The Student Room Group

Question on Contacting Supervisors

Hi everyone! I'll be doing the MPhil in Political Thought and Intellectual History, and I'm so excited to get started!

I do have one pressing question though. It's quite long, so do bear with me.

After talking with one of my lecturers (who actually did the MPhil and administered it), we both kind of agreed that my dissertation proposal probably would not work and that I needed to change the focus of it (for reference, the proposal that I sent outlined a comparative dissertation between a 19th century and 20th century political thinker). This was on the grounds that I would probably struggle to write about what I proposed in 15,000 - 20,000 words (they were on maternity leave when I was doing my application, so I couldn't speak to them proper about the course until late April). I also realised I also decided to do something that was more closely related to my undergrad dissertation (which was on an 18th century political thinker), and I didn't want to write anything about 20th century intellectual thought.

With this in mind, I started doing some preliminary research for my dissertation, as I would like to get some research done before I arrive at Cambridge. I've been leaning more into the 19th century political thinker, and have ultimately decided my dissertation will be solely based on that thinker. My supervisor should still be able to supervise me, considering we briefly discussed about it when I met them last year, but it's obviously a big shift going from a comparative dissertation to focusing on one person. Furthermore, from the way my preliminary research has been going, it looks like my new dissertation will most likely incorporate a lot of 17th century political thought in lieu with the 19th century political thinker, which could bring up other issues (i.e.: needing a second supervisor)

Given all of this, I feel like it would be my best interest to tell my supervisor about my change of plans before I arrive at Cambridge in September. I know that supervisors are busy around this time of year, so if I were to email my supervisor about my change of plans, it would be around mid - July (hopefully by this time my place at Cambridge has been confirmed). How should I go about this? Is it even ok for me to make such a drastic switch on my dissertation topic (which is what I'm most worried about)? Or would it be better to just hold things off until I meet my supervisor in September, and I have to submit the final proposal?
Original post
by AriTahira
Hi everyone! I'll be doing the MPhil in Political Thought and Intellectual History, and I'm so excited to get started!
I do have one pressing question though. It's quite long, so do bear with me.
After talking with one of my lecturers (who actually did the MPhil and administered it), we both kind of agreed that my dissertation proposal probably would not work and that I needed to change the focus of it (for reference, the proposal that I sent outlined a comparative dissertation between a 19th century and 20th century political thinker). This was on the grounds that I would probably struggle to write about what I proposed in 15,000 - 20,000 words (they were on maternity leave when I was doing my application, so I couldn't speak to them proper about the course until late April). I also realised I also decided to do something that was more closely related to my undergrad dissertation (which was on an 18th century political thinker), and I didn't want to write anything about 20th century intellectual thought.
With this in mind, I started doing some preliminary research for my dissertation, as I would like to get some research done before I arrive at Cambridge. I've been leaning more into the 19th century political thinker, and have ultimately decided my dissertation will be solely based on that thinker. My supervisor should still be able to supervise me, considering we briefly discussed about it when I met them last year, but it's obviously a big shift going from a comparative dissertation to focusing on one person. Furthermore, from the way my preliminary research has been going, it looks like my new dissertation will most likely incorporate a lot of 17th century political thought in lieu with the 19th century political thinker, which could bring up other issues (i.e.: needing a second supervisor)
Given all of this, I feel like it would be my best interest to tell my supervisor about my change of plans before I arrive at Cambridge in September. I know that supervisors are busy around this time of year, so if I were to email my supervisor about my change of plans, it would be around mid - July (hopefully by this time my place at Cambridge has been confirmed). How should I go about this? Is it even ok for me to make such a drastic switch on my dissertation topic (which is what I'm most worried about)? Or would it be better to just hold things off until I meet my supervisor in September, and I have to submit the final proposal?

No point. Many people change their dissertation, that's why it's discussed in the application phase, but not usually fixed until after Christmas. Not much point in getting ahead, the timings are there and that's sufficient time and what Cam staff are scheduled to support. Speak to your Supervisor during the first week or two of term and you've got until around Jan/Feb to finalise.

Reply 2

Original post
by threeportdrift
No point. Many people change their dissertation, that's why it's discussed in the application phase, but not usually fixed until after Christmas. Not much point in getting ahead, the timings are there and that's sufficient time and what Cam staff are scheduled to support. Speak to your Supervisor during the first week or two of term and you've got until around Jan/Feb to finalise.

