The Student Room Group

Which essay type should I choose: narrative or descriptive?

For igcse English Lang CAIE, I want to choose descriptive lang essay but my teacher said that it is more difficult then narrative essay?
Advice???!

Reply 1

I always found descriptive easier for gcse because thinking of a cohesive story is more difficult and takes more time for me. I also always found it easier to incorporate lots of language techniques in descriptive because i didnt need to worry about a narrative and could focus on the writing style more. Although i did always make sure to include a bit of a "narrative" i guess to provide some structure - like if the prompt was a sunset the "narrative" would be the sun setting and the changes that came with the night. But i know lots of people who found narrative easier cause it was easier to structure without getting sidetracked. My advice would be to pick one now and stick to it because trying to practice both, or randomly doing descriptive in the exam if you've only done narrative is a lot harder. I'm not sure if the igcse is any different than gcse though. I hope this helps!!

Reply 2

Original post
by Abithegoat
For igcse English Lang CAIE, I want to choose descriptive lang essay but my teacher said that it is more difficult then narrative essay?
Advice???!

It depends on your writing style and preferences. I did IGCSE CAIE in 2023 and would recommend personally doing descriptive for essays because you have a higher chance of getting into the higher bands for AO2 if you use stronger sensory language and figurative language which descriptive writing is substantially better than narrative for. I also found descriptive easier as it prevented me from getting a weaker plot line which would result in a lower grade, as the narrative often would result in students rushing their ending or the introduction being too long. It does depend on whether you prefer to focus on particular scenes and features like the atmosphere or vivid descriptions, or if you prefer a more structured framework, and creating your own characters. I do agree with the other comment saying you should incorporate some narrative to form a structure but just make sure the main focus is on descriptive.

Reply 3

Original post
by Abithegoat
For igcse English Lang CAIE, I want to choose descriptive lang essay but my teacher said that it is more difficult then narrative essay?
Advice???!
I would recommend narrative writing as you are free to describe as well as telling your story, whereas in descriptive essays,it is quite limited as you cannot narrate, but only describe. So,if you choose narrative writing, you are still allowed to describe in your story! Choose whatever you feel is best for you

Reply 4

Original post
by h4lfbloodweirdo
I would recommend narrative writing as you are free to describe as well as telling your story, whereas in descriptive essays,it is quite limited as you cannot narrate, but only describe. So,if you choose narrative writing, you are still allowed to describe in your story! Choose whatever you feel is best for you

thank you

Reply 5

Original post
by WOJ568
It depends on your writing style and preferences. I did IGCSE CAIE in 2023 and would recommend personally doing descriptive for essays because you have a higher chance of getting into the higher bands for AO2 if you use stronger sensory language and figurative language which descriptive writing is substantially better than narrative for. I also found descriptive easier as it prevented me from getting a weaker plot line which would result in a lower grade, as the narrative often would result in students rushing their ending or the introduction being too long. It does depend on whether you prefer to focus on particular scenes and features like the atmosphere or vivid descriptions, or if you prefer a more structured framework, and creating your own characters. I do agree with the other comment saying you should incorporate some narrative to form a structure but just make sure the main focus is on descriptive.

thank you!

Reply 6

Hey all!!! Just wanted to let yall know I chose descriptive writing and got an A*!

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.