The Student Room Group

St Andrews vs Queen Belfast

HI

While considering medicine offers for Sep 2025 intake, I am a bit confused between St Andrews and Belfast. Keeping duration of program aside (St. Andrews 6 years and Belfast 5 years), can someone pls help me on the pros and cons /comparative view on which program is better.

Thanks
(edited 1 month ago)

Reply 1

No idea about course, but you’re comparing two very different places. My daughter has experience of both.

Reply 2

Hello there,

Congratulations on your offers.

Both medical school will make you a fantastic doctor. In terms of what you want from a program, that is pretty subjective. But I don't think anyone could tell you specifically "what is the best course." The priority should be you enjoying your medical degree, and that'll be a combination of the location, the course and the people on it.

St Andrews

Beautiful place - coastal sea side, excellent beaches

It can feel a bit like a bubble - which can feel quite intense

Course has less early clinical exposure than QUB. My impression is it has more a pre-clinical vibe to it, before going to a more clinical school for 4'th year onwards

You will get a intercalated degree - this will be an extra year, and actually postgraduate training (i.e. applying for what type of doctor you want to be) currently doesn't give you any benefit from having an intercalated degree. Obviously, if research is something you would like to consider, intercalation is useful. And, this may all change by the time you are applying!

St Andrews restricted by limiting teaching hospitals. There is Kirkcaldy (Royal Victoria Hospital Kirkcaldy - which is not a tertiary referral centre), and a community hospital. As wells as lots of GP practices

You will transfer for your 4'th year to another medical school

St Andrews is super expensive - and renting is a challenge. A lot of students are now living in Dundee and commute into St Andrews

There's a lot of beautiful bonnie Scotland to explore ( and it's great!)

QUB

Early clinical exposure

Large teaching hospitals - tertiary referral centres

Very cheap city - but does have its issues (and is improving!!)

Northern Ireland is easier to explore with a car

Much larger year group than St Andrews ( pros and cons to that - and can limit some clinical placements)

5 year course - optional intercalation which could bring it up to 6 years

The Northern Irish health care system is really not in a good place, comparatively to Scotland (which also does have similar issues, but not nearly as bad)

Northern Ireland is a lovely country, with lots to explore!

In summary, either will be great. Best maybe to consider which country you would like to be in the most!


Bit about me: I am a current resident doctor in Edinburgh, and work with a number of now qualified St Andrews students (they all seem awesome). We also frequently have students transfer to Edinburgh from St Andrews. I have worked with people from QUB too (equally awesome). I also lived in St Andrews for a bit! And... I am also from Northern Ireland.
(edited 1 month ago)

Reply 3

Original post by anilgarg
HI
While considering medicine offers for Sep 2025 intake, I am a bit confused between St Andrews and Belfast. Keeping duration of program aside (St. Andrews 6 years and Belfast 5 years), can someone pls help me on the pros and cons /comparative view on which program is better.
Thanks
hi how long after your interview did you hear back?

Quick Reply