Thanks so much! That definitely helps a lot.

Reply 3

Original post
by AriTahira
Hi everyone! I'll be doing the MPhil in Political Thought and Intellectual History, and I'm so excited to get started!
I do have one pressing question though. It's quite long, so do bear with me.
After talking with one of my lecturers (who actually did the MPhil and administered it), we both kind of agreed that my dissertation proposal probably would not work and that I needed to change the focus of it (for reference, the proposal that I sent outlined a comparative dissertation between a 19th century and 20th century political thinker). This was on the grounds that I would probably struggle to write about what I proposed in 15,000 - 20,000 words (they were on maternity leave when I was doing my application, so I couldn't speak to them proper about the course until late April). I also realised I also decided to do something that was more closely related to my undergrad dissertation (which was on an 18th century political thinker), and I didn't want to write anything about 20th century intellectual thought.
With this in mind, I started doing some preliminary research for my dissertation, as I would like to get some research done before I arrive at Cambridge. I've been leaning more into the 19th century political thinker, and have ultimately decided my dissertation will be solely based on that thinker. My supervisor should still be able to supervise me, considering we briefly discussed about it when I met them last year, but it's obviously a big shift going from a comparative dissertation to focusing on one person. Furthermore, from the way my preliminary research has been going, it looks like my new dissertation will most likely incorporate a lot of 17th century political thought in lieu with the 19th century political thinker, which could bring up other issues (i.e.: needing a second supervisor)
Given all of this, I feel like it would be my best interest to tell my supervisor about my change of plans before I arrive at Cambridge in September. I know that supervisors are busy around this time of year, so if I were to email my supervisor about my change of plans, it would be around mid - July (hopefully by this time my place at Cambridge has been confirmed). How should I go about this? Is it even ok for me to make such a drastic switch on my dissertation topic (which is what I'm most worried about)? Or would it be better to just hold things off until I meet my supervisor in September, and I have to submit the final proposal?

If you are still uncertain and want to discuss it with them, just shoot them an email. Worst case they don't see it and you still have a chance to meet them properly once term begins.

Reply 4

Hey! I’m also doing political thought and intellectual history, and I also plan on changing my dissertation pretty radically from my proposal. I think it should still be fine with my supervisor, as he’s supervised PhD students in a variety of different topics in contemporary political philosophy and it’s even less relevant for MPhils. I think basically it’s totally ok to change topics, as unless you’re completely upending it from something like early modern thought to critical theory, then it doesn’t really matter how much your supervisor exactly fits at the masters level. Or at least I’m hoping so, because I don’t want to do the topic I wrote about on my proposal any more haha, I’ve thought of something much better. They must know that people will change a lottt from their final year of undergrad or a gap year to actually starting.

Reply 5

Original post
by Anonymous
Hey! I’m also doing political thought and intellectual history, and I also plan on changing my dissertation pretty radically from my proposal. I think it should still be fine with my supervisor, as he’s supervised PhD students in a variety of different topics in contemporary political philosophy and it’s even less relevant for MPhils. I think basically it’s totally ok to change topics, as unless you’re completely upending it from something like early modern thought to critical theory, then it doesn’t really matter how much your supervisor exactly fits at the masters level. Or at least I’m hoping so, because I don’t want to do the topic I wrote about on my proposal any more haha, I’ve thought of something much better. They must know that people will change a lottt from their final year of undergrad or a gap year to actually starting.

Hi there! Thanks for your answer - it's nice to have someone else on here who's about to do the same course.

If you're comfortable enough with it, maybe you can PM me and we can discuss this further. it would also be nice to know someone before the course commences 😁

