The TSR Community Awards 2025 are now live >>

Pearson Ed Excel Alevel (Statistics or Mechanics?) Which to pick?

Hi. For some context, my school has everyone do statistics 1 but I’ve come to dislike statistics as I don’t fully understand the concepts behind it. The school offers statistics 2 as the next book to study and only offers mechanics 1 to physics students.

Here comes the dilemma… I’ve never done physics (only basic physics) but I have done additional math and math before my alevels. I’m willing to put in more effort to study should I choose mechanics 1 but which is more suitable for me? Is statistics 2 easier than mechanics 1? I’ve had quite a few people tell me not to do it… but mechanics 1 does look interesting. With sufficient practice will I be able to excel in M1?

I would appreciate all the advice, please. Thank you.

Reply 1

robust-thornbush

Assuming this is for Further Maths, what did you think about Mechanics questions in the regular A level? It's all in that same style, long multi-part questions that you could easily get lost in - you have to know your stuff thoroughly. It looks like substantially less work than the statistics - I don't do Statistics so I don't know about the difficulty side of things, but that book is twice as long as the Mechanics book.

Switching would of course be a risk, and would give you less support, so I'd only do it if you were confident in your ability to teach yourself. Also, your teachers might just tell you no.

You mention that you don't understand statistics, but if you're getting good marks in it still then there's no reason to switch. The mechanics won't teach you all that much comparatively, you only learn about three different things.

With practice you would of course be able to excel in Mechanics, as in all subjects.

To summarise, Mechanics seems a shorter topic to learn, but potentially less varied, and you might receive less support. I see no reason to switch unless you are awful at, or absolutely hate, Statistics, but there's nothing from preventing you from doing so, assuming you are a competent mathematician.

Sincerely, a mechanics person