The Student Room Group

URGENT- expelled academic misconduct appeal

Hi everyone,

I was recently expelled for academic misconduct. My initial mitigating circumstances weren’t accepted because they were submitted late, but the truth is, I was dealing with serious health issues and genuinely wasn’t able to apply back then.

I’ve now submitted an appeal with new mitigating circumstances, including fresh medical evidence from my psychiatrist that wasn’t available at the time because my diagnosis and treatment were still in progress.

I’m in a much better place now and I’ve been honest and taken full accountability. I just really want a second chance to turn things around.

Has anyone been in a similar situation? Do appeals like this ever work?

Reply 1

Doubtful tbh, if it's been serious enough to warrant expulsion they might not care how it happened or feel a second chance is appropriate :/

Am I right in thinking this appeal is to explain WHY you committed misconduct, rather than denying the actual accusation?

Reply 2

Original post
by StriderHort
Doubtful tbh, if it's been serious enough to warrant expulsion they might not care how it happened or feel a second chance is appropriate :/
Am I right in thinking this appeal is to explain WHY you committed misconduct, rather than denying the actual accusation?


Yeah, you’re right I’m not denying what happened at all. The appeal is to explain why it happened and to provide context that wasn’t available at the time. I made a mistake, and I’ve fully owned up to it.

At my uni, the regulations state that if there are valid mitigating circumstances, expulsion isn’t supposed to be the outcome but because my evidence was post-dated, it wasn’t taken into account originally. Now that I’ve submitted proper medical evidence from my psychiatrist, I’m hoping they’ll reconsider.

I know it’s a serious situation, but I’ve worked hard to get to a better place, and I’m just asking for the chance to move forward.
@gjd800 might be able to offer some advice if they are around.

Reply 4

I've seen an appeal like this succeed, yes. In fact I had three students from the same (large) cohort who faced similar circumstances and all three returned to see out their degree.

So it's not hopeless.

The fact you have actually medical evidence from a specislist is the biggest boon, and I think that if the only hangup to this was late MCs which, had they been submitted on time, would otherwise have been accepted, then I'd be quietly hopeful.

Second offence complicates things slightly, but I'd not be overly concerned about that.

We can never be sure with these things, but, all things being equal, you have as good of a chance as it is possible to have.

Reply 5

Original post
by gjd800
I've seen an appeal like this succeed, yes. In fact I had three students from the same (large) cohort who faced similar circumstances and all three returned to see out their degree.
So it's not hopeless.
The fact you have actually medical evidence from a specislist is the biggest boon, and I think that if the only hangup to this was late MCs which, had they been submitted on time, would otherwise have been accepted, then I'd be quietly hopeful.
Second offence complicates things slightly, but I'd not be overly concerned about that.
We can never be sure with these things, but, all things being equal, you have as good of a chance as it is possible to have.


Thank you so much for your answer!! I’ve sent you a DM could you please check it. Thanks

Reply 6

Original post
by Anonymous
Thank you so much for your answer!! I’ve sent you a DM could you please check it. Thanks

Sorry, after unsavoury encounters with other users, I do not reply to DMs. Better to air everything where it can be seen.

Reply 7

Original post
by gjd800
Sorry, after unsavoury encounters with other users, I do not reply to DMs. Better to air everything where it can be seen.


Oh okay no problem, I was just going to ask that the 2 academic misconduct were ok the same period… idk if that is going to affect the appeal, my uni is in Russel group so I’m afraid they gonna be stricter

Reply 8

Original post
by Anonymous
Oh okay no problem, I was just going to ask that the 2 academic misconduct were ok the same period… idk if that is going to affect the appeal, my uni is in Russel group so I’m afraid they gonna be stricter

If they were in the same session then it might actually add weight to your mitigation claim: two in succession, out of character, because of x y and z reason, that sort of thing.

For what it's worth, I've worked in RG institutions for more than ten years and in my experience, there's little difference between institutions in how 'strictly' policies are applied. You really need to be scraping the barrel at the poorest places before you see any real difference, so I'd not get too hung up on that side of things.

It's hard because you're in a sort of limbo, but I really think you're in as good a position as it is possible to be in at this stage. The nature of these claims and appeals are somewhat unpredictable so I don't want to give you false hope. But I have seen comparable circunstances pan out, as recently as last year.
(edited 7 months ago)

Reply 9

Original post
by gjd800
If they were in the same session then it might actually add weight to your mitigation claim: two in succession, out of character, because of x y and z reason, that sort of thing.
For what it's worth, I've worked in RG institutions for more than ten years and in my experience, there's little difference between institutions in how 'strictly' policies are applied. You really need to be scraping the barrel at the poorest places before you see any real difference, so I'd not get too hung up on that side of things.
It's hard because you're in a sort of limbo, but I really think you're in as good a position as it is possible to be in at this stage. The nature of these claims and appeals are somewhat unpredictable so I don't want to give you false hope. But I have seen comparable circunstances pan out, as recently as last year.