Reply 6

Original post
by AriTahira
Hi everyone! I'll be doing the MPhil in Political Thought and Intellectual History, and I'm so excited to get started!
I do have one pressing question though. It's quite long, so do bear with me.
After talking with one of my lecturers (who actually did the MPhil and administered it), we both kind of agreed that my dissertation proposal probably would not work and that I needed to change the focus of it (for reference, the proposal that I sent outlined a comparative dissertation between a 19th century and 20th century political thinker). This was on the grounds that I would probably struggle to write about what I proposed in 15,000 - 20,000 words (they were on maternity leave when I was doing my application, so I couldn't speak to them proper about the course until late April). I also realised I also decided to do something that was more closely related to my undergrad dissertation (which was on an 18th century political thinker), and I didn't want to write anything about 20th century intellectual thought.
With this in mind, I started doing some preliminary research for my dissertation, as I would like to get some research done before I arrive at Cambridge. I've been leaning more into the 19th century political thinker, and have ultimately decided my dissertation will be solely based on that thinker. My supervisor should still be able to supervise me, considering we briefly discussed about it when I met them last year, but it's obviously a big shift going from a comparative dissertation to focusing on one person. Furthermore, from the way my preliminary research has been going, it looks like my new dissertation will most likely incorporate a lot of 17th century political thought in lieu with the 19th century political thinker, which could bring up other issues (i.e.: needing a second supervisor)
Given all of this, I feel like it would be my best interest to tell my supervisor about my change of plans before I arrive at Cambridge in September. I know that supervisors are busy around this time of year, so if I were to email my supervisor about my change of plans, it would be around mid - July (hopefully by this time my place at Cambridge has been confirmed). How should I go about this? Is it even ok for me to make such a drastic switch on my dissertation topic (which is what I'm most worried about)? Or would it be better to just hold things off until I meet my supervisor in September, and I have to submit the final proposal?

I'm jumping in here with a quick question, I’m about to start the PGDL and have been looking into applying to Cambridge for the MPhil in Political Thought and Intellectual History for next year.

I’m a Russell Group graduate with a low 2:1 in my undergraduate degree, and I’m just wondering realistically what my chances might be with that academic profile?

If any of you who’ve received offers wouldn’t mind sharing your undergraduate background (institution, class of degree, etc.), that would really help me understand the range of applicants they accept. Do you guys think realistically i have any chance at all??

Thanks so much in advance and good luck to everyone starting this September!

Reply 7

Original post
by AriTahira
Hi everyone! I'll be doing the MPhil in Political Thought and Intellectual History, and I'm so excited to get started!
I do have one pressing question though. It's quite long, so do bear with me.
After talking with one of my lecturers (who actually did the MPhil and administered it), we both kind of agreed that my dissertation proposal probably would not work and that I needed to change the focus of it (for reference, the proposal that I sent outlined a comparative dissertation between a 19th century and 20th century political thinker). This was on the grounds that I would probably struggle to write about what I proposed in 15,000 - 20,000 words (they were on maternity leave when I was doing my application, so I couldn't speak to them proper about the course until late April). I also realised I also decided to do something that was more closely related to my undergrad dissertation (which was on an 18th century political thinker), and I didn't want to write anything about 20th century intellectual thought.
With this in mind, I started doing some preliminary research for my dissertation, as I would like to get some research done before I arrive at Cambridge. I've been leaning more into the 19th century political thinker, and have ultimately decided my dissertation will be solely based on that thinker. My supervisor should still be able to supervise me, considering we briefly discussed about it when I met them last year, but it's obviously a big shift going from a comparative dissertation to focusing on one person. Furthermore, from the way my preliminary research has been going, it looks like my new dissertation will most likely incorporate a lot of 17th century political thought in lieu with the 19th century political thinker, which could bring up other issues (i.e.: needing a second supervisor)
Given all of this, I feel like it would be my best interest to tell my supervisor about my change of plans before I arrive at Cambridge in September. I know that supervisors are busy around this time of year, so if I were to email my supervisor about my change of plans, it would be around mid - July (hopefully by this time my place at Cambridge has been confirmed). How should I go about this? Is it even ok for me to make such a drastic switch on my dissertation topic (which is what I'm most worried about)? Or would it be better to just hold things off until I meet my supervisor in September, and I have to submit the final proposal?

Hey, just wondering if you were able to change your thesis topic after all? And whether that had any implications for supervision arrangements? I might be in the same boat so was wondering whether you could offer any advice as to how flexible things are once you are on the course.
(edited 3 months ago)
Original post
by mikehad92
Hey, just wondering if you were able to change your thesis topic after all? And whether that had any implications for supervision arrangements? I might be in the same boat so was wondering whether you could offer any advice as to how flexible things are once you are on the course.

They are very flexible. The get annoyed if you change from some obscure theme in your application to the most popular current subject because the appropriate Supervisors might already be full. But basically most dissertations change a bit, and changing within 'theme' is very common.

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.