’s happens to be one of the colleges it recommends, I can give you some insight into what life is like there. Also, if you are applying for chemistry, I can also give you further insights into what the course is like (at least in the first and second years).


Thank you! I actually don’t live in the UK so it’d be a bit hard for me to attend a live open day. If you could recommend some online conferences or events that’d be super helpful. For instance, I know Oxford hosts zoom meetings via their official website every now and then so I do attend those. I have heard of this college suggester - will try it out soon and let you know my results. Thanks again. Btw, are you currently studying at Oxford, or have you already graduated?

Reply 7

Original post
by Stiffy Byng
OP, my daughter looked at Lincoln, Christ Church, and St Peter's. She applied to and was accepted by St Peter's because she liked its small size and friendly vibe. She starts her second term there next week. She is loving her college, and Oxford in general.
St Peter's does not have glorious architecture, but it's a pleasant space, very centrally located. Its current Master Professor Judith Buchanan is warm and energetic, and the college appears to be well run. It has what is generally acclaimed to be the best college bar in Oxford. The food is OK, with formal Hall twice a week, which is always popular and full.
My daughter has been allocated a room in college for the second year so will live in college for all three years of her degree. About half of the second years live out.
My nephew recently graduated from Exeter College, where he had a good time. Exeter is a pretty college, in one of the best locations in Oxford. Its garden offers a marvellous view of the Old Bodleian, the Radcliffe Camera, All Souls College and the University Church of St Mary.
A friend from work is currently the President of Magdalen, where she was an undergraduate a while back, and she naturally enthuses about her college, which is indeed a magnificent college, with great facilities. Another college to look at might be Trinity, which has recently spent a lot on some refurbishment works. If you like modern architecture, St Catz is great. It's Arne Jacobsen's masterpiece. My friends from Somerville and New College sing the their praises.
I studied at Wadham many years ago and had a great time. It's a beautiful college and I shall always Iove it, but I don't currently recommend Wadham to any student. This is because of the ideological capture of a significant component of its student body by belief systems which I regard as inimical to the idea of what a university should be. I dined in Hall with the Warden and Fellows of Wadham early last year. Only one of the student tables in the (large) Hall was occupied during dinner (it was early in the term and no exams were in progress or in prospect). That does not give a good impression of the state of the college.
As an undergraduate I hung out a lot with friends Queen's and Balliol, both fun at that time. That was long ago, but I have no reason to suppose that they are not still fun.


Thank you so much for taking the time to write such a long message :smile: and congrats to your daughter and nephew! Do you mind if I dm you to ask a few more questions about Oxford?

Reply 8

I just wanna say a huge thank you for the current responses so far - I honestly did not expect this many and am very grateful for everyone’s help and enthusiasm :smile:

Reply 9

Original post
by based_J
Thank you! I actually don’t live in the UK so it’d be a bit hard for me to attend a live open day. If you could recommend some online conferences or events that’d be super helpful. For instance, I know Oxford hosts zoom meetings via their official website every now and then so I do attend those. I have heard of this college suggester - will try it out soon and let you know my results. Thanks again. Btw, are you currently studying at Oxford, or have you already graduated?

That’s fair. I’ll look into online alternatives and get back to you when I find something.

I’m a current student in my second year.

Reply 10

Original post
by based_J
Thank you so much for taking the time to write such a long message :smile: and congrats to your daughter and nephew! Do you mind if I dm you to ask a few more questions about Oxford?

NP, please do.

Reply 11

Original post
by TypicalNerd
That’s fair. I’ll look into online alternatives and get back to you when I find something.
I’m a current student in my second year.


Much appreciated. Good luck with your studies :smile: do you mind if I dm you to ask a few questions about Oxford?

Reply 12

Original post
by based_J
Much appreciated. Good luck with your studies :smile: do you mind if I dm you to ask a few questions about Oxford?

