The Student Room Group

AITA for cheating on my husband of 5 years

I know it sounds bad but let me explain. My husband Richard (M50) and me (F30) were forced into marriage by family. None of us have an emotional or sexual connection with each other but we managed to have a little girl we will call Kinsey. Kinsey is two years old and I love her so much but I don’t wanna be married to her dad anymore. Richard was also flirting with others especially other men and he also made mean comments on my appearance and cooking. I’m scared our splitting up would hurt our little girl her third birthday is in 2 weeks what do I do.

Scroll to see replies

Ma’am, this is a student forum.

Reply 2

I'm sorry that you were forced into a marriage neither of you wanted; nonetheless, I trust you can take "Kinsey" as something good that has come from all this.

From the sounds of this, it sounds like it's just a loveless marriage; by this I mean that it's not an abusive marriage per se (feel free to correct me if I'm wrong). If that's the case, then I wouldn't do anything until after Kinsey's birthday. After this, you may have two choices:-

a) Make a clean break, and start proceedings for a divorce or annulment (if the marriage was forced, I think that would qualify for an annulment, although you won't have the same legal rights as a full-on divorce). I don't know the circumstances, but this may be better for your child in the long run. Children can pick up on negative vibes between the parents, and this may be more detrimental than seeing one parent during the week and the other on weekends. I don't know how your respective families would feel about this and / or what action they would take, so you'd have to factor all that in.

b) Keep up a façade, and stay married as far as everyone else is concerned. I know you mentioned "Richard" flirts with other and makes some unpleasant comments to you... but what is the relationship like between the two of you? I mean, would you consider yourselves as like "mates", where you can have banter and it's all good, and you're comfortable with each other? When I was at Uni, I knew a Muslim "couple" where he was gay and she was a lesbian. They were very close friends, so they kinda entered into a marriage of convenience. To each others families, they were happily married, but in private, they would both do their own things. They both agreed this was a better option than coming out to their families and risking the potential fallouts. As far as I'm aware, they're still together, although I don't think there are /were any children involved. However, if I'm wrong, and you're genuinely uncomfortable around him (for whatever reason), then this clearly isn't an option

Reply 3

Original post
by Old Skool Freak
I'm sorry that you were forced into a marriage neither of you wanted; nonetheless, I trust you can take "Kinsey" as something good that has come from all this.
From the sounds of this, it sounds like it's just a loveless marriage; by this I mean that it's not an abusive marriage per se (feel free to correct me if I'm wrong). If that's the case, then I wouldn't do anything until after Kinsey's birthday. After this, you may have two choices:-
a) Make a clean break, and start proceedings for a divorce or annulment (if the marriage was forced, I think that would qualify for an annulment, although you won't have the same legal rights as a full-on divorce). I don't know the circumstances, but this may be better for your child in the long run. Children can pick up on negative vibes between the parents, and this may be more detrimental than seeing one parent during the week and the other on weekends. I don't know how your respective families would feel about this and / or what action they would take, so you'd have to factor all that in.
b) Keep up a façade, and stay married as far as everyone else is concerned. I know you mentioned "Richard" flirts with other and makes some unpleasant comments to you... but what is the relationship like between the two of you? I mean, would you consider yourselves as like "mates", where you can have banter and it's all good, and you're comfortable with each other? When I was at Uni, I knew a Muslim "couple" where he was gay and she was a lesbian. They were very close friends, so they kinda entered into a marriage of convenience. To each others families, they were happily married, but in private, they would both do their own things. They both agreed this was a better option than coming out to their families and risking the potential fallouts. As far as I'm aware, they're still together, although I don't think there are /were any children involved. However, if I'm wrong, and you're genuinely uncomfortable around him (for whatever reason), then this clearly isn't an option

Thank you for the advice I think I’m going to divorce Richard a couple weeks after Kinseys birthday as for the comments he’s made it genuinely hurt me but he’s a really good father I think we might work out a custody situation

Reply 4

Original post
by Anonymous
Thank you for the advice I think I’m going to divorce Richard a couple weeks after Kinseys birthday as for the comments he’s made it genuinely hurt me but he’s a really good father I think we might work out a custody situation

Sounds like that it would be best for all if you were separated. Better for your daughter to see you guys when you can at least be civil to each other, rather than her picking up on bad-vibes... and who knows how that might affect her.

Best of luck :smile:

Reply 5

Original post
by Old Skool Freak
Sounds like that it would be best for all if you were separated. Better for your daughter to see you guys when you can at least be civil to each other, rather than her picking up on bad-vibes... and who knows how that might affect her.
Best of luck :smile:

I talked to Richard about it and he flipped out and said if we divorce he’s taking Kinsey I’m genuinely lost and don’t know what to do!

Reply 6

Original post
by Anonymous
I know it sounds bad but let me explain. My husband Richard (M50) and me (F30) were forced into marriage by family. None of us have an emotional or sexual connection with each other but we managed to have a little girl we will call Kinsey. Kinsey is two years old and I love her so much but I don’t wanna be married to her dad anymore. Richard was also flirting with others especially other men and he also made mean comments on my appearance and cooking. I’m scared our splitting up would hurt our little girl her third birthday is in 2 weeks what do I do.

when I was a kid, i prayed that my parents would divorce instead of fighting day in and day out.
Original post
by Admit-One
Ma’am, this is a student forum.

thought i stumbled onto reddit..
(edited 8 months ago)

Reply 8

Original post
by Anonymous
I know it sounds bad but let me explain. My husband Richard (M50) and me (F30) were forced into marriage by family. None of us have an emotional or sexual connection with each other but we managed to have a little girl we will call Kinsey. Kinsey is two years old and I love her so much but I don’t wanna be married to her dad anymore. Richard was also flirting with others especially other men and he also made mean comments on my appearance and cooking. I’m scared our splitting up would hurt our little girl her third birthday is in 2 weeks what do I do.

