The Student Room Group

Can someone 🙏 help me answer this alevel business question

An ice cream seller has two options to expand their business for the summer season (June-September inclusive)

Option 1: Rent an ice cream van for £4,000. This is expected to generate net cash flows of £1,500 in June, increasing by 20% each month until September.

Option 2: Rent a beach shack for £6,000. This extends the season to October. Net cash flows are expected to be £2,500 per month, except for October, when they'll fall by 1/5.

Calculate the monthly Average Rate of Return (ARR) for each option.

Reply 1

Original post
by rushing-interpla
An ice cream seller has two options to expand their business for the summer season (June-September inclusive)
Option 1: Rent an ice cream van for £4,000. This is expected to generate net cash flows of £1,500 in June, increasing by 20% each month until September.
Option 2: Rent a beach shack for £6,000. This extends the season to October. Net cash flows are expected to be £2,500 per month, except for October, when they'll fall by 1/5.
Calculate the monthly Average Rate of Return (ARR) for each option.

I am no business person, but is this just simple maths?

The van is going to cost £1000 a month over four months. The shack will cost £1200 each month over five months. Then the first will bring in £1500, then £1500 + 20% then £1500 + 20% etc for four months - you do the maths! The second will bring in £2500 each month and in October a fifth of that - you do the maths.

According to google, RoR = ( (Final Value - Initial Value) / Initial Value ) * 100

So there we go. Now if you have listened in lessons, the rest should be simple no?

Reply 2

Original post
by hotpud
I am no business person, but is this just simple maths?
The van is going to cost £1000 a month over four months. The shack will cost £1200 each month over five months. Then the first will bring in £1500, then £1500 + 20% then £1500 + 20% etc for four months - you do the maths! The second will bring in £2500 each month and in October a fifth of that - you do the maths.
According to google, RoR = ( (Final Value - Initial Value) / Initial Value ) * 100
So there we go. Now if you have listened in lessons, the rest should be simple no?

Appreciate the reply and thank you for trying to help me ( it means alot ), but I do actually get the maths it’s the business side of the ARR I need help with. Like, I’ve done all the calculations properly (my teacher even got the same answer as me for Option 1), and I think my figures are right. It’s just when I go to actually calculate the ARR, I get one answer, ChatGPT gets another,i am not able to contact my teacher and now I’ve got 12.5% for Option 2 but I don’t know if that’s correct or if I’ve misunderstood something as the method i used to get option 1 isn't replicable .

And as I recall... you don’t even do business, do you? 😅 So yeah, I did listen in lesson, I’m just struggling to revise it all and figure out if I’ve got this question right so I can finally move on with the rest of my business revision.Anywhooo Thank u soo much for the reply 😂

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.