The Student Room Group

Forum games not counting towards unanswered threads?

Problem Summary
Forum games not counting towards unanswered threads?

Problem Details
It looks like when I answer an unanswered thread in forum games, it doesn’t count towards the stat.

It’ll say 968 before I answer then still remain on 968 after I answer the thread, this doesn’t happen in other contexts including private forums I think.


Device
Mobile

Browser
Safari

Link
https://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/showthread.php?t=7583504

Additional Information
The chat forum in general works just fine.

Reply 1

Original post
by Talkative Toad
Problem Summary
Forum games not counting towards unanswered threads?
Problem Details
It looks like when I answer an unanswered thread in forum games, it doesn’t count towards the stat.
It’ll say 968 before I answer then still remain on 968 after I answer the thread, this doesn’t happen in other contexts including private forums I think.

Device
Mobile
Browser
Safari
Link
https://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/showthread.php?t=7583504
Additional Information
The chat forum in general works just fine.

Hi. I think we looked at this before and there are some forums that don't count toward the badge. I'll ask someone to double check though. I'm not sure why specific forums would be excluded from badges. Thanks for letting us know 🙂

Reply 2

Original post
by PurpleAndGreen
Hi. I think we looked at this before and there are some forums that don't count toward the badge. I'll ask someone to double check though. I'm not sure why specific forums would be excluded from badges. Thanks for letting us know 🙂


The rest of the chat forum works fine, it’s specifically forum games for some reason where it doesn’t count so I’m wondering if that’s something that’s gone unnoticed rather than intentional design.

I can understand why specific forums are excluded but it does make the naming of the badge misleading if that’s the case (for the chatterbox badge, you’d think that the chat forum of all forums should count towards the badge, an unanswered thread is an unanswered thread regardless of the forum etc).

Yeah some badges like the chatterbox badge and home bird badge I would have maxed out ages ago (1-2 years ago) if the chat forum counted towards those badges.
(edited 10 months ago)

Reply 3

Original post
by Talkative Toad
The rest of the chat forum works fine, it’s specifically forum games for some reason where it doesn’t count so I’m wondering if that’s something that’s gone unnoticed rather than intentional design.
I can understand why specific forums are excluded but it does make the naming of the badge misleading if that’s the case (for the chatterbox badge, you’d think that the chat forum of all forums should count towards the badge, an unanswered thread is an unanswered thread regardless of the forum etc).
Yeah some badges like the chatter box badge and homebird badge I would have maxed out ages ago (1-2 years ago) if the chat forum counter towards those badges.

I've double checked on our test environment and replying first to a forum games thread wasn't counted for the First badge. I'll ask the dev team why. I can't see why there would be a bug with that forum specifically but you're right that it seems an odd choice to intentionally exclude it :dontknow:

Reply 4

Original post
by PurpleAndGreen
I've double checked on our test environment and replying first to a forum games thread wasn't counted for the First badge. I'll ask the dev team why. I can't see why there would be a bug with that forum specifically but you're right that it seems an odd choice to intentionally exclude it :dontknow:

Yeah if it was the whole of chat it still wouldn’t make sense imo but I’d say ah ok it’s that kind of badge again, but for some reason it’s only forum games so yeah.

I do hope that this restriction on badges are lifted one day (or that there’s clear information given to users that certain forums won’t count towards certain badges) as it doesn’t make sense to keep it imo.

Reply 5

Original post
by PurpleAndGreen
Hi. I think we looked at this before and there are some forums that don't count toward the badge. I'll ask someone to double check though. I'm not sure why specific forums would be excluded from badges. Thanks for letting us know 🙂

That's correct, Forum Games is explicitly excluded from that badge, though it's the only section that is. I suspect because it's unlikely that a thread from that forum would fall under "questions you can help answer", whereas threads in Chat very well might. Just a theory on my part though :tongue:

Reply 6

Original post
by RainbowLapras
That's correct, Forum Games is explicitly excluded from that badge, though it's the only section that is. I suspect because it's unlikely that a thread from that forum would fall under "questions you can help answer", whereas threads in Chat very well might. Just a theory on my part though :tongue:


Is there any reason why chat is excluded from the chatterbox badge (doesn’t make sense given the name) then or why chat is excluded from the home bird (somewhat makes sense) one?

Reply 7

Original post
by Talkative Toad
Is there any reason why chat is excluded from the chatterbox badge (doesn’t make sense given the name) then or why chat is excluded from the home bird (somewhat makes sense) one?

Probably just a historic thing, rather than any current reasoning! I suspect longer term it would make sense to include Chat in both of those, but continue excluding Forum Games :beard:

Reply 8

Original post
by RainbowLapras
Probably just a historic thing, rather than any current reasoning! I suspect longer term it would make sense to include Chat in both of those, but continue excluding Forum Games :beard:


I don’t see why forum games should be excluded honestly given that a lot of chat happens in LPTPHWs (it has effectively replaced The Ultimate Chat Thread it looks like it) but fair.

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.