By all means - ask away

Reply 13

Original post
by Stiffy Byng
OP, my daughter looked at Lincoln, Christ Church, and St Peter's. She applied to and was accepted by St Peter's. She liked its small size and friendly vibe. She starts her second term there next week. She is loving her college, and Oxford in general.
St Peter's does not have glorious architecture, but it's a pleasant space, very centrally located. Its current Master Professor Judith Buchanan is warm and energetic, and the college appears to be well run. It has what is generally acclaimed to be the best college bar in Oxford. The food is OK, with formal Hall twice a week, which is always popular and full.
My daughter has been allocated a room in college for the second year so will live in college for all three years of her degree. About half of the second years live out.
My nephew recently graduated from Exeter College, where he had a good time. Exeter is a pretty college, in one of the best locations in Oxford. Its garden offers a marvellous view of the Old Bodleian, the Radcliffe Camera, All Souls College and the University Church of St Mary.
A friend from work is currently the President of Magdalen, where she was an undergraduate a while back, and she naturally enthuses about her college, which is indeed a magnificent college, with great facilities. Another college to look at might be Trinity, which has recently spent a lot on some refurbishment works. If you like modern architecture, St Catz is great. It's Arne Jacobsen's masterpiece. My friends from Somerville and New College sing their praises.
I studied at Wadham many years ago and had a great time. It's a beautiful college and I shall always Iove it, but I don't currently recommend Wadham to any student. This is because of the ideological capture of a significant component of its student body by belief systems which I regard as inimical to the idea of what a university should be. I dined in Hall with the Warden and Fellows of Wadham early last year. Only one of the student tables in the (large) Hall was occupied during dinner (it was early in the term and no exams were in progress or in prospect). That does not give a good impression of the state of the college.
As an undergraduate I hung out a lot with friends at Queen's and Balliol, both fun at that time. That was long ago, but I have no reason to suppose that they are not still fun.

OP, Stiffy is an excellent source of Oxford info so you should get some useful advice. Just for balance, my daughter is a current student at Wadham and having a great time. She finds it a lively, diverse and friendly place, if somewhat disorganised when it comes to admin communications (but that seems to be fairly common!).

Reply 14

Thanks for your kind words. I am glad that your daughter is enjoying Wadham. It is of course the very best college in the very best university in the whole wide World, in Space.

I just think that too many Wadham students and junior Dons are wrapped up in a political conversation with themselves, and have forgotten what Wadham and Oxford are for.

It saddens me to see the college which pretty much invented science in the C17 tangled up in C21 anti-scientific mumbo jumbo.

I think that the current Warden is not the man to stand up to the SU leadership and the junior Fellows. Like most colleges, we tend to get one strong Head of House followed by one weak one. This is probably because the Fellows get fed up being made to run about when the Warden is dynamic, so they elect a quiet one next time. Then the college drifts, so ten years later the Fellows elect someone dynamic again.
(edited 11 months ago)

Reply 15

Original post
by based_J
Hi, year 12 here. I'm applying to Oxford this year (eeeek) and would like some advice on choosing oxford colleges. I know this isn't hugely important as most people don't have a preferred college anyway but I feel like it would be better to do as it might show the uni that you have done some research on colleges and also as of 2023 only 26.7% applicants didn't get into the college of their choice. Deciding what could be your preferred college isn't very time-consuming either so all in all I think it's nice to actually know what you want.
Any response (especially from current oxford students) would be extremely helpful. Thanks in advance.


i applied for oxford 2025 entry (patiently waiting to hear back!) and my advice would be to attend an open day and have a look around. also have a look at how many students the college takes for your subject, as well as how big or small the college is. that being said college choice isn’t that important in the application - lots of people (including myself) get pooled and moved around to other colleges for interviews or offers. just go have a visit and go with your gut!

also here is the oxford college suggester, on the alternative prospectus, it’s very helpful!

https://apply.oxfordsu.org/colleges/suggester/

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.