The Student Room Group

a christmas carol paragraph

hiya, would it be okay if someone could have a quick read through of this and give me some pointers? it isn't a full essay but just a small paragraph. if theres any quotes/ideas you think i could add, or any ways i could structure it differently, it'd be a huge help if you could tell me. thank you!!

Screenshot 2025-04-01 171544.png

Reply 1

Original post by chaoscontrol
hiya, would it be okay if someone could have a quick read through of this and give me some pointers? it isn't a full essay but just a small paragraph. if theres any quotes/ideas you think i could add, or any ways i could structure it differently, it'd be a huge help if you could tell me. thank you!!
Screenshot 2025-04-01 171544.png

Hey! i didnt do christmas carol for gcse but i have read it and i got a 9 for english lit so hopefully i can help.

firstly, my teachers always taught me to refrain from starting sentences with "this" as much as possible as it's a bit vague and can be replaced by something better. Or at least write "this [blank]..." like you did with "this quotation" so it's less vague. For example, instead of "this clearly contrast..." you could write something like "Scrooge's newfound appreciation for the holiday contrasts..." or "His promise to "honour christmas" contrasts..", as currently it's unclear if "this" refers to the first or second quotation - also it helps to get a little more analysis in.

My second tip would be to zoom in on your quotations to explain the points that you are drawing from them better. For example, you claim that scrooge now sees christmas as a joyous time but didn't explain how that is shown by the quotation. Even though it may seem obvious, it's important to draw clear connections between your quotes and the points that you are making, and zooming in on particular words in the quotes can help you do this. For examle, you could zoom in on the word "heart" and connect it to love or a source of life which shows the great importance of the holiday to scrooge.

Final pointer is to try to incorporate context into the paragraph instead of tacking it onto the end almost as an afterthought. You could introduce the idea of scrooge's past attitude being similar to that of victorian society earlier in the paragraph, then link back to it in the end with Dicken's message

Overall, your point and the quotes you chose are good and make sense for the question, and the addition of context is great but maybe try to add more detail. Hope this helps, let me know if you want any more pointers.

Reply 2

Hi there, A level Literature student here
In the intro you need to be more specific about what u mean by changes his ways: so like he changes from miserly to selfless and friendly
Also if u have 3 main points in mind get that in too. Also if you can recall the date of the books publiation then putting that in can also boost marks for the A03
In the paragraph. you can blend the 2 sentences together to make it flow and save time So: In the extract, Scrooge promises to the Ghost of Christmas past that he will honour christmas in his heart....
We need to analyse the quote itself being specific about what the writer does... We need to know why it highlights his redemption so: Dickens use of this metaphor shows his sincerity towards his moral transformation.

You can either use the quote you selected and argue that: this juxtaposese scrooges intital presentation where he snidely comments "That's a poor excuse for picking a mans pocket every 25th of december.This financial language shows scrooge is only concerned with his own greed and presumes any sort of charity is criminal. Dickens uses this moral depravity to emphasise the extent of his redemption catalysed by the novellas events. Scrooge also gains a redemption of faith, going from the indifferent description of ‘every 25th of December’ to the recognition of ‘christmas’ as something to be honoured

Or if you can remember another quote, you could use "No warmth could warm him ,nor wintery weather chill" (from page 3) As you can comment on both the Alliteration of W and the repitition of No. So for instance, you could say: Dickens use of repetition here emphasises to readers how unwilling to change Scrooge is showing the significance of when he finally does change. The alliteration of 'W' creates a dramatic tone showing how the omnicient narrator could be seen as mocking Scrooge for his beliefs and by extenstion the Victorian Upper class that Scrooge represent
Your paragraph stucture is good and the bit at the end about the symbolism is great! You have strong AO1 - that the point you make- and A03 - context- this forms the base of a really good essay its just about expanding and being really detailed and specific about what you're saying, Hope that helped and good luck with your GCSE's

Quick Reply