The Student Room Group

Gcse essay mark

Hi please can someone assess what grade id be at and what I can improve on
Thanks
How is appearance vs reality presented in Macbeth essay?
In Shakespeare's Macbeth, the theme appearance vs reality is presented throughout the play highlighting the deceptive nature of power, ambition and morality.
At the start of the play, we are introduced to the three witches, who play a crucial part in the theme Appearance vs reality. In act 1, scene 1 they end their meeting with the unusual statement '"Fair is foul and foul is fair Hover through the fog and filthy air." The paradoxical statement foreshadows the events that will unfold in the play. The imagery of 'Hover' and 'air' is an example of the unsettling nature of the Witches' world that is brought wherever they go.
In Act 1 Scene 3 Banquo and Macbeth have an encounter with the witches and Banquo questions, "Are ye fantastical, or that indeed which outwardly ye show?" This shows that Banquo is unsure whether the witches or their prophecies are true which suggests the difficulty of distinguishing between what is real and what is not.
After the witches vanish, Macbeth is baffled and says, "Into the air, and what seemed corporal melted, as breath into the wind." The witches, who initially appear to have physical bodies vanish into the air suggesting that what seems real or tangible can be illusory or fleeting. The simile "as breath into the wind" is a powerful image that reflects the ephemeral nature of the Witches existence.
Appearance vs reality is commented throughout the play when Duncan claims, "There's no art to find the minds construction in the face" when he was betrayed by the Thane of Cawdor. Duncan says that people may seem good and trustworthy but they might not be. The irony here is striking; Duncan misjudges Macbeth who outwardly appears loyal but internally harbors ambition and treachery.
As the play progresses, Lady Macbeth advises Macbeth to "look like the innocent flower but be the serpent under't." This stark juxtaposition reveals Lady Macbeth's understanding of the necessity to mask true intentions beneath a facade of innocence. Her manipulative counsel demonstrates the lengths to which individuals will go to hide their ambition.
When Duncan is killed, Donalbain realises that "there's daggers in men's smiles". The noun dagger suggests that there is hidden danger and malicious intent behind the friendly faces. This idea resonates with Lady Macbeth's earlier exhortation, reinforcing the notion that appearances can be dangerously misleading.
Towards the end of the play Malcolm says, "Angels are bright still, though the brightest fell." This biblical allusion to Lucifer encapsulates the complexity of the theme, suggesting that even within the darkest of circumstances, goodness can still exist. This reflects Malcolms' cautious yet hopeful view of humanity.
To conclude Shakespeare effectively presents the idea of appearance vs reality and to not easily trust everyone just because they outwardly seem noble.

Reply 1

Original post
by unknown_2269
Hi please can someone assess what grade id be at and what I can improve on
Thanks
How is appearance vs reality presented in Macbeth essay?
In Shakespeare's Macbeth, the theme appearance vs reality is presented throughout the play highlighting the deceptive nature of power, ambition and morality.
At the start of the play, we are introduced to the three witches, who play a crucial part in the theme Appearance vs reality. In act 1, scene 1 they end their meeting with the unusual statement '"Fair is foul and foul is fair Hover through the fog and filthy air." The paradoxical statement foreshadows the events that will unfold in the play. The imagery of 'Hover' and 'air' is an example of the unsettling nature of the Witches' world that is brought wherever they go.
In Act 1 Scene 3 Banquo and Macbeth have an encounter with the witches and Banquo questions, "Are ye fantastical, or that indeed which outwardly ye show?" This shows that Banquo is unsure whether the witches or their prophecies are true which suggests the difficulty of distinguishing between what is real and what is not.
After the witches vanish, Macbeth is baffled and says, "Into the air, and what seemed corporal melted, as breath into the wind." The witches, who initially appear to have physical bodies vanish into the air suggesting that what seems real or tangible can be illusory or fleeting. The simile "as breath into the wind" is a powerful image that reflects the ephemeral nature of the Witches existence.
Appearance vs reality is commented throughout the play when Duncan claims, "There's no art to find the minds construction in the face" when he was betrayed by the Thane of Cawdor. Duncan says that people may seem good and trustworthy but they might not be. The irony here is striking; Duncan misjudges Macbeth who outwardly appears loyal but internally harbors ambition and treachery.
As the play progresses, Lady Macbeth advises Macbeth to "look like the innocent flower but be the serpent under't." This stark juxtaposition reveals Lady Macbeth's understanding of the necessity to mask true intentions beneath a facade of innocence. Her manipulative counsel demonstrates the lengths to which individuals will go to hide their ambition.
When Duncan is killed, Donalbain realises that "there's daggers in men's smiles". The noun dagger suggests that there is hidden danger and malicious intent behind the friendly faces. This idea resonates with Lady Macbeth's earlier exhortation, reinforcing the notion that appearances can be dangerously misleading.
Towards the end of the play Malcolm says, "Angels are bright still, though the brightest fell." This biblical allusion to Lucifer encapsulates the complexity of the theme, suggesting that even within the darkest of circumstances, goodness can still exist. This reflects Malcolms' cautious yet hopeful view of humanity.
To conclude Shakespeare effectively presents the idea of appearance vs reality and to not easily trust everyone just because they outwardly seem noble.
I'm not sure what mark this could get but I can suggest improvements

Overall, I think to improve you should try to zoom in more with your analysis, really taking the time to pick apart quotes. For example, for Lady M's quote you could zoom into the words "flower" and "serpent" and explore their connotations and what that reveals about her intentions. Also, I think your overall structure could be improved as currently, you veer a bit close to retelling rather than analysing. While organising points chronologically can be good, it's also important to have some overarching points that tie the quotations and analysis together so the points you are making are more clear.

My biggest tip for you would be to structure your essays around 3 main points, with each point having one paragraph. I'd start each paragraph with a clear topic sentence outlining the main point of the paragraph, and end each one with a clear link to the question, this will help organise the points better, because your points are great they just could do with being a bit more structured. For example, your opening sentences could be:

1.

Shakespeare introduces the theme of appearance Vs reality through the paradoxical nature of the witches speech and appearance.

2.

Lady Macbeth weaponizes the trust others place in her and Macbeth by hiding their true plans under a facade of good

3.

Shakespeare shows how some characters can see through the masks others place, seeing their true intentions.

All of the points in your essay could fit into these paragraphs well, and it would demonstrate your ability to connect different points of the play.

Hope this helps!

Reply 2

Thank you so much!

Quick Reply