The Student Room Group

is it unreasonable to ask for a break when you live together?

he's so angry about it and doesn’t want to hear it. he says that if that’s what i want, i should just move out, even though he knows that's not an option right now

Scroll to see replies

It does sound a bit unrealistic tbh esp if relying on him paying for the place and to a lot of people there's no difference between a break and a break up. Either 1 person would normally leave, esp if no children involved or it's an extremely amicable breakup..
Reply 2
Original post by StriderHort
It does sound a bit unrealistic tbh esp if relying on him paying for the place and to a lot of people there's no difference between a break and a break up. Either 1 person would normally leave, esp if no children involved or it's an extremely amicable breakup..

i don't want to break up, though. i just need like a mental break from everything. is it really that much to ask?
Well, if you live together I'm not sure that you'd actually be having much of a break.

Instead of phrasing it as "I want a break", why not book yourself a solo trip away for a couple of weeks?
Original post by Ciel.
i don't want to break up, though. i just need like a mental break from everything. is it really that much to ask?

That's what I'm saying though, a lot of people don't see much of a difference about whether it's temporary or not. And kinda yes, a lot of people would consider their partner wanting to withdraw emotionally from their relationship and their own needs while staying there as a lot to ask.
Reply 5
Original post by PinkMobilePhone
Well, if you live together I'm not sure that you'd actually be having much of a break.
Instead of phrasing it as "I want a break", why not book yourself a solo trip away for a couple of weeks?

he works a lot during the weekday so only really see him in the evenings anyway. but the plan was to - sleep in a different bedroom, stay out of each other's way, no sex etc.
he won't let me go on a solo trip, lol.
Reply 6
Original post by StriderHort
That's what I'm saying though, a lot of people don't see much of a difference about whether it's temporary or not. And kinda yes, a lot of people would consider their partner wanting to withdraw emotionally from their relationship and their own needs while staying there as a lot to ask.

maybe i'm just not cut out for this tbh : /
Original post by Ciel.
he works a lot during the weekday so only really see him in the evenings anyway. but the plan was to - sleep in a different bedroom, stay out of each other's way, no sex etc.
he won't let me go on a solo trip, lol.

Well, he doesn't really get to dictate to you whether or not you can go on a trip. He can grumble about it, but ultimately if you book a trip and go on it he can't stop you.

I understand that you don't want to cause an argument with him, but it sounds like asking for a break is already resulting in one. I reckon being literally away from the house for a couple of weeks so you're not walking on egg shells every evening when he comes home from work is probably going to be better for your mental health if you need some space.
It would mean your partner isn't seeing it as you being on a break from him, but rather you're just on a mental health recharge trip.
Reply 8
Original post by PinkMobilePhone
Well, he doesn't really get to dictate to you whether or not you can go on a trip. He can grumble about it, but ultimately if you book a trip and go on it he can't stop you.
I understand that you don't want to cause an argument with him, but it sounds like asking for a break is already resulting in one. I reckon being literally away from the house for a couple of weeks so you're not walking on egg shells every evening when he comes home from work is probably going to be better for your mental health if you need some space.
It would mean your partner isn't seeing it as you being on a break from him, but rather you're just on a mental health recharge trip.

i'm pretty sure he would. 'for my own good' of course.
i need to find a way to mentally 'reset' at home.
Original post by Ciel.
i'm pretty sure he would. 'for my own good' of course.
i need to find a way to mentally 'reset' at home.


Is it depression you're struggling with primarily?
Reply 10
Original post by PinkMobilePhone
Is it depression you're struggling with primarily?

i get pretty crazy mood swings tbh. most of the time it's depression, but not right now. i don't even know what my mood is right now. i just feel all over the place. i don't know what i want anymore - i just know that my life isn't what i want it to be right now. i keep making bad life choices : /
Original post by Ciel.
i get pretty crazy mood swings tbh. most of the time it's depression, but not right now. i don't even know what my mood is right now. i just feel all over the place. i don't know what i want anymore - i just know that my life isn't what i want it to be right now. i keep making bad life choices : /


I was going to say I've been looking at this thing for my daughter (who suffers from depression) but I haven't quite decided whether or not to get her one yet.
I wondered if it might be of any interest to you:
https://www.flowneuroscience.com/
Reply 12
Typically proposing ‘a break’ is a way of softening the end of a committed relationship that has run its course. It might be fairer to say you want move on and, if you can, bank some of the good times
Reply 13
I don't think you could/should call it a break, but you could discuss setting some boundaries or limitations on your interactions for a few weeks. Although with that will require communication.
Reply 14
Original post by PinkMobilePhone
I was going to say I've been looking at this thing for my daughter (who suffers from depression) but I haven't quite decided whether or not to get her one yet.
I wondered if it might be of any interest to you:
https://www.flowneuroscience.com/

it's giving electric shock therapy vibes : ( their claims seem a bit pseudoscientific but idk.
has she ever tried antidepressants?
Reply 15
Original post by Zarek
Typically proposing ‘a break’ is a way of softening the end of a committed relationship that has run its course. It might be fairer to say you want move on and, if you can, bank some of the good times

i don't think i want to end it, just need some space. LOTS of it.
Reply 16
Original post by Foxehh
I don't think you could/should call it a break, but you could discuss setting some boundaries or limitations on your interactions for a few weeks. Although with that will require communication.

whenever i suggest something like that he takes it so personally : /
Reply 17
Original post by Anonymous
I can’t see how you can have a break from each other living in the same home, I think it would be stressful for both of you. Perhaps one of you could go away for a week or two might be the simplest solution.
Have you contacted your GP?

it's not really an option so unless he reconsiders, i'll probably just stay out of his way for a bit until i feel normal again, lol
it's just annoying that he's making such a big deal out of this
my gp? what for?
(edited 1 month ago)
Original post by Ciel.
it's giving electric shock therapy vibes : ( their claims seem a bit pseudoscientific but idk.
has she ever tried antidepressants?

The GP won't give her them. She's had therapy but it didn't last long and didn't particularly help.
Reply 19
Original post by PinkMobilePhone
The GP won't give her them. She's had therapy but it didn't last long and didn't particularly help.

i assume she's under 18? some private doctors will still prescribe them. but tbh, they are so hit and miss. i've been on so many different ones, usually they just numb you. at this point, i'm kinda over the whole thing. i'm starting to feel like everything they say about depression is bs, and it's usually just due to past trauma and/or general dissatisfaction with life

Quick Reply