Thank you so so much for your reply!! I’m really thinking about the appeal so so much and stressing about the outcome… I’m so nervous and feel that I’ve worked on myself these couple months so much academically and mentally… I’ve improved and grown and I’m in a better place… I’ve write these in my appeal and I’m really hoping that it will succeed :/

Reply 10

Original post
by Anonymous
Thank you so so much for your reply!! I’m really thinking about the appeal so so much and stressing about the outcome… I’m so nervous and feel that I’ve worked on myself these couple months so much academically and mentally… I’ve improved and grown and I’m in a better place… I’ve write these in my appeal and I’m really hoping that it will succeed :/

Hey, I can really feel how much this means to you, and honestly, it’s clear you’ve done a huge amount of work on yourself, both mentally and academically. That takes real strength, and I hope you're giving yourself some credit for how far you’ve come.
I know how heavy the wait can feel, especially when you've put your heart into the appeal. But you’re not alone in this. If you’d like, feel free to send over your appeal, I’d be more than happy to help you proofread it and make sure it’s as strong and clear as possible. You deserve a fair chance at moving forward.

Reply 11

Did it succeed or is OP cooked💀💀💀

Reply 12

Original post
by gjd800
If they were in the same session then it might actually add weight to your mitigation claim: two in succession, out of character, because of x y and z reason, that sort of thing.
For what it's worth, I've worked in RG institutions for more than ten years and in my experience, there's little difference between institutions in how 'strictly' policies are applied. You really need to be scraping the barrel at the poorest places before you see any real difference, so I'd not get too hung up on that side of things.
It's hard because you're in a sort of limbo, but I really think you're in as good a position as it is possible to be in at this stage. The nature of these claims and appeals are somewhat unpredictable so I don't want to give you false hope. But I have seen comparable circunstances pan out, as recently as last year.


When I contacted the student union, they told me that I have a reasonable case.
I’m just so scared and not ready for a rejection. I feel like I’ve worked on myself so much, and that the mistake I made was genuinely beyond my control.

When I had the first hearing with the school, my therapist was my main health provider at the time. I didn’t address the psychiatrist’s diagnosis because it simply wasn’t available yet psychiatric diagnoses require multiple sessions and treatments over time.

Six months later, when I had a hearing with the committee, I still didn’t mention the psychiatrist’s diagnosis. I focused mainly on showing that I was a changed person and that I had grown a lot.

Now, in my appeal, I submitted this new medical evidence, but I’m so scared they’re going to reject it on the basis that I had time and didn’t inform the committee earlier. But the truth is, the psychiatric evidence was genuinely not available at that stage, and I made sure to explain this clearly in my appeal.

I don’t know if anyone has been through something similar. I’m sorry I just can’t stop thinking about the appeal. I’m so stressed :frown:

Reply 13

Original post
by gjd800
I've seen an appeal like this succeed, yes. In fact I had three students from the same (large) cohort who faced similar circumstances and all three returned to see out their degree.
So it's not hopeless.
The fact you have actually medical evidence from a specislist is the biggest boon, and I think that if the only hangup to this was late MCs which, had they been submitted on time, would otherwise have been accepted, then I'd be quietly hopeful.
Second offence complicates things slightly, but I'd not be overly concerned about that.
We can never be sure with these things, but, all things being equal, you have as good of a chance as it is possible to have.


@gjd800 When I contacted the student union, they told me that I have a reasonable case.
I'm just so scared and not ready for a rejection. I feel like I've worked on myself so much, and that the mistake I made was genuinely beyond my control.
When I had the first hearing with the school, my therapist was my main health provider at the time. I didn't address the psychiatrist's diagnosis because it simply wasn't available yet psychiatric diagnoses require multiple sessions and treatments over time.
Six months later, when I had a hearing with the committee, I still didn't mention the psychiatrist's diagnosis. I focused mainly on showing that I was a changed person
I and that I
had grown a lot.
Now, in my appeal, I submitted this new medical evidence, but I'm so scared they're going to reject it on the basis that I had time and didn't inform the committee earlier. But the truth is, the psychiatric evidence was genuinely not available at that stage, and I made sure to explain this clearly in my appeal.
I don't know if anyone has been through something similar.
I'm sorry I just can't stop thinking about the appeal. I'm so stressed :frown:

Reply 14

Quick update the appeal WORKED!!! BUT they gave me a condition to redo the WHOLE year with everything capped at 40, should I take it to the OIA or accept the offer ??

Reply 15

Original post
by Anonymous
Quick update the appeal WORKED!!! BUT they gave me a condition to redo the WHOLE year with everything capped at 40, should I take it to the OIA or accept the offer ??

Personally I'd take the win here. Very unlikely the OIA will force a better result and all considered, this is actually a good result without the misconduct etc, so in the light of that, fantastic result. Well done!

Reply 16

Original post
by gjd800
Personally I'd take the win here. Very unlikely the OIA will force a better result and all considered, this is actually a good result without the misconduct etc, so in the light of that, fantastic result. Well done!


Thank you !! The conditions were super harsh tho everything capped at 40 and if I fail any module I can’t resit I’ll be directly expelled do u think it’s worth taking it to the OIA, accepting it or transferring to another uni ?

Reply 17

Original post
by gjd800
Personally I'd take the win here. Very unlikely the OIA will force a better result and all considered, this is actually a good result without the misconduct etc, so in the light of that, fantastic result. Well done!


I also wanted to say thank you so much! You were the only person who gave me hope and told me it might actually succeed. Everyone else kept saying it was impossible and that it’s so rare for an appeal to work.

Reply 18

Original post
by Anonymous
Thank you !! The conditions were super harsh tho everything capped at 40 and if I fail any module I can’t resit I’ll be directly expelled do u think it’s worth taking it to the OIA, accepting it or transferring to another uni ?

I think those conditions are fair given the circumstances, but ultimately it is up to you. I really do think that this is a big win.

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.