If neither of you are happy in the marriage, staying together just for Kinsey might not be the best long-term solution. Kids pick up on tension. If Richard is also being unkind to you, that’s not okay. Maybe focus on co-parenting in a way that keeps her life stable rather than staying in a relationship that makes you miserable. Hope you find a way forward that brings you peace.

Reply 9

Original post
by Anonymous
I talked to Richard about it and he flipped out and said if we divorce he’s taking Kinsey I’m genuinely lost and don’t know what to do!

I don't want to come across as harsh, but I don't think this post is genuine at all. Not least because you've gone from not knowing what to do, to deciding to divorce your husband, to then speaking to your husband about it all in the space of 12 hours. That is not how things go in the real world. This just reads like someone imitating a Reddit thread.

However, in case there are people who genuinely need this advice in future, I most certainly agree that it is generally better for children to separate than to stay in an unhappy marriage. It is not unusual for there to be disagreements as to who the child lives with and spends time with, but the family court is there to resolve those disputes. As much as there will always be a status quo as to where the child lives following a separation, you would generally expect the child to stay in the family home while the issues around the divorce are finalised. Even if your other half does 'take' her, if you apply to the family court for a child arrangements order, a judge will consider relatively quickly what the interim arrangements should be whilst the case proceeds. I appreciate that litigation is never something that people want to do in this sort of situation, but that is why the family court is there. Him threatening to take her is not a reason to not get the divorce that clearly needs to happen here.

Reply 10

Original post
by Crazy Jamie
I don't want to come across as harsh, but I don't think this post is genuine at all. Not least because you've gone from not knowing what to do, to deciding to divorce your husband, to then speaking to your husband about it all in the space of 12 hours. That is not how things go in the real world. This just reads like someone imitating a Reddit thread.
However, in case there are people who genuinely need this advice in future, I most certainly agree that it is generally better for children to separate than to stay in an unhappy marriage. It is not unusual for there to be disagreements as to who the child lives with and spends time with, but the family court is there to resolve those disputes. As much as there will always be a status quo as to where the child lives following a separation, you would generally expect the child to stay in the family home while the issues around the divorce are finalised. Even if your other half does 'take' her, if you apply to the family court for a child arrangements order, a judge will consider relatively quickly what the interim arrangements should be whilst the case proceeds. I appreciate that litigation is never something that people want to do in this sort of situation, but that is why the family court is there. Him threatening to take her is not a reason to not get the divorce that clearly needs to happen here.

And why name their daughter after a famous sexologist???

Reply 11

Original post
by ageshallnot
And why name their daughter after a famous sexologist???

I think it's a name for the sake of the thread, but it is equally something of a tell tale sign that someone reaching for an anonymous name for a child would go there.

Reply 12

Original post
by Crazy Jamie
I think it's a name for the sake of the thread, but it is equally something of a tell tale sign that someone reaching for an anonymous name for a child would go there.

I didn’t even know Kinsey was a sexologists name and yes it’s for the sake of the thread I don’t wanna put my child’s real name out there. And also this is actually happening I act on impulse and the first thing that comes to mind I just do it probably not the best but I’m working on it a bit.

Reply 13

Original post
by Anonymous
I didn’t even know Kinsey was a sexologists name and yes it’s for the sake of the thread I don’t wanna put my child’s real name out there. And also this is actually happening I act on impulse and the first thing that comes to mind I just do it probably not the best but I’m working on it a bit.

The name must have been in your mind somewhere when you wrote your first post.

Reply 14

Original post
by ageshallnot
The name must have been in your mind somewhere when you wrote your first post.

My co worker is having a baby shower soon and she was thinking about naming her baby Kinsey and it’s a pretty common name

Reply 15

update

Reply 16

Original post
by Anonymous
update

My husband lashed out and fought with me for custody but I won he currently has no visitation rights

Reply 17

Original post
by Anonymous
My husband lashed out and fought with me for custody but I won he currently has no visitation rights

You had a full custody battle in less than four weeks? Now we really are in the realms of fantasy.
Original post
by Crazy Jamie
You had a full custody battle in less than four weeks? Now we really are in the realms of fantasy.

I was going to say I’d be amazed if you could get a hearing date within a month.

Reply 19

Original post
by Admit-One
I was going to say I’d be amazed if you could get a hearing date within a month.

It'd be a good result to get a FHDRA (First Hearing Dispute Resolution Appointment; basically the first hearing after you make an application for a Child Arrangement Order) within 4-6 weeks. A CAFCASS section 7 report (which you'd need in a case like this) would probably take 12-16 weeks at least, though it's taking longer in most areas now, and that only takes you to a Dispute Resolution Appointment. The timeline to a contested final hearing would be at least 8 months from issue, and even then if you did well and happened to issue in a County Court with good availability.

I would honestly doubt this if the OP had said that she'd issued an application for a CAO and everything had been listed and resolved within 4 weeks, because even that is just too fast. But it would only be even remotely possible if everything was resolved amicably by agreement. But where the husband 'lashed out', 'fought for custody' and the OP 'won'? You'd do extremely well to get to that point by the end of this year. Within four weeks is a nonsense.

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.