Hey I’m a current Aidan’s student, please do not bin your offer!
I believe Aidan’s gets an unfair rep because not a lot of people know where it is, when in fact we are literally in the middle of the hill, across the road from most major hill colleges such as Mary’s, Trevs and Van Mildert, and only a 10-15 minute walk from the library and most lecture sites (much closer than the colleges right at the top of the hill like JoBo and Stephenson). Travel is easy enough, pretty much everywhere is within a 15-30 minute walk.
St Aidans genuinely has an extremely vibrant community that are constantly putting on communal events - for example, we are currently in exam season, and the college has been hosting daily wellbeing events such as communal crafts, meditation etc. Freshers week was also an extremely memorable as we got a packed itinerary, including events for both introverts like movie nights and quizzes and extroverts like group club visits. We have a large range of active sports societies as well. Plus as a catered college the shared dining hall has helped me make most of my friends, and the famous fancy dress formal is definitely a fan favourite Aidans tradition.
Aidan’s are also extremely big on diversity, with a large number of international students coming to stay. The college often proudly displays a rainbow flag outside and is hosting the hill college pride events this year. It also has a very active working class and first generation scholars society.
Also if nothing else, when I was touring students around they couldn’t stop commenting on how pretty the college was (google photos do not do it justice!) - we get tonnes of wildlife like ducks and rabbits, lots of wildflowers and very pretty views outside bedroom windows of the main quad.
I promise that most people come to be very proud of the college they get allocated, please do not let it sway your decision (Bailey colleges are usually further away from a lot of lectures anyway)