nottingham or sheffield for philosophy

i received all my offers a while ago and have narrowed it down to nottingham or sheffield with york as insurance
they have the same requirements (AAB) and i love both courses and im pretty sure their reputations fairly similar
sheffield has a few more unique modules than notts and i have no doubts that i'll be able to have a good social life and feel comfortable in sheffield. its known for its openness and the city loves the arts and overall it seems more like me.
but sheffield is a city campus and i prefer campus based unis - sheffield's seems fairly small but i'm not sure if i'm right in thinking that??
i love nottingham's campus and its sports facilities seem better, but the student body mostly don't seem like my kind of people? i'm sure i'd be able to find people more like me through societies and lectures and such but is it worth the risk?
also i want to go for self-catered accommodation while nottingham university park campus is really catered-accommodation centred
overall i think i'm leaning towards sheffield but i want to make sure i'm making the right decision there (my dad's fairly convinced that nottingham would be better because of its reputation but i can convince him towards sheffield)
anyway i'm asking for any advice or info on either uni? 😔❤️
sorry this was long
thanks