I personally chose St Andrews! You get to spend time in both a rural and urban environment (for yrs 4-6), and I think you also get personal tutoring in small groups (similar to Oxbridge). You will still get to study in an Urban environment later as, from what I heard, most students later go to Edinburgh and Glasgow for their last years (for Scottish and no preference route. So, overall, you get to experience two different locations (the beach and the city). gardaute twice (once from St Andrews and once from the other university). Regardless, focusing on opportunity and personal preferences, these were the appealing factors for me to go into St Andrews! Let me know if you have any questions!